MarioWiki:Featured articles/N1/Toad

From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search

Toad

"Toad" was nominated for featured article status at '. If the nomination does not pass by 19:27, 17 January 2025, it will be considered failed.

Support

  1. robokoopa (talk) It is a well written article.
  2. Fire Burnin' (talk)
  3. R3D347H (talk)
  4. Propeller Toad (talk)
  5. Heisei-Paratroopa (talk)
  6. YoshiPickle (talk)
  7. EthanFerris (talk) It's real interesting & detailed.
  8. Pichi-Hime6 (talk) Because THE Toad is not in many games that we can confirm for sure (As there are many Toads that look just like him :P ) This is a pretty well written article so I vote yes.

Oppose

  1. Commander Code-8 (talk) The comics have a scarily impressive amount of info but the stuff immiediatly after them are only one-liners.
  2. Vommack (talk) Even if the comics section is scarily impressive, there are too many little one-liners cleverly stuck where they look like parts of bigger sections...
  3. Matik2002 (talk) Lots of screenshots in comics section, per all.
  4. MEGA-Yoshi (talk) 1. The comic section has WAY too much stuff.

2. WAY too many 1-liners in other sections. Seriously, he's not THAT important in comics.

Removal of Opposes

Comments

I actually think the amount of info in some sections is WAY too much, mainly the comics and Mario & Sonic 2012 Commander Code-8 (talk)

The comic sections tend to vary for Toad's importance and in some of them, Toad tends to be the starring character (eg. Kingdom Enquirer). I agree that the Mario & Sonic 2012 information is rather long, and I'll work on shortening that. Some one-liners that are proclaimed actually are a part of information for spin-off game series including the Mario Kart installments which one-liners are to be expected. Artwork of Propeller Yellow Toad in New Super Mario Bros. WiiPropeller ToadArtwork of Propeller Blue Toad in New Super Mario Bros. Wii (talk)

I shortened the Mario & Sonic 2012 game information as well added some missing game information. Is there any other issues that are left to be addressed in the article? I am somewhat confused as to whether or not the comic information is too much as there are claims saying that more information is better especially when Toad has the main lead in the story. The article seems fine to me; however, I do wonder if anything is missing in it that other FA articles do have. Artwork of Propeller Yellow Toad in New Super Mario Bros. WiiPropeller ToadArtwork of Propeller Blue Toad in New Super Mario Bros. Wii (talk)

Retrieved from "https://www.mariowiki.com/index.php?title=MarioWiki:Featured_articles/N1/Toad&oldid=1295518"