Editing Talk:Tucks (bouncing)

==Of Tucks and Pengar==

Honestly, I think the previous "[[Special:Diff/3192682|Pengā]]" version of the article is much better and more accurate than the current "[[Special:Diff/3201438|Tucks (bouncing)]]" version. "''That name won't cut it; regular Tucks share the same Japanese name, so it's just going to be confusing.''" is the reason given for the move. I disagree for several reasons. Right off the bat, the article is now completely off base with the <nowiki>{{another language}}</nowiki> statement at the top of the article - "''The title of this article is official, but it comes from a '''non-English source'''.''" Changing this to <nowiki>{{conjecture}}</nowiki> wouldn't work either for similar reasons. As stated in [[MarioWiki:Naming#Japanese|Naming]], Japanese romanizations are to be used and have been used in general with the main exception being English loanwords. Regarding the shared Japanese name: so? [[Pokey#Names in other languages|Sha]][[Needlenose#Names in other languages|red]] [[Boom Boom#Names in other languages|na]][[Bunbun#Names in other languages|me]][[Bumblebee#Names in other languages|s]] [[Water Land#Names in other languages|i]][[Seaside Kingdom#Names in other languages|n]] [[Forest of Illusion#Names in other languages|o]][[Maze Woods#Names in other languages|n]][[Forever Forest#Names in other languages|e]] [[Honō no Dōkutsu#Names in other languages|lan]][[Cave of Flames#Names in other languages|gua]][[Fiery Cavern#Names in other languages|ge]] [[Karakara Sabaku#Names in other languages|d]][[Kalimari Desert#Names in other languages|o]][[Dry Dry Desert#Names in other languages|n]]'[[Dry Dry Desert (GCN)#Names in other languages|t]] [[Donkey Kong Island#Names in other languages|necess]][[DK Isles#Names in other languages|arily]] [[Bahamutt#Names in other languages|me]][[Dorrie#Names in other languages|an]] [[Snowy#Names in other languages|sha]][[Snowman Doll#names in other languages|red]] [[Enigma#Names in other languages|nam]][[Bat (Super Mario Galaxy)#Names in other languages|es]] [[Mysterious Factory!#Names in other languages|i]][[The Curious Factory#Names in other languages|n]] [[Tiki Zing#Names in other languages|an]][[Tiki Zing (big)#Names in other languages|ot]][[Fireball (Tiki)#Names in other languages|he]][[Tiki Zing (Foggy Fumes)#Names in other languages|r.]] It would be one thing if this was considered the same subject, but it's not. Finally, I personally find the use of identifier in a title contradicting the stated goal of <nowiki>{{another language}}</nowiki> more confusing. At the very least, a proposal-less, policy-breaking move should've had a unanimous discussion. [[User:LinkTheLefty|LinkTheLefty]] ([[User talk:LinkTheLefty|talk]]) 12:45, May 15, 2021 (EDT)