MarioWiki:Featured articles/N2/Super Smash Bros.: Difference between revisions
From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
Marcelagus (talk | contribs) |
Marcelagus (talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 15: | Line 15: | ||
==== Removal of Opposes ==== | ==== Removal of Opposes ==== | ||
=====LeftyGreenMario===== | =====LeftyGreenMario===== | ||
#{{User|Marcelagus}} -- A list of bonuses would simply clutter the page and would be a useless list of words. And I can't see how the items or stages lack information. We aren't a strategy guide wiki, so adding ambiguous words such as "considerably powerful" are Point-of-View and unprofessional, so all the items need are their functions. As for stages, same deal. All we need is the physical topography and any gimmicks; any strategy-related comments are unwanted in either section. '''EDIT:''' I see you changed your oppose a little, but the fact that it "would be nice" if there was a ''link'' to a different non-existent article is unrelated to the article itself and is thus invalid. | #{{User|Marcelagus}} -- A list of bonuses would simply clutter the page and would be a useless list of words. And I can't see how the items or stages lack information. We aren't a strategy guide wiki, so adding ambiguous words such as "considerably powerful" are Point-of-View and unprofessional, so all the items need are their functions. As for stages, same deal. All we need is the physical topography and any gimmicks; any strategy-related comments are unwanted in either section. '''EDIT:''' I see you changed your oppose a little, but the fact that it "would be nice" if there was a ''link'' to a different non-existent article is unrelated to the quality of the article itself and is thus invalid. | ||
==== Comments ==== | ==== Comments ==== | ||
I see nothing wrong in this article, but some stages and items need more information. {{User|LeftyGreenMario}} | I see nothing wrong in this article, but some stages and items need more information. {{User|LeftyGreenMario}} | ||
Revision as of 23:04, May 26, 2010
Super Smash Bros.
Support
- Marcelagus (talk) -- The entire article is much more organized now. Many images are used to depict the aspects of the game, and gameplay/mode sections have been greatly expanded. This article is back up to par as an article of Featured Article quality.
- KS3 (talk)
- Commander Code-8 (talk)
Oppose
- LeftyGreenMario (talk) I think a link to a list of bonuses from this game would be nice.
Removal of Opposes
LeftyGreenMario
- Marcelagus (talk) -- A list of bonuses would simply clutter the page and would be a useless list of words. And I can't see how the items or stages lack information. We aren't a strategy guide wiki, so adding ambiguous words such as "considerably powerful" are Point-of-View and unprofessional, so all the items need are their functions. As for stages, same deal. All we need is the physical topography and any gimmicks; any strategy-related comments are unwanted in either section. EDIT: I see you changed your oppose a little, but the fact that it "would be nice" if there was a link to a different non-existent article is unrelated to the quality of the article itself and is thus invalid.
Comments
I see nothing wrong in this article, but some stages and items need more information. LeftyGreenMario (talk)
