MarioWiki:Featured articles/N2/Toad

Toad

Support

1. Randombob-omb4761 (talk) I don't see any problems with this article, it looks very long, it has no red links or improvment templates. I never saw this featured.
2. PiranhaPlantLover17 (talk) I think that this article should be nominated because Toad deserves some spotlight. A lot of people always go for the more familiar faces like Mario or Luigi, but rarely anyone veers towards Toad. I love Toad and I think he's pretty awesome. Cute and awesome. And there is so much good information to learn about him. I nominate Toad's article to be recognized as a featured article! Go Toad!

Oppose

1. Time Turner (talk) This article is so packed full of flowery writing that we could write a book using it. Also, perhaps it's because I'm on mobile, but this article looks ridiculously padded. Like someone tried to make it bigger for the sole purpose of making it bigger. I don't know if there's any missing information, or if there are things that should be covered, but these two problems alone cannot be allowed for a featured article. One more thing: "I never saw this featured" is the absolute worst reason to feature something, and should not be used as a valid reason in any circumstance.

Comments

@PirahnaPlantLover, featured articles are based much more on quality than they are on how many people like the character.

Who's online: PhGuy12, Morgan KP, Olofsson, PrincessLover7777, MarioKartMaster, Memelord2020, 1468z, DryBaz, Bee Kirby, The Mario Superstar, ReeceeYT, Porplemontage, Duraner Hawkeye, Coolgamingkidz2004, Luigi1234, RattsT, SuperBallBro, JanMisali, Drake Inferno, Apikachu68, CreativeDolphin42891, Technetium, JMaw9, Ahemtoday, UltraMario, Spiny Bro, Sentient freedom, Kieran376, Pg801180, CBFan5, Mr. Bababoeyh, Nintendo101, Tatanga69420, Doc von Schmeltwick, Pal4, Roiadas, LadySophie17, FlutterJump64, PlugMeister, Perfection

Current Task - Still, still working on rewriting several pages, many not even related to this still-handy link. Status - Intermittently active, returning after Yet Another Hiatus. Talk Rules - Just mind the wiki rules, don't clutter the page, and keep it below the line. If you post a comment on my talk page, check back there, because that's where I may reply more often than not.

18:32, 20 March 2014 (EDT)