Category talk:Protectors of the Mushroom Kingdom

Wondering: Wouldn't this page and the Allies page be pretty much the same thing? Both of them contain people who have protected the Mushroom Kingdom at one time or another. Do you guys think we should merge them? --DarkInsanity (talk)

I think we should change this article to "Mushroom Kingdom" and only have characters (or species) that are directly affiliated with the Mushroom Kingdom in it (meaning characters from Rogueport or other lands should not be in this category, as they are not a part of the Mushroom Kingdom). Only characters like Peach, Mario, Luigi, Toad, Toadsworth, the Chancellor, and the like should be in this category. Other heroes or allies should go in the Allies category. Not all allies have protected the Mushroom Kingdom (such as the Kongs and the animal buddies). --Son of Suns 09:17, 12 June 2006 (EDT)

Add Mallow

If the page isn't merged, shouldn't Mallow be added? He did help protect the Mushroom Kingdom from Mack in SMRPG.

True. And why is Yoshi Kid on the list, when Paper Mario 2:TTYD doesn't even take place in the kingdom (Rogueport and the surrounding lands are their own region, after all)? The only sense I could see this holding sway is that Yoshi Kid helped save the world and, by extension, the Mushroom Kingdom itself, but then, wouldn't ALL allies who've helped save the world be included? I think this list could possibly stand to be a little more exclusive in that regard. Dinosaur bob 19:49, 14 May 2007 (EDT)