Talk:Nurse Toadstool

Ok, seriously. Who said the white color change for Princess Peach was Nurse Toadstool? It was obviously WEDDING PEACH from Super Paper Mario!
— The preceding unsigned comment was added by DarkLink (talk).

Except that Super Paper Mario wasn't released yet, so Wedding Peach didn't exist when Melee was released. So, yeah... How can I put this nicely? You've been owned? Master Lucario The Aura is with me...

Woah! Your right. Thanks
— The preceding unsigned comment was added by DarkLink (talk).

Merge Nurse Toadstool into Princess Peach

This talk page section contains an unresolved talk page proposal. Please try to help and resolve the issue by voting or leaving a comment.

Current time: Sunday, December 22, 2024, 22:05 GMT

Unlike the drty man (Dr. Mario), Nurse Toadstool has no major role or any special abilities that classify her different from her usual self. This is just an alternate costume of Peach. I say we merge her if she doesn't have anything unique other than the fancy costume to classify as a separate article.

Proposer: BabyLuigiOnFire (talk)
Voting start: 5 September, 2010, 23:04
Deadline: 18 September, 2010 23:59 GMT.

Support

1. BabyLuigiOnFire (talk) Per me, and Dr Man is one Drty Doctor.
2. GalacticPetey (talk) Per proposal and BLOF.
3. LeftyGreenMario (talk) Nurse Toadstool is Princess Peach in a different outfit unlike Drty.
4. T.c.w7468 (talk) Per all.
5. MrConcreteDonkey (talk) Unlike Dr. Mario, she is barely seen in the game and not notable enough for her own article; per all.
6. Zero777 (talk) I am Zero! Per all. Zero signing out.
7. GamingGal9 (talk) Nurse Toadstool is STILL Peach, just with a color swap and a different name. It's just a costume.
8. Garlic Stapler (talk) It's still Peach but with a color swap. Also article appears to be a stub. Not really that great of an article either. Just add it to the Peach page.
9. Mr bones (talk) Per my comment bellow. It's just a different outfit and it was proven to be Peach.
10. Fuzzipede27 (talk) I change my vote
11. Castle Toad (talk) - Peach as a nurse. Not another character, nor a powered up Peach
12. Fawfulfury65 (talk) Good. Princess Peach is at Dr. Mario's side as heard in SSBB (unless I misread the comments).
13. papermario97 (talk) Per all
14. Walkazo (talk) - Per FF65: SSBB is proof enough for me.

Oppose

1. Booderdash (talk) Why is Shrowser and Bowser seperate? And the babies from their adults?
2. Mileycyrussoulja (talk) If Dr. Mario gets his own article, then Nurse Toadstool should too. That's final.
3. mrblob1012 (talk) per all

Comments

If we merge these then why are Mario and Dr. Mario seperate? Superboo922

@Booderdash: Dr. Mario and Mario are shown to be different because they are both characters in SSBM.

Oh, and I want to know this: Is Nurse Toadstool actually confirmed to be Peach, or is she just a look a like? Fawfulfury65 (talk)

that's why I wanna know too. The article says the name is official, which means they refer to this "girl" as nurse toadstool in the comic I beleive.Count Bonsula I need blood...18:38, 5 September 2010 (UTC)

MCD, you support this because you think its not notable enough, and you oppose Lakitu Travel, who is not as notable as her, is not seen, which Nurse Toadstool clearly is seen, and where lakitu travel isn't EVER going to be in another game, while N.T will most definitly will. Thats very hypocritical. Boo der dash

Why do you compare Lakitu Travel and this? These are two different subjects. Mario^-HOHO! (Talk / Stalk) 21:50, 5 September 2010 (UTC)

@Booderdash Please, watch your language.Count Bonsula I need blood...21:53, 5 September 2010 (UTC)

@LGM, Because N.T is clearly more notable than Lakitu Travel, and MCD says that Lakitu Travel is notable for its own article, but N.T isn't. @Mr bones. I meant do make the capilized things in italics but I forgot. Or do you mean the word hypocritical? Because thats not a bad word. It means you say somethings one thing is something but say the other thing that is identical isn't. BLOF used it on me before. Boo der dash

When did BLOF use it?Count Bonsula I need blood...23:16, 5 September 2010 (UTC)

The FA nomination for Mario Superstar Baseball. Its not a bad word. I don't know what you're getting so worked up over it about. Boo der dash

No she didn't! No really, she didn't say that. GalladeBlades

"I dunno what to say. It feels like hypocrisy that Booderdash compliments on one image, then bashes the other, even though they were taken by the exact program. BabyLuigiOnFire (Talk)"

Thats BLOF's exact words. in Mariowiki:Featured Articles/N/Mario Superstar Baseball, ut its not bad... Boo der dash

Since when the word "hypocrisy" is a bad word? You can look it up on the dictionary and it won't have the term "vulgar" next to it. Hypocritical, hypocrisy, hypocrite all mean this: when a person's actions contradict their saying. It's like saying, "You're eating so unhealthily, compared to me! Coke is bad for you!" *drinks 10 cans of Coke*. THAT'S hypocrisy Ray Trace^(T|C)

Edit conflict FTL

65: quote: Nurse Toadstool is Peach as a nurse... Do I need to go any further? Mario^-HOHO! (Talk / Stalk) 00:26, 6 September 2010 (UTC)

*facepalm* Just because it says that in the article doesn't mean it is true. Fawfulfury65 (talk)

Why do we need official proof that it is Peach? She has the EXACT same hairstyle as Peach, has the exact same eyes, wears pink clothing, just like Peach, and she even WEARS the same exact earrings. Plus, Princess Peach, was depicted as "Princess Toadstool." I doubt anyone else would look EXACTLY like her. Ray Trace^(T|C)

And the starfish article says Starfish is starfy as a cameo appearence but its not official. When did nintendo or any game confirm Nurse Toadstool to be EXACTLY Princess Peach. Booderdash (talk)

Well, I know that it probably is Peach, but it could just be a Peach look-a-like, not actually her. Dr. Mario and Mario aren't entirely the same characters so... Fawfulfury65 (talk)

Drty and Mario only appeared together in one game, Super Smash Bros., and that game you could have Young Link and Link fighting each other at the same time. Didn't you hear this, that Peach's original name used to be Toadstool? So I think that it IS her, but just going by her old alias. Ray Trace^(T|C)

Well, how can you prove it's not Princess Peach/Toadstool? I probably cannot prove it's Princess Toadstool, but you cannot prove it isn't Princess Toadstool either. Mario^-HOHO! (Talk / Stalk) 03:01, 6 September 2010 (UTC)

It's not confirmed to be her, that's pretty much my proof. Fawfulfury65 (talk)

We have more proof that she is than she isn't?

Let's see our proof: Toadstool is Peach's first name. Looks like Peach. Has never appeared alongside Peach. Appears alongside Mario.

And here's yours: She's not confirmed to be Peach.

I certainly can see who has has the upper hand. MrConcreteDonkey 18:13, 6 September 2010 (UTC)

@MCD toadstool is also used to refer to King toadstool. That's not proof. Since they're not confirmed to be the same, they're not the same.If she was referd to Princess Toadstool in the comic, then that means they're the same.Count Bonsula I need blood...06:59, 8 September 2010 (UTC)

Because it definitely is King Toadstool in thst nurse's outfit. MrConcreteDonkey 16:09, 8 September 2010 (UTC)

Guys if she's not confirmed to be Peach, you can't just assume she's Peach, even if you have all this proof. It has to be official. Fawfulfury65 (talk)

It doesn't need to be official if it is blatantly ovbious. MrConcreteDonkey 16:09, 8 September 2010 (UTC)

Everything here must be official, obvious or not, it's not confirmed to be peach. It may be her twin sister, or whatever. I don't have proof it's her twin sister and you don't have proofs that it's peach. Every thing on this wiki must be confirmed.Count Bonsula I need blood...

But it's not confirmed that this Nurse is not Princess Peach! Now what? Mario^-HOHO! (Talk / Stalk) 18:03, 8 September 2010 (UTC)

So every nurse you see on videogames, you say it's peach and when we say she's not, you tell us prove it? It's you who have to prove it's peach right? Same here, prove that she's peach, not we prove that she's not peach, our proof is that nintendo never stated that peach is Nurse Toadstool!Count Bonsula I need blood...21:18, 8 September 2010 (UTC)

NT doesn't appear more than three times. However one of the times is simply an event in SSBM but as a color swap to match with Dr.Mario. Her abilities were unchanged as well. Even though it isn't truly confirmed as Peach there is no other character in the series or Marioverse closely resembling Peach at all. Also there's only one picture and it's just Peach but in a different outfit. On the Peach page she also is seen a couple of pictures where she is wearing a different outfit but she isn't given a new article for every outfit she does. She isn't given a page for when she is in an X-Naut or wedding dress. However she is shown in the Shadow Queen article but only because the Shadow Queen posses her similar to Super Paper Mario having an article for Luigi+Dimentio+Chaos Heart boss. In all honesty. Just one picture, two places seen and a mention of color palette swap is not good enough for being an article itself. Garlic Stapler (talk)

this character is called Nurse Toadstool, and toadstool even refers to the king of the mushroom kingdom. I know no one resembles her, but we don't have proofs it's her, The possessed peach was proven to be peach because we saw the queen possess her.Count Bonsula I need blood...12:56, 9 September 2010 (UTC)

Well unless the king is actually crossdressing in that picture.... That and it sounds kind of odd. Also nurse toadstool isn't mentioned in the Peache article. Lastly it pretty much states in the stub that it's Peach but in a different outfit. Why does a seperate outfit deserve an article? It's kind of like awhile back where each of Mario's pieces of clothing had their own articles. Garlic Stapler (talk)

Okay, let me put it in one question;Gimme one single proof(confirmed one) that Peach and Nurse Toadstool are the same person.Count Bonsula I need blood...13:03, 9 September 2010 (UTC)

Hmm...never mind, proof is gotten. Immaculate in his medical garb, Dr. Mario destroys killer viruses with his amazing vitamin capsules. With his dedicated nurse, Princess Peach, at his side, Dr. Mario spends day and night in his laboratory working on new miracle cures. Somehow he's managed to keep up with all the new viruses that have arisen over the years. from SSBB. Opposers, please read this. Am not going to support now, just removing my vote.Count Bonsula I need blood...

Another correction. She's only seen two times. Once in the comic series and then SSBM as a color swap opponet in match 35 of the event series. Garlic Stapler (talk)

I don't call that proof, but anyway, I removed my vote per my comment.Count Bonsula I need blood...13:25, 9 September 2010 (UTC)

@Booderdash The reason is that Shrowser is a possessed bowser, much like Dark Fawful, Bowletta and some article are seperated because of they're stronger version of the character, such as Giga Bowser and Dr. Mario and even Wario Man. Here, Peach only wears an outfit. I mean, what about her wedding suit in SPM? Should we make an article about wedding peach or bride peach?Count Bonsula I need blood...19:25, 9 September 2010 (UTC)

Its because Nurse Toadstool was officially CALLED Nurse Toadstool before. Unlike Bride Peach which if fanon. Boo der dash

But nurse toadstool is proven to be peach, and she has no particular role, she's just wearing some outfit. Unlike Dr Mario, who is playable in SSBM, Peach only wears an outfit, and nothing makes her better, stronger, hotter then Pricess Peach. I mean, if your teacher is called bob and you call him Mr. Bob. This makes him different? No! He's just a guy wearing some outfit and teaching.Count Bonsula I need blood...

But Nurse Toadstool was OFFICIALLY called that by Nintendo several times. I mean Dr. Mario has his own article and hes pracitically the same as Nurse Toadstool. Your logic still applies there. Booderdash (talk)

So Bob and Mr Bob are different. Look, the only reason Doctor Mario has its own article is because he appeared as a playable character in SSBM. Nurse Toadstool is officially called like that, but it's only peach in an outfit. She was even refereed to as His Nurse, Princess Peach in SSB's description.Count Bonsula I need blood...

@Booderdash: Shrowser and Bowser are separate because Shrowser plays a part in the main story, and is a boss. You really can't compare him to Nurse Toadstool. MrConcreteDonkey 07:39, 11 September 2010 (UTC)

heres how i see it if we merge these two then we should have to merge baby mario and mario since they are in fact the same people mrblob1012 (talk)

Booderdash, the babies are split from the adults because they are considered to be different characters from the adults. Mario and Baby Mario appear at the same time in MKW. Fawfulfury65 (talk)