Talk:5-Volt

Merge 5-Volt into List of Implied Characters

This talk page section contains an unresolved talk page proposal. Please try to help and resolve the issue by voting or leaving a comment.

Current time: Wednesday, November 27, 2024, 02:03 GMT

This is ridiculous. How is this noteworthy of an article if its only been implied and that the only thing seen of her is her shadow? I say merge into that. The image thing is near impossible and its stubbiness is hard to get rid of.

Proposer: Booderdash (talk)
Deadline: August 14, 2010 24:00 GMT

Support

1. Booderdash (talk) Per me.
2. Zero777 (talk) I am Zero! Per Booderdash. Zero signing out.
3. Mario4Ever (talk) A silhouette is not a sufficient image for a character that is not naturally a silhouette (i.e. Dark characters in Super Paper Mario). Therefore, 5-Volt is not technically seen in-game and is thus an implied character. Per proposal.
4. LeftyGreenMario (talk) Silhouette or not, she is still implied. Per all.
5. Baby Mario Bloops (talk) - Silhouette doesn't proof that it is not implied. For example, Rosalina's family appeared in her storybook, yet they are implied.
6. Walkazo (talk) - Per all.
7. MrConcreteDonkey (talk) Per all.
8. Mario jc (talk) Per all.

Oppose

1. BluePikminKong497 (talk) It cant be merged to that page since it isnt implied. She is actually seen in the games.
2. Superboo922 (talk) Per BPK497. But we should do something about it. Perhaps merge it into 9-volt?
3. Glowsquid (talk) She "appears" in more than one game and her sillouhette is seen at the Game Over screen of Touched!. When I made the Implied pages, it really was to get rid of off-hand mentions in flavor text that wouldn't matter again (ex:Old Man Skoo).
4. Reversinator (talk) 5-Volt appears twice, in two separate games. One is with a silouhette of her, and another shows just her legs, but that proves that she isn't implied.

Comments

Where is she seen in the game? Since it says shes only a shadow so then we can't upload an image for it. Boo der dash

I hardly see a justification in people's reasons that a silouhette is not enough. I'd like to know why it doesn't count. Plus in another game we see 5-Volt, not silouhetted. It was just her legs, but that proves that she isn't just implied.

In my vote, I said that a silhouette is not enough for characters that are not naturally silhouettes. If 9-Volt was a silhouette, it would be, since he would be a silhouette son of a silhouette. The same holds true for Dark characters in Super Paper Mario. Are you seriously considering uploading a pair of legs to represent 5-Volt in the article? Mario4Ever (talk)