Talk:Famicom Grand Prix: F1 Race: Difference between revisions

From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
Line 20: Line 20:
===Move only the first two (Michele Rumble, Antonio Gico, and Howard Axel)===
===Move only the first two (Michele Rumble, Antonio Gico, and Howard Axel)===
#{{User|EvieMaybe}} primary choice.
#{{User|EvieMaybe}} primary choice.
#{{User|Arend}} It seems to me that Michele and Gico were the intended names and were misinterpreted on the wiki as "Michel" and "Zico" through the katakana in the manual; not sure about the "Arnold S." name, since it's completely different from "Howard Axel", but at the very least we can mention their in-game name in his article.


===Move only the last (Michel Rumble, Antonio Zico, and Arnold S.)===
===Move only the last (Michel Rumble, Antonio Zico, and Arnold S.)===

Revision as of 12:33, January 15, 2025

Move half the rival drivers in the game to match their in-game names

A Yellow Block from Super Mario World This talk page section contains an unresolved talk page proposal. Please try to help and resolve the issue by voting or leaving a comment.

Current time: Thursday, January 16, 2025, 04:47 GMT

Pages 4 and 5 of the Famicom Grand Prix: F1 Race manual, showing the six rival drivers.
A manual scan showing all six rivals, for visual convenience.

I was watching a video on this game, when right at the start, I noticed something in the intro cutscene (timestamped): The rival drivers' current names seem to be romanized from the Japanese text in the manual (which gives the drivers full names), while the game itself gives them Latin alphabet first names and surname initials. What's more, half of them have different names in the game and in the manual! George Turbo, Bronco Maccini and Panther Pedalf are predictably listed as George.T, Bronco.M, and Panther.P, but...

While Rumble and Antonio are in the same boat and should be a pretty simple, uncontroversial move, our pal Howard/Arnold seems to have a bit of an identity crisis. Should we move the page to Arnold.S (or Arnold S., going by this ol' proposal), or should we keep him as Howard Axel?

I would guess his name change might've been motivated by trying to avoid a lawsuit (a la James Bomb), since it'd be pretty strange if they changed a character's name FROM something unrelated TO the name of a famous person. The question is, does a manual supercede the game?

Proposer: EvieMaybe (talk)
Deadline: January 29, 2025, 23:59 GMT

Move all three (Michele Rumble, Antonio Gico, and Arnold S.)

  1. EvieMaybe (talk) secondary choice.

Move only the first two (Michele Rumble, Antonio Gico, and Howard Axel)

  1. EvieMaybe (talk) primary choice.
  2. Arend (talk) It seems to me that Michele and Gico were the intended names and were misinterpreted on the wiki as "Michel" and "Zico" through the katakana in the manual; not sure about the "Arnold S." name, since it's completely different from "Howard Axel", but at the very least we can mention their in-game name in his article.

Move only the last (Michel Rumble, Antonio Zico, and Arnold S.)

Do not move any (Michel Rumble, Antonio Zico, and Howard Axel)

Commentonio Zico