Talk:Banana: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
|||
Line 98: | Line 98: | ||
#{{User|Iamthedude}} Per Arend. If we're gonna have articles about those giant enemies, which behave the same except they're bigger, why not have a seperate article about a giant item that DOESN'T work the same as it's smaller counterpart. | #{{User|Iamthedude}} Per Arend. If we're gonna have articles about those giant enemies, which behave the same except they're bigger, why not have a seperate article about a giant item that DOESN'T work the same as it's smaller counterpart. | ||
#{{User|MarioMaster720}} Per Arend. | #{{User|MarioMaster720}} Per Arend. | ||
#{{User|Shadow34}} Per Arend. | |||
===Keep Merged=== | ===Keep Merged=== |
Revision as of 20:04, June 27, 2011
Merge Triple Bananas and Giant Banana into the general Banana article
Template:SettledTPP MERGE ARTICLES 4-1-0-0
I read the articles and Triple Bananas are the same as a single Banana, and The Banana article already explains about Giant Bananas (in the Mario Kart Double Dash section, so I propose we combine them into one article.
Proposer: Red Shell 68066vr (talk) Merge Both articles
Merge only Triple Bananas
Merge only Giant Banana
Leave unmerged
Comments
OK, I don't think that this proposal is right because we have the Banana Bunch article and the triple bananas seem to fit perfectly in it. As for the Giant Banana, I you think that should be merged with the (normal) banana article, then you should merge the other giant variants into their corresponding normal-items' articles as well (IE: Giant Green Shell, Giant Bob-omb, etc). ¢oincoll€ctor
|
Mario Kart Bananas
I've discovered that, in Mario kart Wii and DS, triple bananas are a good defensive item, seeing as you can survive three shells and still be going at a constant speed J-Yoshi64 (talk)
Split Banana and Banana Bunch
Template:SettledTPP NO SPLIT 4-8
Bananas are single items, different from 5 or 10 bananas in one. They are found in different areas, and they are worth more than one. I honestly think this should have it's own page. I also know that Banana Bunch is not a section on this page, but it redirects to here.
Proposer: DKPetey99 (talk) Split
Keep
CommentsOh, don't forget! Two weeks is the proposal time!!Reddragon19k 16:37, 12 June 2011 (EDT) |
Banana and Banana Peel
This talk page section contains an unresolved talk page proposal. Please try to help and resolve the issue by voting or leaving a comment. |
Current time: Friday, September 27, 2024, 12:30 GMT
Why are these merged? Bananas and Banana Peels are two completely different things.Bananas from the Donkey Kong series are like coins,are not opened,and don't have a face.Banana Peels from the Mario Kart series are completely different.They serve as obstacles and they look different too.They arent even bananas,theyre just the peels.These were never intended to be the same thing.As LGM said,Bananas are used for various reasons,while Banana Peels are always used to slip people.
Proposer: yoshiyoshiyoshi (talk)
Deadline: June 27, 2011, 23:59 GMT
Split
Keep Merged
- LeftyGreenMario (talk) Mario Kart, Super Smash Bros. Brawl, Mario Party, Mario comics, Luigi's Mansion, Mario Tennis, Mario Strikers, and Mario Sports Mix have banana peels. Donkey Kong games, Mario Party, Yoshi Story, WarioWario, and Super Mario Sunshine have bananas not used to slip people. It's too complicated. Bananas are used as a way to get coins in DK minigames, but they can be also used as obstacles in the same games (Mass A-Peel is a great example). You are using a general solution to fix something complicated. Mario Kart 64's item's picture is a full banana anyway.
- Mario4Ever (talk) Per LGM.
- Reddragon19k (talk) Per all! Stay merged!
- UltraMario3000 (talk) Per LaeftehGraenMalleo.
- Superfiremario (talk) Per all.
- Walkazo (talk) - Per LeftyGreenMario. Banana peels are just, well, peeled bananas; it makes the most sense to write about all their appearances in one place, rather than forcing people to toggle back and forth to get all their banana-related info.
- Xzelion (talk) – Per all.
Comments
This is the an article on bananas in general. If you're going to split the two based on function, you may as well split everything else. It's me, Mario! (Talk / Stalk) 22:32, 13 June 2011 (EDT)
Split Giant Banana and Banana
This talk page section contains an unresolved talk page proposal. Please try to help and resolve the issue by voting or leaving a comment. |
Current time: Friday, September 27, 2024, 12:30 GMT
Giant Bananas have official names appear in multiple games and on top of that split off into multiple bananas when hit i don't see any reason why they are merged with regular bananas and i think they should be split much like how Giant Bob-omb is split from Bob-omb they are different items with similar effects but they are not the same.
Proposer: Goomba's Shoe15 (talk)
Deadline: July 3, 2011, 23:59 GMT
Split
- Goomba's Shoe15 (talk) who votes against there own proposal.
- UltraMario3000 (talk) Per the size 15 Goomba shoes.
- Nicke8 (talk) Per Gs15.
- Arend (talk) Per the fact we have articles about giant enemies.
- Iamthedude (talk) Per Arend. If we're gonna have articles about those giant enemies, which behave the same except they're bigger, why not have a seperate article about a giant item that DOESN'T work the same as it's smaller counterpart.
- MarioMaster720 (talk) Per Arend.
- Shadow34 (talk) Per Arend.
Keep Merged
- Mario4Ever (talk) A giant banana is still a banana. My reasoning is the same for this as it is for the Banana/Banana Bunch proposal.
- Dr Javelin (talk) There simply isn't enough info to make a whole article on Giant Bananas.
- Bowser's luma (talk) Since Banana Bunch and Triple Bananas are merged, this should stay merged.
- Reddragon19k (talk) Sorry, I like it merged! Per all 3!
- Xzelion (talk) – Per all.
- Walkazo (talk) - Per all; per the TPP that originally merged the pages.
Comments
@Mario4Ever yes a giant banana but is Climbing Koopa not a Koopa Troopa the answer is yes but they aint merged Goomba's Shoe15 (talk)