User talk:MeritC/Archive 8: Difference between revisions
Ninelevendo (talk | contribs) |
Ninelevendo (talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 58: | Line 58: | ||
:::The information is where it should be. {{User:Alex95/sig}} 12:03, 30 August 2017 (EDT) | :::The information is where it should be. {{User:Alex95/sig}} 12:03, 30 August 2017 (EDT) | ||
::::@MeritC While it is important information regarding their clothing designs, just because it debuts in a game does ''not'' mean that the information to important enough to be placed in the trivia section, especially with something as minor as clothing. If we listed when Peach or Daisy get a new dress, we would also have to mention that it was also the first game that Bowser Jr. got his bandana design, the first time that Diddy Kong appeared in a Mario game, etc, which, while useful, isn't important enough to be on the game page. If we did so, the trivia sections would be overly long, and that's obviously something that we want to try and avoid. If the information doesn't have ''anywhere'' else to go, that's when you put it on trivia. In the case of Peach and Daisy's dresses and such, they have a spot to go on their respective pages, in the appearance section. Therefore, that information doesn't need to be anywhere else. - {{User:Ninelevendo/sig}} 08:07, 31 August 2017 (EDT) | ::::@MeritC While it is important information regarding their clothing designs, just because it debuts in a game does ''not'' mean that the information to important enough to be placed in the trivia section, especially with something as minor as clothing. If we listed when Peach or Daisy get a new dress, we would also have to mention that it was also the first game that Bowser Jr. got his bandana design, the first time that Diddy Kong appeared in a Mario game, etc, which, while useful, isn't important enough to be on the game page. If we did so, the trivia sections would be overly long, and that's obviously something that we want to try and avoid. If the information doesn't have ''anywhere'' else to go, that's when you put it on trivia. In the case of Peach and Daisy's dresses and such, they have a spot to go on their respective pages, in the appearance section. Therefore, that information doesn't need to be anywhere else. - {{User:Ninelevendo/sig}} 08:07, 31 August 2017 (EDT) | ||
:::::Yeah that's exactly right, the idea is to keep the trivia sections as small as possible and keep information strictly relevant to the article that it's on. So for future edits, please try to keep that type of information off of trivia sections. Otherwise though, keep up the great work. ;) - {{User:Ninelevendo/sig}} 01:46, 1 September 2017 (EDT) | |||
Revision as of 00:46, September 1, 2017
Hi there, everyone, and welcome to my talk page on the Super Mario Wiki! Feel free to drop me a line if you want to chat.
The only rule is that all talk page content placed here still must follow the rules stated for this site, including the Courtesy section. When you attempt to contact me, if I have an answer to your inquiry, I'll place the reply on your respective talk page.
Take care, everyone! -- M. C.
UPDATE (7/8/2013): If any of you Super Mario Wiki visitors have a forum account and you have an issue that is beyond discussing with me via this or any other of my talk pages here on the main site, then you can see about sending me a private message. Also, my editing sessions are now on a sporadic basis due to certain circumstances that I can't mention here, but I'll try to see about getting back to you guys either on your talk pages or forum PM when I can. Thanks for understanding.
Let it stay
Oh come on, it's her reappearance. You're not giving strong reasons for it, I saw some articles that contain info like that before. --APA TKB 
17:23, 12 July 2013 (EDT)
Retire
Why did you? 
Me, GK Inc.!
(talk! · edits!) {{{1}}}
Re: Recent anon
They've got a pair of month-long prior blocks for edits similar to what we just undid. Think a permablock might be in order? Lord Grammaticus (talk) 01:28, 24 December 2013 (EST)
Mini Peach
I don't think the difference is discernible at all, and besides, the game itself is pretty modern so I don't think it's noteworthy to note the differences anyway. It's like saying Mario's design in that game is Mario's modern design. 
Ray Trace(T|C) 13:23, 7 January 2014 (EST)
Hello
I see you're here. wanna start Talk 6? R O Y 20:24, 20 February 2014 (EST)
Sonic pages
Yeah, I realized as I was updating the latest appearances that perhaps "crossover installments" is the better way to go for that.
Mario Golf: Toadstool Tour Trivia
Hi MetricC, in regards to your edit on Mario Golf: Toadstool Tour, it goes directly against the trivia policy, which states that trivia information should be strictly relevant to the article it's on. For a video game itself, such as Mario Golf: Toadstool Tour, this should only include information about sales, advertising, and other information that has no other place on any other articles to go. Trivia should be kept as a last resort, essentially. Information about a specific character's clothing like Peach and Daisy's sports outfits has no need to be on the Mario Golf: Toadstool Tour article, as it isn't important to the game itself. It is, however, important information about the characters dressing and should be on their (Peach and Daisy's) articles' where the information is relevant. It's better to keep most information about a specific subject in one spot, rather than cluttering other pages with irrelevant information. In short, there is no need for this information to be on Toadstool Tour's trivia page as it already has an article that it's relevant to. Could you please keep this in mind for next time?
To quote the trivia policy, it states an example similar to this: "For example, miscellaneous information about a character's appearance in a game would best belong on that character's respective page - not the game's page." If you have a problem with this, it's basically going against policy, so if you disagree I would recommend starting a conversation with a mod or such to resolve this issue. - 
08:00, 30 August 2017 (EDT)
- To further comment, there was another user yesterday who continued to edit war and readd this information to the irrelevant article. He was ultimately blocked due to his unwillingness to listen to directions. Points about the characters should go on that character's page itself, and I made sure that they already are yesterday.
11:38, 30 August 2017 (EDT)
- Yes, GameCube games are when many characters had their look solidified. But the information of when their current appearance was set, be it Luigi's Mansion, Mario Party 4, or Mario Golf: Toadstool Tour, is more relevant to the characters themselves, not to the game. 11:49, 30 August 2017 (EDT)
- Princess_Peach#Physical_description
- Princess_Daisy#Physical_description
- The information is where it should be. 12:03, 30 August 2017 (EDT)
- @MeritC While it is important information regarding their clothing designs, just because it debuts in a game does not mean that the information to important enough to be placed in the trivia section, especially with something as minor as clothing. If we listed when Peach or Daisy get a new dress, we would also have to mention that it was also the first game that Bowser Jr. got his bandana design, the first time that Diddy Kong appeared in a Mario game, etc, which, while useful, isn't important enough to be on the game page. If we did so, the trivia sections would be overly long, and that's obviously something that we want to try and avoid. If the information doesn't have anywhere else to go, that's when you put it on trivia. In the case of Peach and Daisy's dresses and such, they have a spot to go on their respective pages, in the appearance section. Therefore, that information doesn't need to be anywhere else. - 08:07, 31 August 2017 (EDT)
- Yeah that's exactly right, the idea is to keep the trivia sections as small as possible and keep information strictly relevant to the article that it's on. So for future edits, please try to keep that type of information off of trivia sections. Otherwise though, keep up the great work. ;) - 01:46, 1 September 2017 (EDT)
- Yeah that's exactly right, the idea is to keep the trivia sections as small as possible and keep information strictly relevant to the article that it's on. So for future edits, please try to keep that type of information off of trivia sections. Otherwise though, keep up the great work. ;) -
- @MeritC While it is important information regarding their clothing designs, just because it debuts in a game does not mean that the information to important enough to be placed in the trivia section, especially with something as minor as clothing. If we listed when Peach or Daisy get a new dress, we would also have to mention that it was also the first game that Bowser Jr. got his bandana design, the first time that Diddy Kong appeared in a Mario game, etc, which, while useful, isn't important enough to be on the game page. If we did so, the trivia sections would be overly long, and that's obviously something that we want to try and avoid. If the information doesn't have anywhere else to go, that's when you put it on trivia. In the case of Peach and Daisy's dresses and such, they have a spot to go on their respective pages, in the appearance section. Therefore, that information doesn't need to be anywhere else. -
- Yes, GameCube games are when many characters had their look solidified. But the information of when their current appearance was set, be it Luigi's Mansion, Mario Party 4, or Mario Golf: Toadstool Tour, is more relevant to the characters themselves, not to the game.
