Talk:Double Dash!!

Merge to Rocket Start

This talk page proposal has already been settled. Please do not edit any of the sections in the proposal. If you wish to discuss the article, do so in a new header below the proposal.

merge to rocket start 18-15

The Double Dash!! is indeed a type of Rocket Start so in this proposal, we're going to find out, should this be merged, or not? The article is short but, we want to merge it.

Proposer: Reddragon19k (talk)
Deadline: April 29, 2011, 23:59 GMT Extended: May 6, 2011, 23:59 GMT, May 13, 2011, 23:59 GMT, May 20, 2011, 23:59 GMT, May 27, 2011, 23:59 GMT, June 3, 2011, 23:59 GMT

Merge to Rocket Start

1. Reddragon19k (talk) Per my Proposal and myself!
2. UltraMario3000 (talk) Per the 19000 Red Dragons.
3. Tails777 (talk) A Double Dash is basically the same as a Rocket Start only faster. No point keeping the 2 separate.
4. SWFlash (talk) They are so same, except for the fact that both players should do it instead of one.
5. Zero777 (talk) I guess it's not too much to ask for it to have its own section.
6. Mario4Ever (talk) Just because a Double Dash cannot be performed without another person does not mean it is not a Rocket Start. Per above.
7. Mariomario64 (talk) Per all.
8. yoshiyoshiyoshi (talk) per all
9. DK and Diddy Kong vs Bowser and Bowser Jr. (talk) Per all.
10. Master Crash (talk) The article is relatively small, and is practically the same thing as Rocket Start.
11. Papero (talk) Double Dash is just a stronger Rocket Start variation where two people simultaneously make the same input for a Rocket Start. That's all there is to it.
12. Mpeng (talk)From what I can tell, Double Dash is a KIND of Rocket Start.
13. MarioManiac (talk) Per all.
14. Walkazo (talk) - Per all.
15. Dr Javelin (talk) Double Dash is a variation of Rocket Start that was only featured in one game. Why do we need an entire article on it? All it deserves is its own section in the Rocket Start article.
16. Reversed (talk) They are similar in some ways, but make sure viewers know the difference.
17. Xzelion (talk) – Per all.
18. Mario Fan 123 (talk) It's the same thing, per all.

Leave un-merged

1. Goomba's Shoe15 (talk) But there different functions since this one can only be done in co-op mode while the other can be done in any mode
2. Nicke8 (talk) Per the guy above me.
3. BabyLuigiOnFire (talk) No, they are completely different things. A Double-Dash can only be found in Mario Kart Double Dash and looks significantly different with different sound effects while a Rocket Start is found everywhere else. You cannot execute a Double Dash when playing by yourself, but you can execute either a Rocket Start or a Double Dash when you are with two players. I think we should leave it like this.
4. Bop1996 (talk) Per BLOF.
5. Yoshiwaker (talk) Should we merge Mushroom and Super Shroom? They only look different, Super Shroom heals more HP and costs more! (Sarcasm meter:10/10) Oh, and per all.
6. LeftyGreenMario (talk) Per Yoshiwaker's analogy. Although I can see this merged, I also can see this left unmerged. I think it should be left unmerged. Double Dash!! has a bigger difference with Rocket Start compared to Mushroom and Super Mushroom.
7. Magikrazy51 (talk) Per all.
8. Marioguy1 (talk) - I haven't played Double Dash before, but from what I see, the Rocket Start and the Double Dash are two totally different concepts; the only thing that is similar is that they both speed you up. I don't think that's enough similarities to claim that these two are the same thing (which, essentially, is what merging claims automatically). Aside from that, I really hope nobody is supporting this because the articles are "stubs".
9. theguywithtwohats (talk) Per all.
10. Mariomaster228 (talk) Per all.
11. kirby9612 (talk)I certainly think this article shouldnt be merged because you press different buttons on a double dash and its in multiplayer only.
12. Mario vs Luigi (talk) per kirby9612.
13. Bowser's luma (talk) Per all.
14. Bowser Jr And Tom The Atum (talk) They are two separate things. Why should they be merged?
15. Iamthedude (talk) Per All. Double dash only appears in one mario kart game and can only be performed in co-op mode, making it a seperate thing.

Comments

I was going to oppose but I need to hear more because there is a big difference between the two, but I'm pulled by the fact that we can just have a section on it. Zero777 (talk)

@Zero That's great! Having a section is awesome but, I think I'm going to agree with you on this one! Reddragon19k (talk)

@Kaptain K Rool Because one requires only one player the other requires two Goomba's Shoe15 (talk)

@Zero: I don't think the Rocket Start article needs the Double Dash info on it, that wouldn't work too well... Even if it would, I'd rather use {{Template:Main}} and just give it a passing mention on the Rocket Start article. Bop1996 _(Talk) 12:05, 18 April 2011 (EDT)

But really I don't see the problem of just putting it as a section in the in the Rocket Start article since it doesn't have that much of a difference and information. Zero777 (talk)

If that's the case, I'd rather say something like, "There is a special version of the Rocket Start that appears in Mario Kart: Double Dash! It requires two players to execute, and it gives a much faster boost than a normal Rocket Start." and then use the main template up there to link here... Bop1996 _(Talk) 07:23, 19 April 2011 (EDT)

Well I don't see the point of that since you basically explained everything in a more simplified form. Zero777 (talk)

I don't think it's very good logic to say well a double dash is a type of Rocket start and thats why it should be merged cause using that logic Beach Koopas should be merged with Koopa Troopas since a Beach Koopas is just a Koopa Troopa with out a shell Goomba's Shoe15 (talk)

Your use of logic is fallacious. It is perfectly sound logic to assert that one thing is a type of another, as merges are done on the basis of two or more things being alike. Beach Koopas aren't merged with Koopa Troopas because the length of the former makes it impractical to merge it with the latter. If there is something that cannot be explained efficiently within the confines of a given article, that content gets its own article. Mario4Ever (talk)

But that fails to keep up with consistency and by saying that it is a type of one thing you are implying that it is not the same thing there Reddragon19k presents no argument to support a merge other than that the two are a type of each other and im saying tha if you want to play the consistency game which everybody likes to claim they play you would have to merge every other sub-species into the main article other wise you create an exception which isn't based on previous standards presented in this proposal Goomba's Shoe15 (talk)

First of all, I would appreciate it if you would punctuate your sentences. Doing so will make you easier to understand. Second, you're still not making any logical sense. How exactly does saying that something is a type of something (i.e. a shark is a type of fish) imply that two objects are not the same, at least in that respect? Third, what standards have been presented in this proposal? All I see is a point of contention over whether or not a Double Dash!! is a Rocket Start, nothing more. As far as consistency goes, most matters on the wiki are dealt with on a case-by-case basis, unless they are similar to one another. Being consistent is not always synonymous with doing what is best for the wiki. Mario4Ever (talk)

I don't know how to explain this more: Double Dashes are better than rocket starts, look different, sound different, and are used in a different way. That is more than enough difference to keep them split. Yoshiwaker (talk)

On the Mushroom-Super Shroom comparison, those are items. Items that can be used differently for recipes and events, sold and bought at different prices, found in different locations, and have been in several games with different effects. A Double Dash is a move that's only been in one game and has the same input, same timing window, and used the same way as a Rocket Boost, the only difference being the strength and for two people to do the input for a Rocket Boost at the same time. The different sounds and graphics only indicate that it's been pulled off successfully and don't have any in-game effects to be aware of. Papero (talk)

So why would you merge two different things it doesnt make sense to merge a variation of something when it acts as a stronger version of something Goomba's Shoe15 (talk)

It's provides the same thing as a Rocket Boost provides: A speed boost at the start. As M4E said, it's just a type of Rocket Boost. Papero (talk)

Putrid Piranhas are a kind of Piranha Plant, should we merge them? No, they're similar, but different things, so they should be split. Yoshiwaker (talk)

Mario & Luigi's items have Super Mushroom and Mushroom, but I believe those are in different articles. And Mario & Luigi doesn't use recipes. It's me, Mario! (Talk / Stalk) 04:32, 21 May 2011 (EDT)

We need an extension limit for sure. It shouldn't last forever. SWFlash