MarioWiki:Featured articles/N1/Baby Peach: Difference between revisions

From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
Line 22: Line 22:
==== Comments ====
==== Comments ====
Shouldn't the agre reversal section be in a sort of Other Media section of it's own? the cartoon and the video games aren't really part of the same canon. Also, the baseball image is flying out of the section into the lower one. Meaning it doesn't fit at all. the Mario Kart picture is a little too low as well. The Bowsers Mass Kidnaping picture is also too low/big. Like I said in my oppose, the page doesn't correspond with other character pages. Cameo appearances, and then list of appearances? Weather an appearance is cameo or not, if there is reasonable info it should go in the bigraphy, and I think sports appearances should as well. Look at the Daisy page. Do you see how it's made it's biography section mainly out of sports appearances? How does that not make sense. also, the list of appearances uses a table sort of thing. Should this be applied to other pages? I've never seen it before. In the quotes those need to be in a cartoon section of their own. Like keep them there but put a header above them in the quotes section to identify them as from the cartoon. the image gallery isn't centered, and the screenshots use the same screenshots from the page, i saw that there was a proposal to use the same art in the section for art and the page at least once, but nothing about screenshots. Nothing wrong with the page, my left foot. [[User:MarioKun|MarioKun]]
Shouldn't the agre reversal section be in a sort of Other Media section of it's own? the cartoon and the video games aren't really part of the same canon. Also, the baseball image is flying out of the section into the lower one. Meaning it doesn't fit at all. the Mario Kart picture is a little too low as well. The Bowsers Mass Kidnaping picture is also too low/big. Like I said in my oppose, the page doesn't correspond with other character pages. Cameo appearances, and then list of appearances? Weather an appearance is cameo or not, if there is reasonable info it should go in the bigraphy, and I think sports appearances should as well. Look at the Daisy page. Do you see how it's made it's biography section mainly out of sports appearances? How does that not make sense. also, the list of appearances uses a table sort of thing. Should this be applied to other pages? I've never seen it before. In the quotes those need to be in a cartoon section of their own. Like keep them there but put a header above them in the quotes section to identify them as from the cartoon. the image gallery isn't centered, and the screenshots use the same screenshots from the page, i saw that there was a proposal to use the same art in the section for art and the page at least once, but nothing about screenshots. Nothing wrong with the page, my left foot. [[User:MarioKun|MarioKun]]
:Your left foot, huh?  Just say what's wrong.  I'm back from vacation so I can take care of all of this now.  You mention the Daisy page in your comment.  That page goes against Mario Wiki policy stating that character articles should be divided into main game and sports game sections.  However, because the character has only appeared in one main game, that is not followed.  However, Baby Peach has and thus your comparison to that article is inapplicable at best.  Your arguement about canon does not hold water as there is no official Mario canon, only indications about which games and other media come before each other.  Try as I might, I have still found no difinitive source saying that the Super Show! is separate from the video games.  Besides, that problem was taken care of by now... is there anything else that you want changed or are you okay with the article now?  The appearances chart is fine.  I checked around and it does not violate any MarioWiki policy. {{User:Stumpers/sig}} 21:18, 19 July 2008 (EDT)


[[User:Elise]]  The article meets the requirements but if it bothers you so much I fix it a little. But not all articles are going to look alike.
[[User:Elise]]  The article meets the requirements but if it bothers you so much I fix it a little. But not all articles are going to look alike.
Just to adress MarioKun's comments:
#Age Reversal: Fixed.
#Baseball Image: Fixed.
#Low, Big, etc: What do you mean by low? Resolution?
#Style Correspondence:
##Cameo Section: Per a new proposal that passed, it is okay.
##List of Appearances: It is a new trend that is showing up in other articles.  See [[Baby Daisy]].
##Sports Appearances: They are separated per MarioWiki policy (if you're interested I can find the exact page that says this)
##Quotes: Done.
##Image Gallery: I contacted RAP for assistance.
##Screenshots: I've never heard of such a screenshot gallery being unaccepatable, but it's not a big issue, would you still like it gone?
#Nothing Wrong With the Page: Do the changes mean you get to keep your left foot now? :)  Thanks for your concerns. {{User:Stumpers/sig}} 02:36, 20 July 2008 (EDT)

Revision as of 02:36, July 20, 2008

"Baby Peach" was nominated for featured article status at 15:09, 30 June 2008. If the nomination does not pass by 15:09, 29 August 2008, it will be considered failed.

Baby Peach

Support

  1. Stumpers (talk) - The article covers all the bases I can think of: the biography is detailed, personality/appearance is covered, cameos are covered in accordance to a proposal that is about to pass, the image gallery contains a screenshot and artwork from each of her appearances, and the Official Profiles and Statistics section is as full as we can make it until Sluggers comes out in English.
  2. Pikax (talk) - I too can see nothing wrong with the article.
  3. theused (talk) - Per Pikax.
  4. Starry Parakarry (talk) - Per all. Plus, there are tons of pictures!
  5. Luigi3000 (talk) - Ditto.And your right lots of pictures!
  6. Toadette 4evur (talk) Per all.
  7. Moonshine (talk) - Yeah, I change my vote. I think it's ready now.
  8. Baby Luigi Bros Good article with lot's of info.

Oppose

  1. MarioKun (talk) - The page doesn't correspond with other character pages. See more in comments.
  2. ForeverDaisy09 (talk) - All I need is for someone to make the gallery center properly, and a bigger interactions section.

Comments

Shouldn't the agre reversal section be in a sort of Other Media section of it's own? the cartoon and the video games aren't really part of the same canon. Also, the baseball image is flying out of the section into the lower one. Meaning it doesn't fit at all. the Mario Kart picture is a little too low as well. The Bowsers Mass Kidnaping picture is also too low/big. Like I said in my oppose, the page doesn't correspond with other character pages. Cameo appearances, and then list of appearances? Weather an appearance is cameo or not, if there is reasonable info it should go in the bigraphy, and I think sports appearances should as well. Look at the Daisy page. Do you see how it's made it's biography section mainly out of sports appearances? How does that not make sense. also, the list of appearances uses a table sort of thing. Should this be applied to other pages? I've never seen it before. In the quotes those need to be in a cartoon section of their own. Like keep them there but put a header above them in the quotes section to identify them as from the cartoon. the image gallery isn't centered, and the screenshots use the same screenshots from the page, i saw that there was a proposal to use the same art in the section for art and the page at least once, but nothing about screenshots. Nothing wrong with the page, my left foot. MarioKun

User:Elise The article meets the requirements but if it bothers you so much I fix it a little. But not all articles are going to look alike.

Just to adress MarioKun's comments:

  1. Age Reversal: Fixed.
  2. Baseball Image: Fixed.
  3. Low, Big, etc: What do you mean by low? Resolution?
  4. Style Correspondence:
    1. Cameo Section: Per a new proposal that passed, it is okay.
    2. List of Appearances: It is a new trend that is showing up in other articles. See Baby Daisy.
    3. Sports Appearances: They are separated per MarioWiki policy (if you're interested I can find the exact page that says this)
    4. Quotes: Done.
    5. Image Gallery: I contacted RAP for assistance.
    6. Screenshots: I've never heard of such a screenshot gallery being unaccepatable, but it's not a big issue, would you still like it gone?
  5. Nothing Wrong With the Page: Do the changes mean you get to keep your left foot now? :) Thanks for your concerns. Stumpers! 02:36, 20 July 2008 (EDT)
Retrieved from "https://www.mariowiki.com/index.php?title=MarioWiki:Featured_articles/N1/Baby_Peach&oldid=416340"