Talk:Crocodile Isle (Donkey Kong 64)

Wait, the official guide I have calls it K. Rool's Ship. -- Sir Grodus

Nintendo Power? If so, change it back. The conjecture template was on this page, so I decided to change the name. -- Son of Suns

I assume this meant Prima's Official Strategy Guide, which is considered a lower-priority source. LinkTheLefty (talk) 11:14, 12 October 2014 (EDT)

Merge to Crocodile Isle

This talk page proposal has already been settled. Please do not edit any of the sections in the proposal. If you wish to discuss the article, do so in a new header below the proposal.

no quorum 2-1
Considering the amount of variance DK Island has, I fail to see why this should be treated any differently. Yes, in DK64, it's a completely mechanical vehicle, but SSBU merges the design to an actual geological formation. On that note, we don't treat Bowser's Castle differently across games (barring stage articles), and it's been treated as a mobile weapon on occasion as well.

Proposer: Doc von Schmeltwick (talk)
Deadline: April 3, 2022, 23:59 GMT

Support

1. Doc von Schmeltwick (talk) - Per
2. Hewer (talk) Per proposal, recurring locations have never stayed consistent outside of Mario Kart.

Oppose

1. LinkTheLefty (talk) I'm actually not too sure about this one. If it only had one name for Donkey Kong 64, I'd probably be for it, but it has multiple, and "Crocodile Isle" just happens to be the one with the highest priority. This part of the series is also kind of weird since we're suddenly supposed to believe that Cranky is DK's father and that the Golden Bananas were always there all along as part of the banana hoard. If anything, this should merge with Blast-o-Matic, which Super Smash Bros. seems to take as the name of the island too.

Comments

@LinkTheLefty: While I'm not ready to jump on the support bandwagon just yet, I don't agree with your arguments. Crocodile Isle doesn't "just happen" to be the name with the highest priority, it comes from the game's manual, which we consider comparable to in-game names as far as priority is concerned. The other names all come from strategy guides, which are secondary sources. Since they contradict a primary source, they should not be considered a factor in this at all. If "Crocodile Isle" were also a guide name, I would understand, but it isn't. We certainly shouldn't merge this with Blast-o-Matic; the SSBU spirit clearly just uses a render of the island as its image for convenience, since no official artwork of the weapon itself exists, and merging things purely because of Smash wouldn't sit well with me anyway. 13:18, March 20, 2022 (EDT)

I seem to recall a Sakurai presentation where he referred to the island itself as the Blast-o-Matic, but I can't find what I'm looking for right now, and in fact, one of the in-game tips simply refers to it as the "island fortress" that the Blast-o-Matic is on. Still, I stand by the primary name being emblematic of the inconsistencies that surfaced during this specific period. If you're going by the manual names, you can also refer to manual descriptions. Page 20 of the Donkey Kong Country 2: Diddy's Kong Quest manual, under "The Legend of Crocodile Isle": "As the home port of Kaptain K. Rool’s cutthroat pirates, Crocodile Isle is teeming with all types of Kremings. There’s even more variety of terrain on this island than there was in Donkey Kong Country. And K. Rool definitely has the home turf advantage here." Page 29 of the Donkey Kong 64 manual, under "The Islands": "The once idyllic Kong Isle now has an unpleasant neighbor in the form of K. Rool’s massive mechanical Crocodile Isle. This monstrosity towers over our homeland, with the ridiculously-named Blast-o-Matic device ready to reduce it to rubble. Between them, these two contrasting islands conceal the entrances to all the levels." Already there's a strong implication that the former is the Kremlings' natural homeland, and that the latter is an artificial one that K. Rool had built. Outside of the Kremling association, it's basically in name only. LinkTheLefty (talk) 16:32, March 20, 2022 (EDT)

I understand that, but my point here is a rebuilt Crocodile Isle is still Crocodile Isle. Doc von Schmeltwick (talk) 16:46, March 20, 2022 (EDT)

Think of it this way: the current situation is akin to the split of Mario vs. Donkey Kong's mechanical enemies from their original organic counterparts (except there's more of a grounds to re-merge those if it was really desired, as they're closer as copies than the Crocodile Isles). LinkTheLefty (talk) 18:09, March 20, 2022 (EDT)

I'd see it as more like splitting the weird artificial depictions of established enemies from Sunshine. Doc von Schmeltwick (talk) 00:45, March 21, 2022 (EDT)

I still think that was (partly at least) Nintendo's retroactive explanation for the nonstandard enemy designs in the GameCube era, considering you have Piantas with Chain Chomplet pets and selling the game's Cheep-Cheeps at a fish market. LinkTheLefty (talk) 06:06, March 21, 2022 (EDT)

Bowser's Castle has had more iterations than anyone can count, including a floating island, a flying fortress, a tower, a pinball board, etc., and it's pretty clear that they aren't all the exact same place. But we still keep them all merged because they're different iterations of the same idea. Hewer (talk · contributions · edit count) 12:55, March 21, 2022 (EDT)

My point is they're barely the same idea. One's got varied landscapes, lush environments, ancient ruins, etc. The other is a driven construct. The only part they might have in common is the galleon area. LinkTheLefty (talk) 13:10, March 21, 2022 (EDT)

Merge to Crocodile Isle - take 2

This talk page proposal has already been settled. Please do not edit any of the sections in the proposal. If you wish to discuss the article, do so in a new header below the proposal.

Merge to Crocodile Isle 5-0
See my above arguments. Last proposal barely had any votes for either support or opposition, so trying again.

Proposer: Doc von Schmeltwick (talk)
Deadline: September 21, 2024, 23:59 (GMT)

Support

1. Doc von Schmeltwick (talk) - Per
2. PrincessPeachFan (talk) Agreed.
3. ThePowerPlayer (talk) Per how Donkey Kong Island is handled.
4. Camwoodstock (talk) Per proposal. The differences between this and Literally Any Other Crocodile Isle aren't all that severe to warrant a full split like this.
5. Killer Moth (talk) Per proposal

#Super Mario RPG (talk) Per points made in the previous proposal.

Comments

Supporting due to the fact that several areas in Donkey Kong 64 are connected to the DKC2 ones. PrincessPeachFan (talk) 08:37, September 8, 2024 (EDT)

You know you can put your reasons in your vote rather than separately in the comments... Doc von Schmeltwick (talk) 21:06, September 16, 2024 (EDT)