Gallery talk:Trophies

Hello all, this page was started by me since we have so many random trophies but no gallery for them, some have lists about them but no central page like You have Super Mario Odyssey and Super Mario Galaxy etc. that have their own galleries but they have a central gallery at Gallery:Mario, so that’s what this was supposed to be, but there are 2 opinions from other users that are a problem, 1 says Mario zwiki is trying to lessen Smash Bros. Coverage, even though this was for more than just smash Bros. And that this will likely get deleted anyway, and there’s another opinion that says that this is a good idea and should keep going, but we don’t know who’s right on this one, let me know your opinion below please, it would be a big help Do The Mario (Talk) 01:56, 12 June 2018 (EDT)

Worth it? (yes)

Now, there has been some question over whether this recently-created under-construction gallery is worth having when there are already tables of trophies spread across four "list" pages; I, for one, believe it is useful, as it would have them all in one easy-to-access page and be less of a formatting nightmare across various devices, due to not being a table and not having descriptions. There are also some who want Smash coverage lessened after a proposal that went through whilst I was tempbanned; the reason it went through was due to Smashwiki's existence, but Smashwiki has entire fancruft articles over random cloud platforms, and seems to be geared not primarily, but solely to a very specific sect of the competitive community, which is not what a wiki is for, it's for usage by the general populace. So yeah, not a fan of that site, and think that lessening coverage here would be nothing but detrimental to everyone. Doc von Schmeltwick (talk) 01:58, 12 June 2018 (EDT)

I agree with you, however zi also sorta agree with Alex, so I will stay neutral on this one Do The Mario (Talk) 02:01, 12 June 2018 (EDT)

@Doc If you have a problem with the proposal, counter it with another proposal. It reached a consensus, so rambling about it here won't change anything.

But as Alex95 said on Do the Mario's talk page, since we are lessening our coverage on Smash, an alternative method of listing trophy images really isn't a necessity for us. Not to mention the long loading time for the page with how many trophies there are in the series, so really it would just be counterproductive in terms of convenience. Mario JC 02:10, 12 June 2018 (EDT)

Okay, now I’m totally confused do I delete it,keep it or what? And what proposal? I’m so confused right now, Do The Mario (Talk) 02:14, 12 June 2018 (EDT)

Okay, I think I figured this out and as the creator of the page here is my stand: Mariojc and Alex95 are higher in rank than Doc and I, what they say goes my stand on the issue all together:maybe we should lessen up considering there is another wiki for this, and I’m fine with it getting deleted simply because the hard work I put in has already been copied so this won’t affect me, I say since Mariojc and Alex95 say it should go, then it should go Do The Mario (Talk) 02:21, 12 June 2018 (EDT)

Having the trophy images split up by game pages seems easier for everyone, and having them all on one page will make loading times difficult considering the amount of trophies there are. It'd likely end up getting split like Mario's gallery at one point, which would just make this gallery even more pointless. On top of that, Do The Mario agrees with its deletion, Doc. It doesn't matter what SmashWiki is doing with its content, for us, having two of the same lists is excessive. 09:59, 12 June 2018 (EDT)