Talk:Clog: Difference between revisions
LinkTheLefty (talk | contribs) (Created page with "=="Species/Character"== {{talk}} Recently, Clog was moved to "Clog (species)" and the conjectural Clog Monster was moved to "Clog (character)". Checking the episodes on the wi...") |
LinkTheLefty (talk | contribs) mNo edit summary |
||
| (4 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
=="Species/Character"== | =="Species/Character"== | ||
Recently, Clog was moved to "Clog (species)" and the conjectural Clog Monster was moved to "Clog (character)". Checking the episodes on the wiki in question out, I think this is completely off. The only time it has a direct name is as "Clog" in Tutti Frutti, Oh Mario and Toupee. In Wild Thing, two Clog-like creatures make a minor appearance, but they're not referred to in any way and their presence is quickly forgotten. I don't think that's enough to classify it with a "species" identifier since the two aforementioned episodes use it in the context of an individual name. They also seem to have a slightly different appearance from Clog, with what looks like one horn/eye(?) each. Regarding the "character" in The Marios Fight Back, that one isn't referred to directly by name either; the "clog" here is a generic, inanimate one in the sink, and the most said about the mutant in particular is "you created a monster" by the guest. I suggest moving this article back to its previous state, and either moving the monster article back to "Clog Monster" or possibly calling it "Monster (''The Super Mario Bros. Super Show!'')" instead. [[User:LinkTheLefty|LinkTheLefty]] ([[User talk:LinkTheLefty|talk]]) 14:33, July 29, 2020 (EDT) | |||
Recently, Clog was moved to "Clog (species)" and the conjectural Clog Monster was moved to "Clog (character)". Checking the episodes on the wiki in question out, I think this is completely off. The only time it has a direct name is as "Clog" in Tutti Frutti, Oh Mario and Toupee. In Wild Thing, two Clog-like creatures make a minor appearance, but they're not referred to in any way and their presence is quickly forgotten. I don't think that's enough to classify it with a "species" identifier since the two aforementioned episodes use it in the context of an individual name. They also seem to have a slightly different appearance from Clog, with what looks like one horn/eye(?) each. Regarding the "character" in The Marios Fight Back, that one isn't referred to directly by name either; the "clog" here is a generic, inanimate one in the sink, and the most said about the mutant in particular is "you created a monster" by the guest. I suggest moving this article back to its previous state, and either moving the monster article back to "Clog Monster" or possibly calling it "Monster (''The Super Mario Bros. Super Show!''" instead. [[User:LinkTheLefty|LinkTheLefty]] ([[User talk:LinkTheLefty|talk]]) 14:33, July 29, 2020 (EDT) | |||
The reason I moved it was because Mario and Luigi said the clog cleaner removes all clogs, which is what the clog monster was, an ordinary clog. In hindsight, I probably should’ve put up a talk first. | |||
[[User: Grandet Omate|Grandet Omate]] ([[User talk:Grandet Omate|talk]]) 02:33, August 18, 2020 (EDT) | |||
Latest revision as of 12:37, August 18, 2020
"Species/Character"[edit]
Recently, Clog was moved to "Clog (species)" and the conjectural Clog Monster was moved to "Clog (character)". Checking the episodes on the wiki in question out, I think this is completely off. The only time it has a direct name is as "Clog" in Tutti Frutti, Oh Mario and Toupee. In Wild Thing, two Clog-like creatures make a minor appearance, but they're not referred to in any way and their presence is quickly forgotten. I don't think that's enough to classify it with a "species" identifier since the two aforementioned episodes use it in the context of an individual name. They also seem to have a slightly different appearance from Clog, with what looks like one horn/eye(?) each. Regarding the "character" in The Marios Fight Back, that one isn't referred to directly by name either; the "clog" here is a generic, inanimate one in the sink, and the most said about the mutant in particular is "you created a monster" by the guest. I suggest moving this article back to its previous state, and either moving the monster article back to "Clog Monster" or possibly calling it "Monster (The Super Mario Bros. Super Show!)" instead. LinkTheLefty (talk) 14:33, July 29, 2020 (EDT)
The reason I moved it was because Mario and Luigi said the clog cleaner removes all clogs, which is what the clog monster was, an ordinary clog. In hindsight, I probably should’ve put up a talk first. Grandet Omate (talk) 02:33, August 18, 2020 (EDT)
