Editing Talk:Preying Mantas
From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then publish the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
| Latest revision | Your text | ||
| Line 15: | Line 15: | ||
== Merge with [[Jellyfish]] == | == Merge with [[Jellyfish]] == | ||
{{ | |||
{{TPP}} | |||
It's just a normal jellyfish with a wacky, but thoroughly obsolete, nickname. Most licensed guidebooks, each for three different releases with decades spacing them out, straight up call them ''[[wiktionary:くらげ|kurage]]'' (Japanese for "jellyfish", the literal animal). It's the Player's Guide for SMW2 that's the odd one out, and let's not forget that it's the same book that calls Cheep Cheeps "Flopsy Fish"/"Piscatory Pete", Ukikis "Grinders", and separates one particular [[Nep-Enut]] from its species just because it's found underground. Before someone inevitably mentions it, I'm not even making a case for how the Japanese books are somehow more authoritative than the English one just because the ''Yoshi's Island'' games themselves were developed in Japan--given the existence of no direct source, such as a manual or the games, to attest the name of this enemy, it's simply a case of 3 different, largely more current sources against 1 source from 1995, all equally official,{{footnote|main|*}} irrespective of their language. | It's just a normal jellyfish with a wacky, but thoroughly obsolete, nickname. Most licensed guidebooks, each for three different releases with decades spacing them out, straight up call them ''[[wiktionary:くらげ|kurage]]'' (Japanese for "jellyfish", the literal animal). It's the Player's Guide for SMW2 that's the odd one out, and let's not forget that it's the same book that calls Cheep Cheeps "Flopsy Fish"/"Piscatory Pete", Ukikis "Grinders", and separates one particular [[Nep-Enut]] from its species just because it's found underground. Before someone inevitably mentions it, I'm not even making a case for how the Japanese books are somehow more authoritative than the English one just because the ''Yoshi's Island'' games themselves were developed in Japan--given the existence of no direct source, such as a manual or the games, to attest the name of this enemy, it's simply a case of 3 different, largely more current sources against 1 source from 1995, all equally official,{{footnote|main|*}} irrespective of their language. | ||
| Line 37: | Line 37: | ||
#{{User|Ray Trace}} I can't say this case is the same as Piscatory Pete and Flopsy Fish. For one, this enemy is the only one here that has reappeared in Yoshi's New Island with an unchanged design (Piscatory Petes do not exist in New Island). I also think it's very distinct compared to generic cases of Jellyfish and it plays distinctly too (you can jump on them and they move up and down.) In addition, [[Dr. Freezegood]] is also simply called "Snowman" in Japanese, yet I would also oppose the merge because it was given a unique name to distinguish itself from other snowmen (also with an unchanged design from the first game rather than using something more generic or [[Mr. Blizzard]] or something). I'd say in this case, it's better off split. | #{{User|Ray Trace}} I can't say this case is the same as Piscatory Pete and Flopsy Fish. For one, this enemy is the only one here that has reappeared in Yoshi's New Island with an unchanged design (Piscatory Petes do not exist in New Island). I also think it's very distinct compared to generic cases of Jellyfish and it plays distinctly too (you can jump on them and they move up and down.) In addition, [[Dr. Freezegood]] is also simply called "Snowman" in Japanese, yet I would also oppose the merge because it was given a unique name to distinguish itself from other snowmen (also with an unchanged design from the first game rather than using something more generic or [[Mr. Blizzard]] or something). I'd say in this case, it's better off split. | ||
#{{User|Waluigi Time}} Per all. | #{{User|Waluigi Time}} Per all. | ||
#{{User|Nintendo101}} I understand the thought process here, but I personally do not think names are the only thing that should be considered when contemplating lumps or splits. I understand this would be less apparent if it was already lumped with generic jellyfish, but this specific subject has a recurring design, function, and is recognized as an “enemy” in the paratext for the games it appears in (namely page 42 in the Shogakukan guidebook, page 128 in the Nintendo Power guidebook, and page 18 in the Nintendo of Europe guidebook). It does not seem to me to be a generic jellyfish, and I do not think it was intended to be understood as one in the same way Dr. Freezegood is likely not supposed to be perceived as a generic snowman despite its Japanese name. I think it would be more accurate for Preying Mantas to retain their article, separate from generic jellyfish. | #{{User|Nintendo101}} I understand the thought process here, but I personally do not think names are the only thing that should be considered when contemplating lumps or splits. I understand this would be less apparent if it was already lumped with generic jellyfish, but this specific subject has a recurring design, function, and is recognized as an “enemy” in the paratext for the games it appears in (namely page 42 in the Shogakukan guidebook, page 128 in the Nintendo Power guidebook, and page 18 in the Nintendo of Europe guidebook). It does not seem to me to be a generic jellyfish, and I do not think it was intended to be understood as one in the same way Dr. Freezegood is likely not supposed to be perceived as a generic snowman despite its Japanese name. I think it would be a more accurate for Preying Mantas to retain their article, separate from generic jellyfish. | ||
#{{User|FanOfYoshi}} Per all | #{{User|FanOfYoshi}} Per all. | ||
====Comments==== | ====Comments==== | ||
| Line 61: | Line 55: | ||
::::::::That "zany 1995 American guide" is licensed by Nintendo and it's the only official name we have in regards to this creature's name, and I think should take priority over Japanese guidebooks which are the same amount of reliability as these guidebooks. This creature is more similar to Dr. Freezegood than it is to Piscatory Pete vs Cheep Cheep with its more stand-out design and behavior endemic to the Yoshi series and I think it's much more servicable and searchable for our readerbase to use the Preying Mantas name in service of that guidebook than it is relying on Japanese names and internal data to tuck away at a barely related catch all species page. {{User:Ray Trace/sig}} 18:53, September 14, 2024 (EDT) | ::::::::That "zany 1995 American guide" is licensed by Nintendo and it's the only official name we have in regards to this creature's name, and I think should take priority over Japanese guidebooks which are the same amount of reliability as these guidebooks. This creature is more similar to Dr. Freezegood than it is to Piscatory Pete vs Cheep Cheep with its more stand-out design and behavior endemic to the Yoshi series and I think it's much more servicable and searchable for our readerbase to use the Preying Mantas name in service of that guidebook than it is relying on Japanese names and internal data to tuck away at a barely related catch all species page. {{User:Ray Trace/sig}} 18:53, September 14, 2024 (EDT) | ||
:::::::::The SEO argument, I also disagree with. The site's purpose is not to cater to what readers project in the series. Misidentifying a subject based on one old guidebook is the opposite of doing a service to people interested in Mario. There are three other guidebooks released at different points in time (one as recently as 2014) that provide a consistent perspective on this enemy; pushing them aside just because they're not English is disingenuous. {{User:Koopa con Carne/Sig}} 19:02, September 14, 2024 (EDT) | :::::::::The SEO argument, I also disagree with. The site's purpose is not to cater to what readers project in the series. Misidentifying a subject based on one old guidebook is the opposite of doing a service to people interested in Mario. There are three other guidebooks released at different points in time (one as recently as 2014) that provide a consistent perspective on this enemy; pushing them aside just because they're not English is disingenuous. {{User:Koopa con Carne/Sig}} 19:02, September 14, 2024 (EDT) | ||
The literature I provided citations for above, including the Japanese source for the name Kurage, categorize Preying Mantas as enemies (i.e. Goombas, Koopas, Shy Guys, Boos), not as obstacles (i.e. typically abiotic subjects). That seems to be of deliberate categorical importance, and not something I personally feel can be comfortably lumped with other subjects. | The literature I provided citations for above, including the Japanese source for the name Kurage, categorize Preying Mantas as enemies (i.e. Goombas, Koopas, Shy Guys, Boos), not as obstacles (i.e. typically abiotic subjects). That seems to be of deliberate categorical importance, and not something I personally feel can be comfortably lumped with other subjects. | ||
I think a relevant point of comparison is that information on Bowser's transformation from the ''Super Mario Bros.'' live-action film and dinosaurs from the ''Super Mario World'' cartoon were removed from the [[T-Rex]] article, because even though it is is based on a real-life species of dinosaur, the article is not generic in scope. It covers the capturable enemy from ''Super Mario Odyssey''. - [[User:Nintendo101|Nintendo101]] ([[User talk:Nintendo101|talk]]) 19:03, September 14, 2024 (EDT) | I think a relevant point of comparison is that information on Bowser's transformation from the ''Super Mario Bros.'' live-action film and dinosaurs from the ''Super Mario World'' cartoon were removed from the [[T-Rex]] article, because even though it is is based on a real-life species of dinosaur, the article is not generic in scope. It covers the capturable enemy from ''Super Mario Odyssey''. - [[User:Nintendo101|Nintendo101]] ([[User talk:Nintendo101|talk]]) 19:03, September 14, 2024 (EDT) | ||
:The Dinosaur article covers dinosaurs in general, the T-Rex one covers one particular member of that group. They'd have stayed split even if the Odyssey T-Rex wasn't capturable. Dinohattanites are also a very peculiar human-like reptilian race that are said to evolve from dinosaurs. Here, there's nothing that points to Preying Mantas being analogous to a particular real species of jellyfish; it's just called a jellyfish. {{User:Koopa con Carne/Sig}} 19:12, September 14, 2024 (EDT) | :The Dinosaur article covers dinosaurs in general, the T-Rex one covers one particular member of that group. They'd have stayed split even if the Odyssey T-Rex wasn't capturable. Dinohattanites are also a very peculiar human-like reptilian race that are said to evolve from dinosaurs. Here, there's nothing that points to Preying Mantas being analogous to a particular real species of jellyfish; it's just called a jellyfish. {{User:Koopa con Carne/Sig}} 19:12, September 14, 2024 (EDT) | ||
::I'm sorry, I may not have conveyed the point I was making in bringing that up. The reason why that information was removed was not because they weren't ''Tyrannosaurus rex'', it was because the article reflects T-Rex in the narrowest sense - [https://www.mariowiki.com/index.php?title=T-Rex&diff=3088992&oldid=3088985 the enemy from ''Super Mario Odyssey'']. I think having an article dedicated to a recurring subject (such as the Preying Mantas) with the same design, behavior, and paratextual systematics across appearances is a sincere reflection of the material in the games and is inherently clarifying that | ::I'm sorry, I may not have conveyed the point I was making in bringing that up. The reason why that information was removed was not because they weren't ''Tyrannosaurus rex'', it was because the article reflects T-Rex in the narrowest sense - [https://www.mariowiki.com/index.php?title=T-Rex&diff=3088992&oldid=3088985 the enemy from ''Super Mario Odyssey'']. I think having an article dedicated to a recurring subject (such as the Preying Mantas) with the same design, behavior, and paratextual systematics across appearances is a sincere reflection of the material in the games and is inherently clarifying that this not a generic subject (or at least that is my impression. Other interpretations are valid). I think my perspective would be a bit different if, say, there was a guidebook released for ''Yoshi's New Island'' that explicitly discussed this subject in a generic context and/or did not categorize it as an enemy. To the best of my knowledge, or at least from the digging I have done for this, no such resources exist (not even a Prima Guidebook, unfortunately). It'd be nice if there was some sort of "Yoshi Portal," but in lieu of something like that or some other contemporary clarification, I do not think I would support lumping it with generic jellyfish subjects. - [[User:Nintendo101|Nintendo101]] ([[User talk:Nintendo101|talk]]) 19:35, September 14, 2024 (EDT) | ||
