Talk:Boo: Difference between revisions
From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
(I"m surprised than there is not much content here.) |
(Post"d my review.) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{PAIRrequest|Phoenix Rider created by mistake one of these "Featured article Nomination" for this page, apparently not knowing about the New PAIR system. Since he nominated it, I supposed it could use a review.|[[User:Gofer|Gofer]]}} | {{PAIRrequest|Phoenix Rider created by mistake one of these "Featured article Nomination" for this page, apparently not knowing about the New PAIR system. Since he nominated it, I supposed it could use a review.|[[User:Gofer|Gofer]]}} | ||
{{PAIRreview | |||
|A-rating=2.9 | |||
|A-comment=Relatively accurate, the only error I found was the "Streche are boo with long body." thing. | |||
|D-rating=2.0 | |||
|D-comment= I found the "What make a Boo a Boo." section quite nice, especially considering than th past Fa Goomba didn't have such a thing. UNfortunately, most of the section is pretty much speculation (The "Bigger Hideout = More powerful Boo" thing is an example.) As for the article,It could use some depth, for example, the SMRPG section don't have much information while the same section on Big Boo have load and load of information. The SUper Paper Mario section is welll, an one-liner, unnceptable. It also lack much information for the spinoff game, esspecially Mario Striker charged. | |||
|G-rating=3.0 | |||
|G-comment=I let soemone else review that. | |||
|I-rating=3.0 | |||
|I-comment=Good, The article could use some more, IMO. | |||
|F-rating=4.0 | |||
|F-comment=Good, no problem here. | |||
|FR-comment=Slighty above average, not FA worthy.Full of POV and speculation, also. | |||
|signature=[[User:Gofer|Gofer]]}} | |||
How are Boos part of the Koopa Troop? They might not directly help Bowser, but just attack Mario when he is in a ghost house or is in their territory. There isn't enough (or no) proof that Boos or its subspecies are part of Bowser's minions.{{User:Knife/sig}} | How are Boos part of the Koopa Troop? They might not directly help Bowser, but just attack Mario when he is in a ghost house or is in their territory. There isn't enough (or no) proof that Boos or its subspecies are part of Bowser's minions.{{User:Knife/sig}} | ||
*there not, there minions of Big/King Boo. He's his own boss. {{User:WarioLoaf/sig}} | *there not, there minions of Big/King Boo. He's his own boss. {{User:WarioLoaf/sig}} | ||
Revision as of 12:36, July 30, 2007
| PAIRreview for Boo by Gofer | ||
| Accuracy | 2.9 | Relatively accurate, the only error I found was the "Streche are boo with long body." thing. |
| Depth | 2.0 | I found the "What make a Boo a Boo." section quite nice, especially considering than th past Fa Goomba didn't have such a thing. UNfortunately, most of the section is pretty much speculation (The "Bigger Hideout = More powerful Boo" thing is an example.) As for the article,It could use some depth, for example, the SMRPG section don't have much information while the same section on Big Boo have load and load of information. The SUper Paper Mario section is welll, an one-liner, unnceptable. It also lack much information for the spinoff game, esspecially Mario Striker charged. |
| Grammar | 3.0 | I let soemone else review that. |
| Images | 3.0 | Good, The article could use some more, IMO. |
| Formatting | 4.0 | Good, no problem here. |
| Final Rating: | 14.9 | Slighty above average, not FA worthy.Full of POV and speculation, also. |
| Reviewer: | Gofer | |
How are Boos part of the Koopa Troop? They might not directly help Bowser, but just attack Mario when he is in a ghost house or is in their territory. There isn't enough (or no) proof that Boos or its subspecies are part of Bowser's minions.Knife (talk)
