MarioWiki:Featured articles/N1/Mario Tennis Open

Mario Tennis Open

Support

1. Mr.L1998 (talk) This article is written with details. It is a nice game too. A lot of screenshots are shown. It can be a featured article!
2. Metalex123 (talk)
3. Sonicrush888 (talk)

Oppose

1. Tucayo (talk) - The Gallery, Staff and Media sections don't follow the Empty Section policy.
2. MeritC (talk) - While it has a lot of good information and the majority of stuff has been accounted for, I too don't think this article is ready for "featured article territory" just yet.
3. King Pikante (talk) - Per MeritC.
4. SmartYoshi (talk) Per Tucayo.

Removal of Opposes

Tucayo

1. LeftyGreenMario (talk) This problem was easily fixed. There are now no empty sections.
2. Marshal Dan Troop (talk) Per LGM.
3. BabyLuigiOnFire (talk) Per Shoey

MeritC

1. Marshal Dan Troop (talk) I feel that your vote is invalid and here's why the entire point of an oppose vote on an FA is to tell the supporters what needs to be fixed your vote doesn't do that instead it offers a vague explanation but gives no indication on what is wrong and is therefore invalid.
2. LeftyGreenMario (talk) Per Marshal Dan Troop.
3. BabyLuigiOnFire (talk) Per Shoey

King Pikante

1. Marshal Dan Troop (talk) You pered MeritC's vote which I am trying to get removed therefore your vote is invalid for the same reason.
2. LeftyGreenMario (talk) Per Marshal Dan Troop.
3. BabyLuigiOnFire (talk) Per Shoey

SmartYoshi

1. Marshal Dan Troop (talk) Tucky's vote is now invalid therefore yours is as well.
2. LeftyGreenMario (talk) Per Marshal Dan Troop.
3. BabyLuigiOnFire (talk) Per Shoey

Comments

Yoshi876 (talk) The thing is every game that is currently featured has empty sections, so I'm not sure whether we should discount a game proposed for featuring just because it does have empty sections.

[Daisy Lover] Light blue Yoshi and Yellow Yoshi's Images are not correct. Light blue has some background mistake and yellow has faint text over it. Also Bowser Jr's image is a lot bigger than the rest. Besides the gallery flaws, one also needs to include that Mario Tennis Open has a Puzzle Swap piece and should link an image of the completed puzzle swap next to it as well. Those should happen before this becomes featured.

MeritC, exactly what makes you feel this article is not ready to be featured? You're very vague in your oppose vote. LeftyGreenMario (talk)

By the way, Daisy Lover, just because Bowser Jr. is slightly bigger than the rest doesn't mean it's not "correct". Also, in Light Blue Yoshi's case, the light blue background is pretty inconsistent, but it won't warrant an article not being featured. Also, I don't think Puzzle Swap is required to be covered in this article. LeftyGreenMario (talk)

Another comment: I think the opening paragraph can be a tad longer. LeftyGreenMario (talk)

@ LeftyGreenMario, my case is this -- yes, the information so far is good but I don't think all aspects of the game have been accounted for yet. Additionally, I believe more tables could be useful for the article itself after we recheck on the character stats, which is still very crucial. MeritC (talk)

Which aspect of the game? You should specify. Not all the game modes are here? Not all the controls are covered? On character stats, I don't think there are official stats on characters. In fact, their stats aren't even shown in game. Sure, all the characters vary, even within their own group, but, again, like in Mario Power Tennis, we don't really have the stats. We have to determine the stats in-game by estimating. LeftyGreenMario (talk)