Template:Proposal: Difference between revisions

From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
(Mine is the latest (nothing against the existing one))
(please shorten it)
Line 1: Line 1:
== Repeated Info, Pointless Pages? ==
== Repeated Info, Pointless Pages? ==
If you look at the [[Final Smash]] page, you'll see that each one is listed in a table, along with a fairly large amount of info about it. Each one has a link to the page that is specifically about that particular Final Smash (e.g. the Aura Storm has its own page, etc). I've read these individual separate pages, and their info is practically the same as what it says on the main Final Smash page. So, are these small pages kind of pointless? In fact, some of the descriptions on the FS page are more detailed than on the page they link to, as they contain info about damage percentages and stuff.  
If you look at the [[Final Smash]] page, you'll see that each one is listed in a table, along with a fairly large amount of info about it. Each one has a link to the page that is specifically about that particular Final Smash (e.g. the Aura Storm has its own page, etc). I've read these individual separate pages, and their info is practically the same as what it says on the main Final Smash page. So, are these small pages kind of pointless? In fact, some of the descriptions on the FS page are more detailed than on the page they link to, as they contain info about damage percentages and stuff. {{proposal-link|Repeated Info, Pointless Pages?}}
 
I think either one of these options should be considered: We either remove all the individual FS pages (as in [[End of Day]], [[Mario Finale]], etc) and make the info in the table of Final Smash page more detailed...
 
OR we only include very small amounts of info on the main Final Smash page, so that it's actually worth having the linked pages.
 


'''Proposer''': {{User|Dom}}<br>
'''Proposer''': {{User|Dom}}<br>
'''Deadline''': July 12, 2008, 20:00
'''Deadline''': July 12, 2008, 20:00
{{proposal-link|Repeated Info, Pointless Pages?}}

Revision as of 06:13, July 6, 2008

Repeated Info, Pointless Pages?

If you look at the Final Smash page, you'll see that each one is listed in a table, along with a fairly large amount of info about it. Each one has a link to the page that is specifically about that particular Final Smash (e.g. the Aura Storm has its own page, etc). I've read these individual separate pages, and their info is practically the same as what it says on the main Final Smash page. So, are these small pages kind of pointless? In fact, some of the descriptions on the FS page are more detailed than on the page they link to, as they contain info about damage percentages and stuff. (more...)

Proposer: Dom (talk)
Deadline: July 12, 2008, 20:00