MarioWiki:Featured articles/N1/White Mage

White Mage

Support

1. Ashley and Red (talk) Is a great article, and describes the character (White Mage) perfectly, with no.need of huge sections, tables, etc. Also, I don't see flowery writing, spelling issues or things like that.

Oppose

1. Mario (talk) This article is way too short, comparable to Baby Donkey Kong, a successfully unfeatured article, and without sufficient padding, it's difficult to expand beyond this.
2. Yoshi876 (talk) Per Mario, the article is just too small. We failed Shigeru Miyamoto on size, and the article is smaller than that. The starting section is also too short.
3. Watcher of Game (talk) The article is often a target for trivial edits and constant undoing of edits. I feel it's not ready to be Featured yet.

Removal of Opposes

Watcher of a gamer

1. Ashley and Red (talk)Your oppose doesn't makes sense: Articles like Rosalina and Waluigi have this "problem"(lack of world) and they are featured.
2. Baby Luigi (talk) That doesn't matter. The undoing of those edits take practically less than a second and just two clicks so it's not an issue for us at all. Your oppose doesn't address the article's real problems and therefore it's invalid.

Comments

I can expand it by doing sections like clothing, phisical description, powers and abilities section. What do you think?User:Ashley anEoTselkie/sig

Most of it is already covered in the Mario Sports Mix section, so I think it's mostly restating what the article already offers. The biggest problem with White Mage is her appearances relating to the Mario series is extremely limited, and they're in only sports games. That's not enough to make the article substantial. It's me, Mario! (Talk / Stalk) 23:45, 26 April 2014 (EDT)