Talk:1-Up Mushroom

Split and Merge the "Mario and Luigi series section" from 1-Up Mushroom into the regular Mushroom article

Template:SettledTPP DO NOTHING 2-5

We merged all the other RPG mushrooms, except for the 1-Up Super, so we should merge this one. EDIT: There was a talk page proposal that proposed to merge all the Mario & Luigi series mushrooms, made by Baby Mario Bloops. Now, the recent 1-Up Super TPP said to merge that article into 1-Up Mushroom, and then I knew that not all the M&L series mushrooms were merged. I propose to clean up some stuff by merging the Mario and Luigi series section with the Mushroom article.

Proposer: KS3 (talk · contribute)
Deadline: May 28 2010, 24:00

Split and Merge

1. KS3 (talk) per proposal.
2. Geniusguy445 (talk) i propose all three. http://www.mariowiki.com/Talk:1-Up_Super#Comments

Do nothing

1. Tucayo (talk) - Why? No. It is a 1-Up mushroom, not a simple mushroom.
2. Baby Mario Bloops (talk) - There is a reason for why we have the Super Mushroom page. The 1-up mushroom has been very common throughout the Mario Series. It has its own distinct name and appearance, doesn't act like any other kind of mushroom, and has a article that is not even close to a stub. Unless we merge the Super Mushroom page, along with other sub-mushrooms, then I completely oppose merging.
3. Gamefreak75 (talk) Per all.
4. Walkazo (talk) - Per all: they're too different to smash together this time.
5. Mario Fan 123 - Tucayo is right. Do you doesn't know the difference between a 1-Up Mushroom and a NORMAL Mushroom? The 1-Up revives you from death, and the Mushroom only restores some HP when you are STILL alive, understand? Thank you for your time.

Comments

@Everyone: Well if you see, there are no info on the Super Mushrooms in the RPGs in the Super Mushroom Aricle; they have been merged into the Mushroom article via a talk page proposal made by this user. KS3 (talk · contribute) 22:53, 14 May 2010 (EDT)

I changed the proposal. KS3 (talk · contribute)

Split 1-up Super from 1-up Mushroom

This talk page section contains an unresolved talk page proposal. Please try to help and resolve the issue by voting or leaving a comment.

Current time: Monday, December 23, 2024, 01:03 GMT

Why was the 1-Up Super merged with the 1-Up Mushroom. It is also a super mushroom, and since it is a combination of both, it doesn't make any sense to put all the info into 1-Up Mushroom. So I propose what the heading says, "Split the 1-Up Super from 1-Up Mushroom."

Proposer: KS3 (talk · contribute)
Deadline: July 10 2010, 24:00

Support

1. KS3 (talk) Per my own proposal.
2. Its-a-me Yoshi! (talk) I agree it makes no sense.
3. Walkazo (talk) - As I said in my opposition of the proposal to merge them in the first place: "[The 1-Up Super is] both a Super Mushroom and a 1-Up Mushroom, so merging it with either would be a mistake, as would sticking it into the Mushroom article: it's unique, and should remain as a stand-alone article."

Oppose

1. NARCE (talk) It makes perfect sense. It is a variety of the 1-Up Mushroom, and not a very common one at that.