Talk:1-Up Super: Difference between revisions

From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
m (Text replacement - "([Pp]roposal|[Ss]ettled)(Outcome|TPP)" to "$1 $2")
 
(20 intermediate revisions by 10 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
==Shouldn't this be merged?==
Shouldn't this be merged with 1-Up Mushroom? All the rest of the Mario & Luigi items have one article each of different types (e.g. Hot, Fiery and TNT Drumsticks all in Drumstick (item)). I think a proposal should be started. {{user:Mario jc/sig}}
Shouldn't this be merged with 1-Up Mushroom? All the rest of the Mario & Luigi items have one article each of different types (e.g. Hot, Fiery and TNT Drumsticks all in Drumstick (item)). I think a proposal should be started. {{user:Mario jc/sig}}
:Well, it is a 1up mushroom after all.Why don't you make a proposal or something?{{User:Mr bones/sig}}
:Well, it is a 1up mushroom after all.Why don't you make a proposal or something?{{User:Mr bones/sig}}
::Maybe I will... {{user:Mario jc/sig}}
::Maybe I will... {{user:Mario jc/sig}}


== Merge [[1-Up Super]] with [[1-Up Mushroom]] ==
==Merge [[1-Up Super]] with [[1-Up Mushroom]]==
 
{{settled TPP}}
{{TPP}}
{{Proposal outcome|passed|4-3|merge}}
I really think this article [[1-Up Super]] should be merged with the original [[1-Up Mushroom]] article itself, because all the rest of the Mario & Luigi items are in their respective categories instead of separate articles (e.g. Super, Ultra and Max Mushrooms are all in the Mushroom article). So I suggest that this one should do the same.
I really think this article [[1-Up Super]] should be merged with the original [[1-Up Mushroom]] article itself, because all the rest of the Mario & Luigi items are in their respective categories instead of separate articles (e.g. Super, Ultra and Max Mushrooms are all in the Mushroom article). So I suggest that this one should do the same.


Line 14: Line 15:
#{{User|Mr bones}} It is a 1 up mushroom.Like the drumstick article.It should be merged with it.Also, Mario jc?You created the proposal so you have to support it.
#{{User|Mr bones}} It is a 1 up mushroom.Like the drumstick article.It should be merged with it.Also, Mario jc?You created the proposal so you have to support it.
#{{user|Mario jc}} Per what I just said at the top. And yes, this ''is'' a 1-up Mushroom.
#{{user|Mario jc}} Per what I just said at the top. And yes, this ''is'' a 1-up Mushroom.
#{{User|geniusguy445}} Ok. It can be merged as long as someone can weave the 1-up mushroom, the 1-up, super and the mushroom together. If that can be done, i approve.
#{{User|Commander Code-8}} Per Mr Bones


===Oppose===
===Oppose===
#{{User|KS3}} This should be merged into the [[Mushroom]] article itself, with all the rest of the RPG mushrooms.
#{{User|KS3}} This should be merged into the [[Mushroom]] article itself, with all the rest of the RPG mushrooms.
#{{User|Walkazo}} - It's both a Super Mushroom and a 1-Up Mushroom, so merging it with either would be a mistake, as would sticking it into the Mushroom article: it's unique, and should remain as a stand-alone article.
#{{User|Walkazo}} - It's both a Super Mushroom and a 1-Up Mushroom, so merging it with either would be a mistake, as would sticking it into the Mushroom article: it's unique, and should remain as a stand-alone article.
#{{User|Geniusguy445}} I suggest merging Mushroom with 1-up super. 1-up mushrooms are different. Both mushrooms and 1-up supers are in the rpg's and 1-up mushrooms are not. This is like proposing to merge it with super mushrooms. (don't) Some things are just too different. Merge things that are similar. '''Note:''' 1-up supers are '''not''' 1-up mushrooms. The super is just named similarly. "It is named after the 1-Up Mushroom and the Super Mushroom." However, you ''could'' make a reference that supers are the RPGs 1-up mushrooms. Also, 1-ups are not as frequent in the RPGs. They are in many, many other games. In these types of cases, many items receive their own page when enough info is available from other games. That's all i was saying.
#{{User|Geniusguy445}} My biggest concern is that someone would not be able to write a page that can join the three together. Oh, and if you join two, join the third. My argument was that Everyone recognizes the super mushroom and the 1-up, but the 1-up super and the mushroom is only in the RPG's. Again, if they're joined, please keep them as easy to find/ understand as before. Most articles do that. If this can't, forget it.               ->                        '''My vote is to ''support'' '''


===Comments===
===Comments===
Regarding to Geniusguy445's opposing comment - Uh, 1-up mushrooms did appear in the RPG games, specifically Mario & Luigi PRG games. {{user|Mario jc}}
Regarding to Geniusguy445's opposing comment - Uh, 1-up mushrooms did appear in the RPG games, specifically Mario & Luigi PRG games. {{user|Mario jc}}
Regarding to Geniusguy445's supporting comment - Just wanted to say that we're only merging 1-up super to 1-up mushroom, not any other mushrooms. {{user|Mario jc}}
{{user|Geniusguy445}} i propose all three. http://www.mariowiki.com/Talk:1-Up_Mushroom

Latest revision as of 15:29, May 31, 2024

Shouldn't this be merged?[edit]

Shouldn't this be merged with 1-Up Mushroom? All the rest of the Mario & Luigi items have one article each of different types (e.g. Hot, Fiery and TNT Drumsticks all in Drumstick (item)). I think a proposal should be started. Small Mario sprite from Super Mario Bros. Mario JC

Well, it is a 1up mushroom after all.Why don't you make a proposal or something?Dry Bones in Paper MarioCount Bonsula I need blood...Ml2 drybones.png
Maybe I will... Small Mario sprite from Super Mario Bros. Mario JC

Merge 1-Up Super with 1-Up Mushroom[edit]

Brown Block This talk page proposal has already been settled. Please do not edit this section or its subsections. If you wish to discuss the article, please do so in a new section below the proposal.

merge 4-3
I really think this article 1-Up Super should be merged with the original 1-Up Mushroom article itself, because all the rest of the Mario & Luigi items are in their respective categories instead of separate articles (e.g. Super, Ultra and Max Mushrooms are all in the Mushroom article). So I suggest that this one should do the same.

Proposer: Mario jc (talk)
Deadline: May 21st 2010, 23:59 May 28th 2010, 23:59 June 4th 2010, 23:59

Support[edit]

  1. Mr bones (talk) It is a 1 up mushroom.Like the drumstick article.It should be merged with it.Also, Mario jc?You created the proposal so you have to support it.
  2. Mario jc (talk) Per what I just said at the top. And yes, this is a 1-up Mushroom.
  3. geniusguy445 (talk) Ok. It can be merged as long as someone can weave the 1-up mushroom, the 1-up, super and the mushroom together. If that can be done, i approve.
  4. Commander Code-8 (talk) Per Mr Bones

Oppose[edit]

  1. KS3 (talk) This should be merged into the Mushroom article itself, with all the rest of the RPG mushrooms.
  2. Walkazo (talk) - It's both a Super Mushroom and a 1-Up Mushroom, so merging it with either would be a mistake, as would sticking it into the Mushroom article: it's unique, and should remain as a stand-alone article.
  3. Geniusguy445 (talk) My biggest concern is that someone would not be able to write a page that can join the three together. Oh, and if you join two, join the third. My argument was that Everyone recognizes the super mushroom and the 1-up, but the 1-up super and the mushroom is only in the RPG's. Again, if they're joined, please keep them as easy to find/ understand as before. Most articles do that. If this can't, forget it. -> My vote is to support

Comments[edit]

Regarding to Geniusguy445's opposing comment - Uh, 1-up mushrooms did appear in the RPG games, specifically Mario & Luigi PRG games. Mario jc (talk)

Regarding to Geniusguy445's supporting comment - Just wanted to say that we're only merging 1-up super to 1-up mushroom, not any other mushrooms. Mario jc (talk)

Geniusguy445 (talk) i propose all three. http://www.mariowiki.com/Talk:1-Up_Mushroom

Retrieved from "https://www.mariowiki.com/index.php?title=Talk:1-Up_Super&oldid=4236837"