MarioWiki:Featured articles/Unfeature/N1/Kirby: Difference between revisions
From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
| Line 17: | Line 17: | ||
#{{User|Time Q}}: The comics are indeed rare, but I have most of them, so I ''could'' add more images (if I find some time). Anyways, he doesn't prove the proposer's points wrong, so his vote is invalid. | #{{User|Time Q}}: The comics are indeed rare, but I have most of them, so I ''could'' add more images (if I find some time). Anyways, he doesn't prove the proposer's points wrong, so his vote is invalid. | ||
#{{User|Commander Code-8}} Per Time Q. | #{{User|Commander Code-8}} Per Time Q. | ||
#{{User|Marioguy1}} - Well, inadequate sources for images is ''not'' a valid reason. If there are not enough sources then obviously, the article cannot have excellent content and without excellent content we wouldn't be providing the best we have on the wiki, would we? | |||
'''KS3''' | '''KS3''' | ||
#{{User|Time Q}}: As long as it isn't fixed, this is an invalid reason. | #{{User|Time Q}}: As long as it isn't fixed, this is an invalid reason. | ||
#{{User|Commander Code-8}} Per Time Q | #{{User|Commander Code-8}} Per Time Q | ||
#{{User|Marioguy1}} - Time Q ''said'' he can fix it, whether he can or can't is also a matter of whether he will or won't and now we have gotten into so many "what ifs" that the article has no proof that it will ''ever'' be fixed! Long story short - renominate this article after he fixes it. | |||
==== Comments ==== | ==== Comments ==== | ||
GameFreak75: When you say the article's longer than most other FAs, You'd clearly forgotten that it's just longer because of all the images displaying Kirby's forms. {{User|Commander Code-8}} | GameFreak75: When you say the article's longer than most other FAs, You'd clearly forgotten that it's just longer because of all the images displaying Kirby's forms. {{User|Commander Code-8}} | ||
Revision as of 18:10, April 23, 2010
Kirby
Remove Featured Article Status
- Commander Code-8 (talk) The comics sections barely tell us anything, and they need more images. until those issues are resolved this article shouldn't be Featured.
Keep Featured Article Status
- Reversinator (talk) Lenght-wise, the sections are ok, and comics are pretty rare, so getting images would be like finding a needle in a haystack.
- KS3 (talk) Time Q can fix it.
- Gamefreak75 (talk) There is no problem with this. The comics cannot be expanded (or by my standards). The whole article is longer than half the featured articles there are. This article has plenty of pictures and has detailed descriptions. I say keep this.
Removal of Support/Oppose Votes
Reversinator
- Time Q (talk): The comics are indeed rare, but I have most of them, so I could add more images (if I find some time). Anyways, he doesn't prove the proposer's points wrong, so his vote is invalid.
- Commander Code-8 (talk) Per Time Q.
- Marioguy1 (talk) - Well, inadequate sources for images is not a valid reason. If there are not enough sources then obviously, the article cannot have excellent content and without excellent content we wouldn't be providing the best we have on the wiki, would we?
KS3
- Time Q (talk): As long as it isn't fixed, this is an invalid reason.
- Commander Code-8 (talk) Per Time Q
- Marioguy1 (talk) - Time Q said he can fix it, whether he can or can't is also a matter of whether he will or won't and now we have gotten into so many "what ifs" that the article has no proof that it will ever be fixed! Long story short - renominate this article after he fixes it.
Comments
GameFreak75: When you say the article's longer than most other FAs, You'd clearly forgotten that it's just longer because of all the images displaying Kirby's forms. Commander Code-8 (talk)
