Talk:Coin: Difference between revisions
From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
Time Turner (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
Time Turner (talk | contribs) mNo edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{PAIRreview | {{PAIRreview | ||
|A-rating= | |A-rating=2.5 | ||
|A-comment=Like a lot of articles, accuracy's hit and miss. I'll name one: at the beginning of the article, it says when Mario gets 100 coins, the player gets a 1-up, when obviously Mario gets the 1-Up. | |A-comment=Like a lot of articles, accuracy's hit and miss. I'll name one: at the beginning of the article, it says when Mario gets 100 coins, the player gets a 1-up, when obviously Mario gets the 1-Up. | ||
|D-rating=2.5 | |D-rating=2.5 | ||
| Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
|I-rating=1.0 | |I-rating=1.0 | ||
|I-comment=Where are all the images? I have never seen so little images in an article with so many sections. More than three quarters of the whole article needs images. | |I-comment=Where are all the images? I have never seen so little images in an article with so many sections. More than three quarters of the whole article needs images. | ||
|F-rating= | |F-rating=2.5 | ||
|F-comment=I don't have much to work with. There are little images and little templates, so I can't do much here. | |F-comment=I don't have much to work with. There are little images and little templates, so I can't do much here. | ||
|FR-comment=This article needs some major rewriting and expanding. | |FR-comment=This article needs some major rewriting and expanding. | ||
Revision as of 12:20, March 2, 2010
| PAIRreview for Coin by Hello, I'm Time Turner. | ||
| Accuracy | 2.5 | Like a lot of articles, accuracy's hit and miss. I'll name one: at the beginning of the article, it says when Mario gets 100 coins, the player gets a 1-up, when obviously Mario gets the 1-Up. |
| Depth | 2.5 | I know you can't go into that much depth with coins, but surely more information could be added. |
| Grammar | 2.5 | There are many grammar error littered throughout the article. |
| Images | 1.0 | Where are all the images? I have never seen so little images in an article with so many sections. More than three quarters of the whole article needs images. |
| Formatting | 2.5 | I don't have much to work with. There are little images and little templates, so I can't do much here. |
| Final Rating: | 11 | This article needs some major rewriting and expanding. |
| Reviewer: | Hello, I'm Time Turner. | |
Should we put how coins work on Club Nintendo? MisterJaffffey
G0 Coin
- Well maybe a quick mention (if they are Mario coins), but it seems such information would be more beneficial on a Club Nintendo page. -- Son of Suns (talk)
- We should - it's a major Nintendo program that releases some exclusive Mario products. Unfortunately I don't know enough about it to actually start the article. -- Son of Suns (talk)
