Editing Talk:Bowser Jr.
From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then publish the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
Latest revision | Your text | ||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{ | {{award-winner | ||
|year=first | |||
|#=13|award=Favorite Koopaling|presenter=RAP | |||
}} | |||
{{award-winner | |||
|year=third | |||
|#=28|award=Favorite Mini-boss|presenter=Hyper Guy | |||
}} | |||
{{award-winner | |||
|year=Seventh | |||
|#=23|award=Favorite Mini-boss|presenter=Superchao | |||
}} | |||
{{notforumtalk}} | |||
==An Observation; Is it Noteable?== | ==An Observation; Is it Noteable?== | ||
Line 9: | Line 22: | ||
Uhh, this is pretty irrelevant to Bowser Jr. himself, but I'm not really fond of the Koopa family tag...mark...thing at the bottom there. Lakitu and not Morton? Morton IS a dead link at the moment, and I wouldn't be able to make as detailed of a page compared to other Koopaling pages, but he deserves to be there more than Lakitu. Does anyone know how to fix this? [[User:Evan|Evan]] | Uhh, this is pretty irrelevant to Bowser Jr. himself, but I'm not really fond of the Koopa family tag...mark...thing at the bottom there. Lakitu and not Morton? Morton IS a dead link at the moment, and I wouldn't be able to make as detailed of a page compared to other Koopaling pages, but he deserves to be there more than Lakitu. Does anyone know how to fix this? [[User:Evan|Evan]] | ||
: I just fixed it, but to answer your question, that info was placed in a template. A template can be edited just like any other entry and has it's own page. In this case, it was [[Template: | : I just fixed it, but to answer your question, that info was placed in a template. A template can be edited just like any other entry and has it's own page. In this case, it was [[Template:Koopa]]. -- [[User:Ghost Jam| Ghost Jam]] | ||
==Question== | ==Question== | ||
Line 169: | Line 182: | ||
== Is Bowser Jr. affiliated with Princess Peach? == | == Is Bowser Jr. affiliated with Princess Peach? == | ||
{{ | {{SettledTPP}} | ||
{{ | {{ProposalOutcome|failed|5-6|unaffiliated}} | ||
Sigh... since communication seems to be so hard these days, and since I see an edit war arising here, we will settle this argument democratically. So stop edit warring and start voting. Ah, and another thing: Any kind of flame or personal attack made here will be met with appropriate measurements. You have been warned! | Sigh... since communication seems to be so hard these days, and since I see an edit war arising here, we will settle this argument democratically. So stop edit warring and start voting. Ah, and another thing: Any kind of flame or personal attack made here will be met with appropriate measurements. You have been warned! | ||
Line 238: | Line 251: | ||
Shouldn't this article be called "Bowser, Jr.", not "Bowser Jr."? Most people who have a "Jr." in their name have to have a comma, but is this the case with Bowsie? {{User:Toad85/sig}} | Shouldn't this article be called "Bowser, Jr.", not "Bowser Jr."? Most people who have a "Jr." in their name have to have a comma, but is this the case with Bowsie? {{User:Toad85/sig}} | ||
== He isn't a prince == | == He isn't a prince == | ||
Line 257: | Line 267: | ||
Why is it that Bowser Jr.'s New Super Mario Bros U. artwork can't be used for the info box? I thought we are suppose to use the most recent image in the info box. People just change it back to the Mario Party 9 artwork when ever someone changes it to New Super Mario Bros. U. What is the reason for this? [[User:Smasher345|Smasher345]] 22:29, 21 December 2012 (EST) | Why is it that Bowser Jr.'s New Super Mario Bros U. artwork can't be used for the info box? I thought we are suppose to use the most recent image in the info box. People just change it back to the Mario Party 9 artwork when ever someone changes it to New Super Mario Bros. U. What is the reason for this? [[User:Smasher345|Smasher345]] 22:29, 21 December 2012 (EST) | ||
:In most cases, the latest artwork is used. But the [[:File:Bowserjr NSMBU.png|Bowser Jr. artwork]] for ''NSMBU'' is specialized for that game, meaning there is something "atypical" about it (see [[Template: | :In most cases, the latest artwork is used. But the [[:File:Bowserjr NSMBU.png|Bowser Jr. artwork]] for ''NSMBU'' is specialized for that game, meaning there is something "atypical" about it (see [[Template:Character-infobox|the policy]]). In this case, Bowser Jr. is flying the [[Koopa Clown Car#New Super Mario Bros. U|Koopa Clown Car]]. Therefore, the older solo artwork from ''Mario Party 9'' is used instead. | ||
:{{User:YoshiKong/sig}} 22:40, 21 December 2012 (EST) | :{{User:YoshiKong/sig}} 22:40, 21 December 2012 (EST) | ||
Line 282: | Line 292: | ||
==Proposal== | ==Proposal== | ||
{{ | {{SettledTPP}} | ||
{{ | {{ProposalOutcome|vetoed|This is ''way'' too minor for a TPP: just use {{tem|talk}} and discuss it without the overkill of a formal vote.}} | ||
I want to change the quote to the above. | I want to change the quote to the above. | ||
Line 317: | Line 327: | ||
My point is that his (and Kamek's) is not guranteed and should be noted. -pants98 | My point is that his (and Kamek's) is not guranteed and should be noted. -pants98 | ||
:There is no official proof of them dying, so it'd be speculation which isn't allowed on the wiki. {{User|Yoshi876}} | :There is no official proof of them dying, so it'd be speculation which isn't allowed on the wiki. {{User|Yoshi876}} | ||
== His Real Mama == | == His Real Mama == | ||
Line 340: | Line 348: | ||
== change the image. == | == change the image. == | ||
{{ | {{SettledTPP}} | ||
{{ | {{ProposalOutcome|failed|13-0-0-2|''Mario Party 9''}} | ||
I wanna change the image! The current one is getting old. let's see. | I wanna change the image! The current one is getting old. let's see. | ||
Line 348: | Line 356: | ||
===keep the same one.=== | ===keep the same one.=== | ||
[[File:MP9 | [[File:Bowserjr MP9.png|90px]] | ||
#{{User|Baby Luigi}} This is the one that is most representative of him. The other images all violate infobox policy. | #{{User|Baby Luigi}} This is the one that is most representative of him. The other images all violate infobox policy. | ||
#{{User|Mario}} He's not holding or riding anything. | #{{User|Mario}} He's not holding or riding anything. | ||
Line 382: | Line 390: | ||
@opposers: What policy? All I see is a recommendation. Don't link to guidelines and think it's automatically policy and ''must'' be followed. :/ {{User:Mario/sig}} 17:09, 26 September 2014 (EDT) | @opposers: What policy? All I see is a recommendation. Don't link to guidelines and think it's automatically policy and ''must'' be followed. :/ {{User:Mario/sig}} 17:09, 26 September 2014 (EDT) | ||
:What people were referring to was [[Template:character infobox|this]]. (''However, if the latest artwork is specialized for that game (i.e. the character's wearing sporting gear, driving a kart, etc.), an older image may be retained as the infobox image instead.'') {{User:BabyLuigi64/sig}} | :What people were referring to was [[Template:character-infobox|this]]. (''However, if the latest artwork is specialized for that game (i.e. the character's wearing sporting gear, driving a kart, etc.), an older image may be retained as the infobox image instead.'') {{User:BabyLuigi64/sig}} | ||
::@mario: because it should be optional to follow policies that are written for a reason {{User:Baby Luigi/sig}} 19:16, 26 September 2014 (EDT) | ::@mario: because it should be optional to follow policies that are written for a reason {{User:Baby Luigi/sig}} 19:16, 26 September 2014 (EDT) | ||
Line 442: | Line 450: | ||
== Decide what image to use for Bowser Jr.'s infobox == | == Decide what image to use for Bowser Jr.'s infobox == | ||
{{ | {{SettledTPP}} | ||
{{ | {{ProposalOutcome|passed|11-3-3|''Mario Party 9''}} | ||
Since this seems to be a bit contentious right now, I figured the best option would be to make a TPP to decide which image we should use for Bowser Jr.'s infobox. | Since this seems to be a bit contentious right now, I figured the best option would be to make a TPP to decide which image we should use for Bowser Jr.'s infobox. | ||
<gallery> | <gallery> | ||
File:MP9 | File:Bowserjr MP9.png|Option 1 | ||
File:SMPBowserJr.png|Option 2 | File:SMPBowserJr.png|Option 2 | ||
File:BowserJr BISDX Point.png|Option 3 | File:BowserJr BISDX Point.png|Option 3 | ||
Line 474: | Line 482: | ||
#{{User|WeirdDave13}} Per Doc. Makes more sense to use this one instead. | #{{User|WeirdDave13}} Per Doc. Makes more sense to use this one instead. | ||
#{{User|MarioManiac1981}} Per Doc. Since the other characters have their infoboxes updated to use their ''Super Mario Party'' artworks (barring Mario and Luigi), why shouldn't Bowser Jr.'s artwork stay the way it is? Option 3 should be in Bowser Jr.'s gallery page. | #{{User|MarioManiac1981}} Per Doc. Since the other characters have their infoboxes updated to use their ''Super Mario Party'' artworks (barring Mario and Luigi), why shouldn't Bowser Jr.'s artwork stay the way it is? Option 3 should be in Bowser Jr.'s gallery page. | ||
I think wii should use his artwork from ''[[Super Mario Party]]''. {{User:YoshiFan08/sig}} | |||
===Option 3 (Bowser Jr.'s Journey)=== | ===Option 3 (Bowser Jr.'s Journey)=== | ||
#{{User|FanOfYoshi}} Looks good enough to fit in the infobox. Since it's the recent Mario game to have been released in Japan, i think this is the most appropriate option. The Mario & Luigi artworks are drawn in a very good way. | #{{User|FanOfYoshi}} Looks good enough to fit in the infobox. Since it's the recent Mario game to have been released in Japan, i think this is the most appropriate option. The Mario & Luigi artworks are drawn in a very good way. | ||
Line 484: | Line 492: | ||
:It's not straightforward and easy to put on a policy though, and at a certain point a case-by-case inspection is needed. In this case, the problem with the ''Mario & Luigi'' series is that it has its own artstyle, there is a tendency to avoid artwork in a unique artstyle as it tends to alter main features of the design, although in this case there doesn't seem to be an important removal or alteration of any of the major traits of Bowser Jr.'s design. In the case of the artwork for ''Super Mario Party'', there is indeed the issue that [[List of Bowser Jr. profiles and statistics#Mario Portal|the bib is a main trait of Bowser Jr.]], so the concern on whether the main artwork should show it in full is legitimate. Finally, the artwork of ''Mario Party 9'' is really old and is missing some details, like those related to the material of which the cuffs and the bibs are composed. There is no clear better solution here.--[[User:Mister Wu|Mister Wu]] ([[User talk:Mister Wu|talk]]) 18:55, 6 January 2019 (EST) | :It's not straightforward and easy to put on a policy though, and at a certain point a case-by-case inspection is needed. In this case, the problem with the ''Mario & Luigi'' series is that it has its own artstyle, there is a tendency to avoid artwork in a unique artstyle as it tends to alter main features of the design, although in this case there doesn't seem to be an important removal or alteration of any of the major traits of Bowser Jr.'s design. In the case of the artwork for ''Super Mario Party'', there is indeed the issue that [[List of Bowser Jr. profiles and statistics#Mario Portal|the bib is a main trait of Bowser Jr.]], so the concern on whether the main artwork should show it in full is legitimate. Finally, the artwork of ''Mario Party 9'' is really old and is missing some details, like those related to the material of which the cuffs and the bibs are composed. There is no clear better solution here.--[[User:Mister Wu|Mister Wu]] ([[User talk:Mister Wu|talk]]) 18:55, 6 January 2019 (EST) | ||
::Yeah, that's true. I do think something should be mentioned about exceptions being allowed in cases of stylized artwork (although, looking at the infobox again, I'd say that falls under "if the latest artwork is specialized for that game") or poses that may be unsuitable though. --{{User:Waluigi Time/sig}} 19:30, 6 January 2019 (EST) | ::Yeah, that's true. I do think something should be mentioned about exceptions being allowed in cases of stylized artwork (although, looking at the infobox again, I'd say that falls under "if the latest artwork is specialized for that game") or poses that may be unsuitable though. --{{User:Waluigi Time/sig}} 19:30, 6 January 2019 (EST) | ||