Talk:Nintendo Comics System: Difference between revisions
(Undo revision 3513752 by MontyMoleLoreMaster (talk) this question does not warrant {{talk}}, save it only for more pressing matters) Tag: Undo |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 11: | Line 11: | ||
Did Rocky Wrenches or Monty Moles even appear in one of these comics (the Nintendo Adventure Books which are inspired on these comics did feature Rocky Wrenches so I am wondering if these comics ever had Rocky Wrenches at least once)? [[User:MontyMoleLoreMaster|MontyMoleLoreMaster]] ([[User talk:MontyMoleLoreMaster|talk]]) 14:37, December 4, 2021 (EST) | Did Rocky Wrenches or Monty Moles even appear in one of these comics (the Nintendo Adventure Books which are inspired on these comics did feature Rocky Wrenches so I am wondering if these comics ever had Rocky Wrenches at least once)? [[User:MontyMoleLoreMaster|MontyMoleLoreMaster]] ([[User talk:MontyMoleLoreMaster|talk]]) 14:37, December 4, 2021 (EST) | ||
==Should the page really be named "Nintendo Comics System"?== | |||
{{talk}} | |||
This has something that has been bugging me for a while and with me planning to rewrite this page, I may as well bring it up: I'm not sure having "Nintendo Comics System" as the catch-all title for Valiant Mario's comic as we currently do is entirely correct. That's indeed how the first half-dozen publications were called when the comics had a grab bag of Mario/Zelda/Captain N/other stories. When the book got more Mario-heavy, the titles shifted to "Nintendo Comic Systes featuring ''Super Mario Bros.'' and when the non-Mario/Zelda titles were dropped, Valiant shifted to reprinting those stories in standalone volumes, with the Mario ones all featuring some variant of "Super Mario Bros.". As such, I believe "Super Mario Bros." (or [[Super Mario Bros. (Valiant Comics)]] for the purpose of the wiki) would be the more correct title. | |||
Now, there a ''lot'' of asteriks here. First is that the chaotic way Valiant released and rereleased those books make it difficult to figure out the exact timeline of their publication. Insight about the industry context or the creative process of the book either does not exist or was not well-archived- for all I know Valiant still referred to those Mario books as "Nintedo Comic Systems" on some retailler incentive sheet or internal audit even if the cover says otherwise. There would also still be value in having a page for the "Nintendo Comic Systems" umbrella brand as the Game Boy comics are very much a separate thing from the main Mario title, as are the Captain N comics (whose Donkey Kong appearances I'm not sure yet are substantive enough to warrant the comic its own page) | |||
But yeah, thoughts? Corrections? --[[User:Glowsquid|Glowsquid]] ([[User talk:Glowsquid|talk]]) 08:32, April 18, 2023 (EDT) | |||
Revision as of 07:32, April 18, 2023
Story Listing
The story listing had been simplified, but I think it was actually better in the previous version. There you could look for stories in specific issues, but now it's just a list with hardly any order. --Grandy02 14:34, 18 October 2008 (EDT)
Scans
TRSRockin is gone, but for anyone still interested in reading some of the comics, here's another site that has a bunch of them. -- Sir Grodus 19:16, 19 July 2011 (EDT)
Rocky Wrench
Did Rocky Wrenches or Monty Moles even appear in one of these comics (the Nintendo Adventure Books which are inspired on these comics did feature Rocky Wrenches so I am wondering if these comics ever had Rocky Wrenches at least once)? MontyMoleLoreMaster (talk) 14:37, December 4, 2021 (EST)
Should the page really be named "Nintendo Comics System"?
|
This talk page or section has a conflict or question that needs to be answered. Please try to help and resolve the issue by leaving a comment. |
This has something that has been bugging me for a while and with me planning to rewrite this page, I may as well bring it up: I'm not sure having "Nintendo Comics System" as the catch-all title for Valiant Mario's comic as we currently do is entirely correct. That's indeed how the first half-dozen publications were called when the comics had a grab bag of Mario/Zelda/Captain N/other stories. When the book got more Mario-heavy, the titles shifted to "Nintendo Comic Systes featuring Super Mario Bros. and when the non-Mario/Zelda titles were dropped, Valiant shifted to reprinting those stories in standalone volumes, with the Mario ones all featuring some variant of "Super Mario Bros.". As such, I believe "Super Mario Bros." (or Super Mario Bros. (Valiant Comics) for the purpose of the wiki) would be the more correct title.
Now, there a lot of asteriks here. First is that the chaotic way Valiant released and rereleased those books make it difficult to figure out the exact timeline of their publication. Insight about the industry context or the creative process of the book either does not exist or was not well-archived- for all I know Valiant still referred to those Mario books as "Nintedo Comic Systems" on some retailler incentive sheet or internal audit even if the cover says otherwise. There would also still be value in having a page for the "Nintendo Comic Systems" umbrella brand as the Game Boy comics are very much a separate thing from the main Mario title, as are the Captain N comics (whose Donkey Kong appearances I'm not sure yet are substantive enough to warrant the comic its own page)
But yeah, thoughts? Corrections? --Glowsquid (talk) 08:32, April 18, 2023 (EDT)
