User talk:SolemnStormcloud: Difference between revisions
From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
No edit summary |
7feetunder (talk | contribs) (→Bandit) |
||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
I don't agree with making things subcategories based on a majority, so I don't think Bandits should be a subcategory of thieves. {{User:7feetunder/sig}} 19:09, November 7, 2021 (EST) | I don't agree with making things subcategories based on a majority, so I don't think Bandits should be a subcategory of thieves. {{User:7feetunder/sig}} 19:09, November 7, 2021 (EST) | ||
:That's a fair point, but what about [[:Category:Lava Bubbles]] being under [[:Category:Fire creatures]] despite containing the non-fiery [[Poison Bubble]]? Or some subjects in [[:Category:Ghosts]] not being [[:Category:Undead|undead]] (e.g. [[Bonneter]])? A number of a category's subjects not applying under a subcategory is not new. [[User:ShootingStar7X|ShootingStar7X]] ([[User talk:ShootingStar7X|talk]]) 19:18, November 7, 2021 (EST) | :That's a fair point, but what about [[:Category:Lava Bubbles]] being under [[:Category:Fire creatures]] despite containing the non-fiery [[Poison Bubble]]? Or some subjects in [[:Category:Ghosts]] not being [[:Category:Undead|undead]] (e.g. [[Bonneter]])? A number of a category's subjects not applying under a subcategory is not new. [[User:ShootingStar7X|ShootingStar7X]] ([[User talk:ShootingStar7X|talk]]) 19:18, November 7, 2021 (EST) | ||
::I don't think ghosts should be a subcategory of undead either - a large chunk of them do not qualify (e.g. every normal ghost in ''Luigi's Mansion''). As for Poison Bubbles, just because they're poisonous doesn't mean they aren't fiery; they could be both based on their appearance, which is just a palette swap of the normal Lava Bubble. Either way, this should at least be discussed first, especially since it inevitably brings up the question of how many/what percentage of exceptions are allowed before it can still remain a subcategory. {{User:7feetunder/sig}} 19:39, November 7, 2021 (EST) | |||
Revision as of 19:39, November 7, 2021
Bandit
I don't agree with making things subcategories based on a majority, so I don't think Bandits should be a subcategory of thieves. 
19:09, November 7, 2021 (EST)
- That's a fair point, but what about Category:Lava Bubbles being under Category:Fire creatures despite containing the non-fiery Poison Bubble? Or some subjects in Category:Ghosts not being undead (e.g. Bonneter)? A number of a category's subjects not applying under a subcategory is not new. ShootingStar7X (talk) 19:18, November 7, 2021 (EST)
- I don't think ghosts should be a subcategory of undead either - a large chunk of them do not qualify (e.g. every normal ghost in Luigi's Mansion). As for Poison Bubbles, just because they're poisonous doesn't mean they aren't fiery; they could be both based on their appearance, which is just a palette swap of the normal Lava Bubble. Either way, this should at least be discussed first, especially since it inevitably brings up the question of how many/what percentage of exceptions are allowed before it can still remain a subcategory. 19:39, November 7, 2021 (EST)
- I don't think ghosts should be a subcategory of undead either - a large chunk of them do not qualify (e.g. every normal ghost in Luigi's Mansion). As for Poison Bubbles, just because they're poisonous doesn't mean they aren't fiery; they could be both based on their appearance, which is just a palette swap of the normal Lava Bubble. Either way, this should at least be discussed first, especially since it inevitably brings up the question of how many/what percentage of exceptions are allowed before it can still remain a subcategory.
