MarioWiki:Featured articles/N1/Coin Rush: Difference between revisions

From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
(→‎Support: added my support)
m (Text replacement - "{{[Ff]a-archive" to "{{FA archive notice")
 
(22 intermediate revisions by 9 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
__NOTOC__
__NOTOC__
===[[{{#titleparts:{{PAGENAME}}||3}}]]===
===[[{{SUBPAGENAME}}]]===
{{FANOMSTAT|nominated=December 2, 2012, 13:56 (GMT)|passed=}}
{{FA archive notice|nominated=07:56, 2 December 2012 (EST)|passed=16:38, 15 December 2012}}
===Support===
===Support===
#{{User|Electrical Bowser jr.}} Very detailed for a petty article (it covers the cost of each pack), with lots of good-quality pictures.
#{{User|Electrical Bowser jr.}} Very detailed for a petty article (it covers the cost of each pack), with lots of good-quality pictures.
#{{User|Mariobros1985}}
#{{User|Mariobros1985}}
#{{User|YoshiCookie}}
#{{User|YoshiCookie}}
#{{User|Calztchi}} It covers everything there is to be covered on a key feature of a recent game, which is important. I think it deserves to be featured.
#{{User|Calztchi}}
#{{User|SmartYoshi}}
#{{User|YoshiKong}}


===Oppose===
===Oppose===
#{{user|MarioSmasher}} – I am not sure if this can become a FA: there are more packs likely to come, and it's best to keep it as a non-FA, until <s>the end of the world comes</s> <s>Nintendo will become lazy</s> the service ends.
#{{User|SmartYoshi}} No. No way. Too short.


===Removal of Opposes===
===Removal of Opposes===
{{User|SmartYoshi}}
{{User|SmartYoshi}}
:''User withdrew oppose vote on their own behalf.


#{{User|Electrical Bowser jr.}} So what if it's short? What matters is that it has good details (not spam)! It's not even that short, anyway!
#{{User|Electrical Bowser jr.}} So what if it's short? What matters is that it has good details (not spam)! It's not even that short, anyway!
#{{User|YoshiKong}} Per Electrical dude, it is up to date and complete with all info currently available.


{{User|MarioSmasher}}  
{{User|MarioSmasher}}  
:''Removal passed.''


#{{User|Electrical Bowser jr.}}I appreciate how you didn't pull any punches, but the article is great already, and it'll be even better when those packs are released.
#{{User|Electrical Bowser jr.}}I appreciate how you didn't pull any punches, but the article is great already, and it'll be even better when those packs are released.
#{{User|Marshal Dan Troop}} Bowser's going to appear in games yet he's been featured...so unless we need to unfeature him we can't deny featured article rights to this article.
#{{User|Marshal Dan Troop}} Bowser's going to appear in games yet he's been featured...so unless we need to unfeature him we can't deny featured article rights to this article.
#{{User|YoshiKong}} Per all.


===Comments===
===Comments===
Line 26: Line 32:


@ElectricalBowserJr What do you mean by "''pull any punches''"? Please explain, thank you. {{User|MarioSmasher}}
@ElectricalBowserJr What do you mean by "''pull any punches''"? Please explain, thank you. {{User|MarioSmasher}}
 
:Oh great, we make an article that will expand even more a FA. Take a look at [[Mario]]. It could be a FA, but it can't as more games come and we have to add info for them. Same for this. More packs will come and we have to add, add, add… {{User|MarioSmasher}}
SmartYoshi's vote is in fact valid because the rules say '''be of reasonable length, and not marked as a stub.''' therefore he can argue that being too short is a reason to reject a FA. {{User|Marshal Dan Troop}}
SmartYoshi's vote is in fact valid because the rules say '''be of reasonable length, and not marked as a stub.''' therefore he can argue that being too short is a reason to reject a FA. {{User|Marshal Dan Troop}}

Latest revision as of 16:41, May 31, 2024

Coin Rush

Smg2 icon bronzestar.png

This is an archive of a successful featured article nomination. If this page is unprotected, do not modify its contents, as it is an archive of past discussions.
Coin Rush was nominated to be a featured article at 07:56, 2 December 2012 (EST) and passed at 11:38, 22 December 2012.


Support

  1. Electrical Bowser jr. (talk) Very detailed for a petty article (it covers the cost of each pack), with lots of good-quality pictures.
  2. Mariobros1985 (talk)
  3. YoshiCookie (talk)
  4. Calztchi (talk)
  5. SmartYoshi (talk)
  6. YoshiKong (talk)

Oppose

Removal of Opposes

SmartYoshi (talk)

User withdrew oppose vote on their own behalf.
  1. Electrical Bowser jr. (talk) So what if it's short? What matters is that it has good details (not spam)! It's not even that short, anyway!
  2. YoshiKong (talk) Per Electrical dude, it is up to date and complete with all info currently available.

MarioSmasher (talk)

Removal passed.
  1. Electrical Bowser jr. (talk)I appreciate how you didn't pull any punches, but the article is great already, and it'll be even better when those packs are released.
  2. Marshal Dan Troop (talk) Bowser's going to appear in games yet he's been featured...so unless we need to unfeature him we can't deny featured article rights to this article.
  3. YoshiKong (talk) Per all.

Comments

There is likely to be more Coin Rush packs to come, so maybe it is best to nominate this at a later time. But it's up to you. YoshiKong (talk) 08:15, 2 December 2012 (EST)

@ElectricalBowserJr What do you mean by "pull any punches"? Please explain, thank you. MarioSmasher (talk)

Oh great, we make an article that will expand even more a FA. Take a look at Mario. It could be a FA, but it can't as more games come and we have to add info for them. Same for this. More packs will come and we have to add, add, add… MarioSmasher (talk)

SmartYoshi's vote is in fact valid because the rules say be of reasonable length, and not marked as a stub. therefore he can argue that being too short is a reason to reject a FA. Marshal Dan Troop (talk)

Retrieved from "https://www.mariowiki.com/index.php?title=MarioWiki:Featured_articles/N1/Coin_Rush&oldid=4237811"