Editing Talk:List of Smash Taunt characters
From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then publish the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
| Latest revision | Your text | ||
| Line 39: | Line 39: | ||
So I was thinking about making a proposal to merge this page somewhere since it doesn't seem particularly Mario-relevant, but Doc brought up a good idea in the above discussion: making this a page about Smash Taunts in general. This makes sense to me as Smash Taunts are a Mario-relevant feature of the games, since they can have conversations about Mario characters. However, I then realised that although this page claims to be about the "Smash Taunt characters", it already has a section for listing the different Smash Taunt conversations, so there isn't really a change in content that needs to be done here so much as a bit of reorganising. | So I was thinking about making a proposal to merge this page somewhere since it doesn't seem particularly Mario-relevant, but Doc brought up a good idea in the above discussion: making this a page about Smash Taunts in general. This makes sense to me as Smash Taunts are a Mario-relevant feature of the games, since they can have conversations about Mario characters. However, I then realised that although this page claims to be about the "Smash Taunt characters", it already has a section for listing the different Smash Taunt conversations, so there isn't really a change in content that needs to be done here so much as a bit of reorganising. | ||
Currently, [[Smash Taunt]] links to a section on the [[taunt]] page. I propose that we instead make this page into the Smash Taunt page, changing the title to "Smash Taunt", and the section on the taunt page can be trimmed and link to this page with a [[Template:Main]]. Then, we incorporate that information on this page and | Currently, [[Smash Taunt]] links to a section on the [[taunt]] page. I propose that we instead make this page into the Smash Taunt page, changing the title to "Smash Taunt", and the section on the taunt page can be trimmed and link to this page with a [[Template:Main]]. Then, we incorporate that information on this page and reorder the rest of the page to have the "conversations" list first, before the "characters" list. | ||
The "conversations" section currently just has the Star Fox ones while the [[List of Snake's codec conversations|Snake codecs]] and [[List of Palutena's Guidance conversations|Palutena's guidances]] are split into their own pages. This made sense back when we covered all the conversations, but now that we only have the Mario ones listed, those pages are both short enough that I think they could be merged back here (and they're also the main thing that gives this subject Mario relevance so it would be nice to actually have them on the page). Adding the lengths of these three pages comes to about 66,000 bytes, which isn't too bad. However, since we trimmed those two lists to only cover the Mario character conversations, it begs the question of why we still have the Star Fox conversations listed, since those aren't character-specific at all. I could go either way on whether to keep them, so I'll have two support options. | |||
'''TLDR:''' I'm proposing to rename this page to "Smash Taunt", move the "conversations" section above the "characters" section, merge [[List of Snake's codec conversations]] and [[List of Palutena's Guidance conversations]] here, and potentially also remove the Star Fox conversations. I realise that this is a very specific proposal, but I figured these changes were big enough to be worth voting on first. | |||
'''TLDR:''' I'm proposing to rename this page to "Smash Taunt", merge [[List of Snake's codec conversations]] and [[List of Palutena's Guidance conversations]] here, and potentially also remove the Star Fox conversations | |||
'''Proposer''': {{User|Hewer}}<br> | '''Proposer''': {{User|Hewer}}<br> | ||
