Talk:Whispy Woods
Merge Whispy Woods to Green Greens and Dream Land
Template:SettledTPP DON'T MERGE 11-16
Ever since the proposal of merging Ultimate Chimera, I thought about how Whispy Woods has its own article. So me and Reversinator decided it needed to be merged.
Proposer: Magikrazy51 (talk)
Deadline: March 29, 2011 23:59 GMT Delayed Extension (see below): May 11, 2011, 23:59 GMT
Support
Oppose
CommentsI don't think the article needs to be merged. The only portion that needs mentioning is the reference in the Club Nintendo comic. The rest can be deleted, as Whispy Woods is already mentioned as an environmental hazard in each of the stages in which he appears. Mario4Ever (talk)
Then why'd you support it, Bowser's Luma? Magikrazy51 (talk)
"The page will probably be deleted after the merge," - No, that's not how it works: even if all the links are updated, there's a good chance that people will still try to search for "Whispy Woods", and so it has to stay as a redirect, like how Ultimate Chimera is a redirect. - Walkazo 19:38, 21 March 2011 (EDT)
@Magikrazy51 it wouldnt make a stub if it had all the right info Goomba's Shoe15 (talk) Iv'e been thinking about it and maybe if this proposal passes, I'd put in Whispy Wood's trophy section and add a trivia section saying "Whispy Woods also appeared in Mario im Wunderland where he told Mario to see Crab, the wizard" or something along those lines. If this is a good enough mention of that comic, feel free to change. With a solution, The Magikrazy
But that's not consistant because he's not just some random stage hazard he's an independent character with independent appearances Goomba's Shoe15 (talk)
did Kraid appear in any other Mario related media cause im not trying to be sarcatstic i really have no idea Goomba's Shoe15 (talk)
Well i don't consider Nintendo Monopoly to be an official mario thing largely cause it's a board game with no real relation to Mario unlike Club Nintendo which has a real plot. Goomba's Shoe15 (talk)
However, it makes a short appearance in the Club Nintendo comic "Super Mario: Mario im Wunderland." Whispy Woods is the first creature Mario encounters in Wunderland when he accidently gets there. It does not serve as an enemy here, though; rather it advices Mario to go to Crab, a wizard who is able to fulfill desires. Also i might have surported this but every time Whispy woods appears it's in a different location never the same also you surported the opposed the Fish one why not this
No its not different why would you merge info into a location that has nothing to do with said location just because it's minor does not mean it should be merged Goomba's Shoe15 (talk) @Ratfink43 That's not a valid reason. The subject of this proposal has a trophy but was nevertheless merged. Mario4Ever (talk) how is his opinion that because something has a trophy any less valid it's his opinion on why he thinks something shouldnt be merged just because one talk page proposal says something does not make it the established rule of the wiki Goomba's Shoe15 (talk) I'm new, can I remove reasons that seem invalid? Magikrazy51 (talk)
Usually, when its merge to,the entire article doesnt get merged and simply deleted, Kirby9612 |
OK
So how do I do this? I'm new at these proposal things. Magikrazy51 (talk)
Well, this is unprecedented...
The proposal was marked as settled, removed from the list on the proposals page, and left alone. I looked through the revision history and found that Nicke8 voted after the deadline, but the margin would have been 9-8, so it should have been extended. Should we just change the template and such so it's active again, and mark the deadline as if it had just started, and been extended for a week? Bop1996 (Talk)
- I just asked a sysop, but he's not currently online. When he or another sysop is online, I'm sure we'll have a solution. It certainly is a peculiar situation given the amount of time that has passed since this was archived.... Mario4Ever (talk) 21:13, 3 May 2011 (EDT)
Prolly i noticed that right after it happened but like i said i misinterpeted the rules but yeah it shouls either be nullified and than re opened or it should just be re opened with the articles split Goomba's Shoe15 (talk)
Sorry, guys. This was my first proposal. I thought that if it wasn't a tie, but only one or so votes off, it should only be extended after 10 or more votes. I thought that meant 10 votes on side. Magikrazy51 (talk)