Editing User talk:SlayerIbn

== Dear Mario jc -  ==

In my opinion, it is better to give an enemy without an official public name a name that is adapted to English, taking into account that the name of its 3D model is the same, but in its Japanese translation, rather than giving the name of the 3D model directly. I understand that it would be better to leave the internal name of the 3D model if there is no adaptation of the internal name to English (like Takebo), but in a case like Wonder Piranha Plant (PackunWonder internally. Packun is Piranha Plant in Japanese, but this time with a C instead of a K), or Wonder Smackerel (HaidenWonder internally. Haiden is Smackerel in Japanese), the name should be adapted to English. I don't want to say it's official either, so I left the name as a conjectural one. I hope you understand my point of view, and if you disagree, I would like to understand your vision as well. [[User:SlayerIbn|SlayerIbn]] ([[User talk:SlayerIbn|talk]]) 22:58, November 4, 2023 (EDT)

:As [[MarioWiki:Naming#Japanese]] and [[MarioWiki:Japanese#Subjects with Japanese names]] says, the name should be romanised (in this case, it already is), not use its localised/translated name. This is already the case with not just the [[Itsunomanika Heihō]] example on the page, but also other, identical cases like [[Vampire Heyho]], which currently use the original Japanese file name. {{User:Mario jc/sig}} 23:33, November 4, 2023 (EDT)

::I've been discussing this with admins on the Discord server, so maybe you would like to join, if you want to. [[User:SlayerIbn|SlayerIbn]] ([[User talk:SlayerIbn|talk]]) 23:44, November 4, 2023 (EDT)
Latest revision		Your text
Line 1:		Line 1:
	== Dear Mario jc - ~~Enemies name adaptation~~ ==		== Dear Mario jc - ==

	In my opinion, it is better to give an enemy without an official public name a name that is adapted to English, taking into account that the name of its 3D model is the same, but in its Japanese translation, rather than giving the name of the 3D model directly. I understand that it would be better to leave the internal name of the 3D model if there is no adaptation of the internal name to English (like Takebo), but in a case like Wonder Piranha Plant (PackunWonder internally. Packun is Piranha Plant in Japanese, but this time with a C instead of a K), or Wonder Smackerel (HaidenWonder internally. Haiden is Smackerel in Japanese), the name should be adapted to English. I don't want to say it's official either, so I left the name as a conjectural one. I hope you understand my point of view, and if you disagree, I would like to understand your vision as well. [[User:SlayerIbn\|SlayerIbn]] ([[User talk:SlayerIbn\|talk]]) 22:58, November 4, 2023 (EDT)		In my opinion, it is better to give an enemy without an official public name a name that is adapted to English, taking into account that the name of its 3D model is the same, but in its Japanese translation, rather than giving the name of the 3D model directly. I understand that it would be better to leave the internal name of the 3D model if there is no adaptation of the internal name to English (like Takebo), but in a case like Wonder Piranha Plant (PackunWonder internally. Packun is Piranha Plant in Japanese, but this time with a C instead of a K), or Wonder Smackerel (HaidenWonder internally. Haiden is Smackerel in Japanese), the name should be adapted to English. I don't want to say it's official either, so I left the name as a conjectural one. I hope you understand my point of view, and if you disagree, I would like to understand your vision as well. [[User:SlayerIbn\|SlayerIbn]] ([[User talk:SlayerIbn\|talk]]) 22:58, November 4, 2023 (EDT)