Editing Talk:Luigi
From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then publish the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
| Latest revision | Your text | ||
| Line 376: | Line 376: | ||
[[Robo Koopa]]. It's a featured article, and an alter-ego. If we have that article, why can't we have this one? And for an example with Luigi, [[Mr. L]]. {{User:Reversinator/sig}} | [[Robo Koopa]]. It's a featured article, and an alter-ego. If we have that article, why can't we have this one? And for an example with Luigi, [[Mr. L]]. {{User:Reversinator/sig}} | ||
:It's probably going by the logic that merged [[Talk:Leo_Luster|Leo Luster]] with Bluster Kong. I personally would love to see all those personae merged into [[King Koopa's alter egos]] (but maybe give the chart a "summary" section to briefly describe each alter-ego and its role in the corresponding episode). Most of them don't have articles yet anyway, and I feel that lengthy summaries like on [[Robo Koopa]] are a bit unnecessary: people can just read the episode summaries. Video game alter-egos have a bit more to stand on, seeing as their summaries aren't just rehashing a single game's summary, in most cases, but I'd be fine with merging things like [[Dark Fawful]], [[Bowletta]], [[Shrowser]] and possibly even [[Mr. L]], although given the fact that "Mr. L" played such an important role in ''SPM'', I'd also be fine with that article staying. Same deal with [[Dr. Mario]]: he's not a one-hit wonder, and not giving him his own page would look like an omission on our part. - {{User:Walkazo/sig}} 10:40, 4 February 2011 (EST) | :It's probably going by the logic that merged [[Talk:Leo_Luster|Leo Luster]] with Bluster Kong. I personally would love to see all those personae merged into [[King Koopa's alter egos]] (but maybe give the chart a "summary" section to briefly describe each alter-ego and its role in the corresponding episode). Most of them don't have articles yet anyway, and I feel that lengthy summaries like on [[Robo Koopa]] are a bit unnecessary: people can just read the episode summaries. Video game alter-egos have a bit more to stand on, seeing as their summaries aren't just rehashing a single game's summary, in most cases, but I'd be fine with merging things like [[Dark Fawful]], [[Bowletta]], [[Shrowser]] and possibly even [[Mr. L]], although given the fact that "Mr. L" played such an important role in ''SPM'', I'd also be fine with that article staying. Same deal with [[Dr. Mario (character)|Dr. Mario]]: he's not a one-hit wonder, and not giving him his own page would look like an omission on our part. - {{User:Walkazo/sig}} 10:40, 4 February 2011 (EST) | ||
::In my opinion, Robo Koopa should be merged as it is not notable enough to warrant its own article. But Bowletta, Dark Fawful (don't know who Shrowser is) and Mr. L are all main villains of a game. Robo Koopa appeared as the villain during one episode of a TV show. Bowletta, Dark Fawful, etc. are the main villains of their own games. They should remain split (IMO). {{User|Marioguy1}} | ::In my opinion, Robo Koopa should be merged as it is not notable enough to warrant its own article. But Bowletta, Dark Fawful (don't know who Shrowser is) and Mr. L are all main villains of a game. Robo Koopa appeared as the villain during one episode of a TV show. Bowletta, Dark Fawful, etc. are the main villains of their own games. They should remain split (IMO). {{User|Marioguy1}} | ||
:::Slitghly off topic, but King Koopa has quite a few pages on his alter-egos. We even listed them: [[King Koopa's alter egos]]. Since this will pass, should we delete/merge these alter-egos? {{User:Reversinator/sig}} | :::Slitghly off topic, but King Koopa has quite a few pages on his alter-egos. We even listed them: [[King Koopa's alter egos]]. Since this will pass, should we delete/merge these alter-egos? {{User:Reversinator/sig}} | ||
