Talk:Party Tent: Difference between revisions
(→Merge into Mario Party 8: Passed) |
|||
| (5 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
==Merge into ''[[Mario Party 8]]''== | ==Merge into ''[[Mario Party 8]]''== | ||
{{TPP}} | {{Settled TPP}} | ||
{{Proposal outcome|passed|8-0-0-0|merge}} | |||
Party Tent is the only dedicated Party Mode page we have on the wiki (at least to my knowledge). The page also looks shorter than some of the Party Mode ''sections'' of other games (like ''[[Mario Party 7]]'', whose Party Mode, or Party Cruise, is described in the ''Mario Party 7'' page, which is why I'm proposing to merge this with ''Mario Party 8'' rather than the [[Star Carnival]] page). Also, this is the only major mode in ''[[Mario Party 8]]'' (aside from the [[Fun Bazaar]], which is analogous to other shops in other ''[[Mario Party (series)|Mario Party]]'' games such as the [[Duty-Free Shop]], for which there are pages for) that actually has a page, as the Star Battle Arena, Minigame Tent, and Extras Zone are also sections. For these reasons (mostly this page being the only Party Mode page and major ''Mario Party 8'' mode page we have on the wiki), I'm proposing that this page be merged into ''Mario Party 8''. However, there might be some people who would want to keep this page, so I'm also adding options to make pages for Party Modes for other ''Mario Party'' games (relating to my first major reason, like {{Fake link|Party Cruise}}) and for other ''Mario Party 8'' modes (relating to my second major reason, like {{Fake link|Star Battle Arena}}), which I don't think are good ideas due to the similar lack of content for these pages, but there are some that would want those instead. | Party Tent is the only dedicated Party Mode page we have on the wiki (at least to my knowledge). The page also looks shorter than some of the Party Mode ''sections'' of other games (like ''[[Mario Party 7]]'', whose Party Mode, or Party Cruise, is described in the ''Mario Party 7'' page, which is why I'm proposing to merge this with ''Mario Party 8'' rather than the [[Star Carnival]] page). Also, this is the only major mode in ''[[Mario Party 8]]'' (aside from the [[Fun Bazaar]], which is analogous to other shops in other ''[[Mario Party (series)|Mario Party]]'' games such as the [[Duty-Free Shop]], for which there are pages for) that actually has a page, as the Star Battle Arena, Minigame Tent, and Extras Zone are also sections. For these reasons (mostly this page being the only Party Mode page and major ''Mario Party 8'' mode page we have on the wiki), I'm proposing that this page be merged into ''Mario Party 8''. However, there might be some people who would want to keep this page, so I'm also adding options to make pages for Party Modes for other ''Mario Party'' games (relating to my first major reason, like {{Fake link|Party Cruise}}) and for other ''Mario Party 8'' modes (relating to my second major reason, like {{Fake link|Star Battle Arena}}), which I don't think are good ideas due to the similar lack of content for these pages, but there are some that would want those instead. | ||
| Line 11: | Line 12: | ||
#{{User|SolemnStormcloud}} Per proposal. | #{{User|SolemnStormcloud}} Per proposal. | ||
#{{User|Ray Trace}} It's just a game mode. | #{{User|Ray Trace}} It's just a game mode. | ||
#{{User|ThePowerPlayer}} Considering the standard, this article is far too short not to be merged to the main article. | |||
#{{User|Technetium}} Per all. | |||
#{{User|Nintendo101}} Per proposal. | |||
#{{User|Super Mario RPG}} Per everyone. | |||
====Create pages for other ''Mario Party'' Party Modes==== | ====Create pages for other ''Mario Party'' Party Modes==== | ||
#{{User|Altendo}} Secondary choice. This at least makes it consistent with other ''Mario Party'' Party Modes, although I don't think a lot of information will be available for each of these new pages. | <s>#{{User|Altendo}} Secondary choice. This at least makes it consistent with other ''Mario Party'' Party Modes, although I don't think a lot of information will be available for each of these new pages.</s> | ||
====Create pages for other ''Mario Party 8'' modes==== | ====Create pages for other ''Mario Party 8'' modes==== | ||
#{{User|Altendo}} Tertiary choice. I don't really like this decision, as it would make ''Mario Party 8'' the only ''Mario Party'' game with dedicated mode pages, but it will at least make this page consistent with other ''Mario Party 8'' modes like the Star Battle Arena. | <s>#{{User|Altendo}} Tertiary choice. I don't really like this decision, as it would make ''Mario Party 8'' the only ''Mario Party'' game with dedicated mode pages, but it will at least make this page consistent with other ''Mario Party 8'' modes like the Star Battle Arena.</s> | ||
====Do nothing==== | ====Do nothing==== | ||
====Comments==== | ====Comments==== | ||
Latest revision as of 01:16, September 14, 2024
Merge into Mario Party 8[edit]
|
This talk page proposal has already been settled. Please do not edit this section or its subsections. If you wish to discuss the article, please do so in a new section below the proposal. |
merge 8-0-0-0
Party Tent is the only dedicated Party Mode page we have on the wiki (at least to my knowledge). The page also looks shorter than some of the Party Mode sections of other games (like Mario Party 7, whose Party Mode, or Party Cruise, is described in the Mario Party 7 page, which is why I'm proposing to merge this with Mario Party 8 rather than the Star Carnival page). Also, this is the only major mode in Mario Party 8 (aside from the Fun Bazaar, which is analogous to other shops in other Mario Party games such as the Duty-Free Shop, for which there are pages for) that actually has a page, as the Star Battle Arena, Minigame Tent, and Extras Zone are also sections. For these reasons (mostly this page being the only Party Mode page and major Mario Party 8 mode page we have on the wiki), I'm proposing that this page be merged into Mario Party 8. However, there might be some people who would want to keep this page, so I'm also adding options to make pages for Party Modes for other Mario Party games (relating to my first major reason, like Party Cruise) and for other Mario Party 8 modes (relating to my second major reason, like Star Battle Arena), which I don't think are good ideas due to the similar lack of content for these pages, but there are some that would want those instead.
Proposer: Altendo (talk)
Deadline: September 13, 2024, 23:59 GMT
Merge Party Tent into Mario Party 8[edit]
- Altendo (talk) Primary choice. I think it's best to make this consistent with both the Party Modes from other Mario Party games as well as other modes from Mario Party 8.
- Sparks (talk) The article is fairly short and I say a merge to the main game's article is harmless. Per Altendo.
- SolemnStormcloud (talk) Per proposal.
- Ray Trace (talk) It's just a game mode.
- ThePowerPlayer (talk) Considering the standard, this article is far too short not to be merged to the main article.
- Technetium (talk) Per all.
- Nintendo101 (talk) Per proposal.
- Super Mario RPG (talk) Per everyone.
Create pages for other Mario Party Party Modes[edit]
#Altendo (talk) Secondary choice. This at least makes it consistent with other Mario Party Party Modes, although I don't think a lot of information will be available for each of these new pages.
Create pages for other Mario Party 8 modes[edit]
#Altendo (talk) Tertiary choice. I don't really like this decision, as it would make Mario Party 8 the only Mario Party game with dedicated mode pages, but it will at least make this page consistent with other Mario Party 8 modes like the Star Battle Arena.
