MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive/13
MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive Template Mario Kart Name ChangesNO CHANGE 1-12 okay... I have noticed that all the articles on the wii karts all have their european names. Why? What's wrong with the american ones? They used to have american names! and so, I propose we change the article names... Deadline: March 3, 2009, 17:00 Change them
Leave them
CommentsIn accordance with a previous proposal, for six months following a given proposal, no proposals can be made to overturn it. For example, we just had the proposal to use European names for subjects which first appeared in games that were released in Europe first. It passed, and so, for the next six months, we can't make proposals to overturn it. Therefore, this proposal is invalid, but there's no way you could have been expected to know... sorry about this. Stumpers (talk)
Arend: Those aren't the Japanese names. o_O ToadetteAnime4evur (talk)
Personally, why the hell was it changed anyways? Doesn't that just screw things up for us Americans? :/ --The Blue Dragon (talk)
Change Six-Month Proposal Reversal Rule to 60 DaysALLOW REVERSAL OF PROPOSALS AFTER 60 DAYS 18-0 I recently learned of a rule that says proposals cannot be reversed for six months. However, six months seems like a ridiculously long wait, and some of these proposals really do need to be reversed. Simply, it only makes sense to change the limit to 60 days. Deadline: March 9, 2009, 17:00 Change limit
Leave as isCommentsLook at the proposal above! Ralphfan (talk)
Okay, we'll do it... and then change it back 60 days later! :D DoctorWho 1995 (talk) Create a Dispute Resolution CommitteeDON'T CREATE 0-6 So, I've been browsing Wookieepedia and have noticed they have a sysop's noticeboard. I think we should have something like this to alert sysops of important things and solve disputes between users. We would call this the "Dispute Resolution Committee". Proposer: Yoshario (talk) SupportOppose
CommentsI think we need this so regular users may alert sysops, since regular users do not have access to the sysop boards. Yoshario (talk)
Change Log-InNO CHANGES 3-8 1 hour ago I just had a horrible experience.My computer had somehow forgot my password for this Wiki,thus I took 1 hour trying to remember it,as I had lost the piece of paper the password was written on.So to stop this experience happening to anyone else,we could maybe have two options,like a question? Instead of a password? Are we allowed this? Do you want it? I'll be waiting! Proposer: Hyper Guy (talk) Something Different!
Leave as is!
CommentsIs the password thing something all Wikis HAVE to do? if it is,ignore this.Hyper Guy (talk) Hmmm... I'm not entirely sure I understand the proposal. Do you mean two accounts? That's what I think you are saying. Bloc Partier (talk)
Ok,I added an example.This IS my first proposal.Hyper Guy (talk) Courses based on CoursesMERGE THEM 2-14 Hey everyone it's User:MC Hammer Bro. again. This time I've noticed things like Super Smash Bros. stages and Mario Kart courses that share names with courses in games that they are based off of. Mainly I noticed how Article: Tick Tock Clock, course 14 in Super Mario 64 is seperate from Tick Tock Clock (course) but...Rainbow Ride from Super Mario 64 and Rainbow ride (Rainbow cruise) stage from Super Smash Bros. Melee are in the same articel. So my question is show the articles be merged or seperated? Proposer: MC Hammer Bro. (talk) Split 'em up
Merge 'em together
CommentsZafum: It will take you to both things, so i dont see whats wrong Tucayo (talk)
Idk, it just seems......as a "bad example" to new users.Who knows, probanly they'll say, "OMG y don't they put seperate articles 4 it!ZOMG they suck!!!lol.I'm leaving." or something like that.Ninja Yoshi (talk) Beta EnemiesMAKE BETA ENEMY PAGE 5-3 I dont know where to put this but here goes. I propose we create a page for all beta enemies, including stats, behavior, psychopath thoughts etc. Proposer: YourBuddyBill (talk) Make Beta Enemy Page
Do Not Make Beta Enemy Page
CommentsFixed. ;) And I would like to know all the stuff about them too, but separate pages for each enemy is rather tedious, in my opinion. Maybe not, but I would like it if we could know more about them. Bloc Partier (talk) Did Son of Suns vote in the wrong place? He said he wanted to keep separate pages; yet voted in do not make separate pages. Or am I reading it wrong? --Yoshario (talk)
sorry, the directions are a bit complicated 4 me YourBuddyBill (talk)
I do think that YBB has a point, though, since it does have to do with the beta enemy being notable or not. Plus, a list is always good as an easy directory for articles. Then again, a category would do that job also. Yoshario (talk) thing is, not every one HAS an article. theyre just meshed together on the beta elements page with tidbits on other pages YourBuddyBill (talk) Yoshario, I believe YBB is proposing to create ONE page to cover all Beta enemies, which right now have content in different places, not their own articles (nor is YBB proposing to give them each articles). Drill Bit is unique for being an enemy that appeared in the game but is also a beta enemy, as it was given stats but never used in battle. Hope that clears things up. -- Son of Suns (talk) So its not just a list, but an article that has the information on Beta Enemies instead of separate articles? I think that would be good. But then, would we still cover unused Drill Bit information in that article? --Yoshario (talk)
Alright, I like that idea, better remove my oppose. Yoshario (talk) Instead of creating another page, how about having a sub section in the Beta Elements page? They would classify in that category, but would things get a little too complicated? Super-Yoshi (talk) Arend: Are you sure you voted under the right header? Supporting means the enemies will get a page separate from the Beta Elements, but it sounds like you want them as part of the main Elements page only (which is the current policy, as far as I know)... - Walkazo (talk)
I have AR codes for a beta Red Koopa in Sm64ds!Not to mention beta hat boxes.Too bad my AR broke....Ninja Yoshi (talk) Worlds and levelsMERGE ARTICLES 7-6 YBB again, Im noticing that some games have all of the levels of a world on the world's page, like 7-1, 7-2, 7-3, and 7-4 are all on the same page as World 7, but with other games, worlds just have links to level pages, like Chocolate Island and Chocolate Secret. Should we merge them all together, or split them apart? Note that this is relevant to pipeprojects. Proposer: YourBuddyBill (talk) Merge
Split
CommentsUgh, this would destroy all my hard work to make Mt. Teapot Featured. But unfortunately it's a good idea. Blech. Kombatgod (talk) I think it is wrong thinking of merging or splitting everything. Like any other section in every page, if a section about a zone is too large, it'll need an article, if it fits well in the page of the world it'll remain a section. It is fool to have lots of stub pages just because we decided to split them all, or to have incredibly large articles just because we decided to merge. I think the only point is how long should a zone section be to become an article?
|