Editing Talk:Bowser's Fury
From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then publish the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
| Latest revision | Your text | ||
| Line 25: | Line 25: | ||
== Create page for {{fake link|Cat Enemies (Bowser's Fury)}} == | == Create page for {{fake link|Cat Enemies (Bowser's Fury)}} == | ||
===Create page for {{fake link|Cat Enemies (Bowser's Fury)}}=== | |||
{{TPP}} | {{TPP}} | ||
I've been reading the discussion around the topic, although they are recognized as cat counterparts of the normal SM3DW enemies, their only difference is an addition of cat ears and fur, so I think it would be best to create a specific page for these enemies in general and thanks to this group them into a single differentiated article or make Each Enemy It's Own page, the name of this page is simple {{fake link|Cat Enemies (Bowser's Fury)}} | I've been reading the discussion around the topic, although they are recognized as cat counterparts of the normal SM3DW enemies, their only difference is an addition of cat ears and fur, so I think it would be best to create a specific page for these enemies in general and thanks to this group them into a single differentiated article or make Each Enemy It's Own page, the name of this page is simple {{fake link|Cat Enemies (Bowser's Fury)}} | ||
| Line 39: | Line 40: | ||
#{{User|Arend}} Per proposal. (Also, can we split the Bowser's Fury Cat Goomba from [[Cat Goomba|the ''3D World'' one]], while we're at it?) | #{{User|Arend}} Per proposal. (Also, can we split the Bowser's Fury Cat Goomba from [[Cat Goomba|the ''3D World'' one]], while we're at it?) | ||
#{{User|Rykitu}} Per all. | #{{User|Rykitu}} Per all. | ||
#{{User|Hewer}} Actually, this makes sense. Why shouldn't we split variants with different designs and different names, and that are officially identified as separate on Mario Portal? A similar case would be [[Raving Piranha Plant]], or [[Talk:Hyrule Circuit#Create pages for the Zelda elements, take II|this proposal]] that gave us the likes of [[Deku Baba]] and [[ | #{{User|Hewer}} Actually, this makes sense. Why shouldn't we split variants with different designs and different names, and that are officially identified as separate on Mario Portal? (I'd actually oppose splitting the two Cat Goombas based on that.) A similar case would be [[Raving Piranha Plant]], or [[Talk:Hyrule Circuit#Create pages for the Zelda elements, take II|this proposal]] that gave us the likes of [[Deku Baba]] and [[Cash]]. | ||
====Don't Create The Page (Oposse)==== | ====Don't Create The Page (Oposse)==== | ||
| Line 48: | Line 48: | ||
#{{User|EvieMaybe}} per [[MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive/65#Decide_how_to_handle_the_toy_enemies_from_across_the_Mario_vs._Donkey_Kong_series|the proposal]] that merged the Mario vs. Donkey Kong toy enemies to their base enemies. it's just an aesthetic variation for theming purposes | #{{User|EvieMaybe}} per [[MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive/65#Decide_how_to_handle_the_toy_enemies_from_across_the_Mario_vs._Donkey_Kong_series|the proposal]] that merged the Mario vs. Donkey Kong toy enemies to their base enemies. it's just an aesthetic variation for theming purposes | ||
#{{user|PopitTart}} If Green Koopa Troopa and Red Koopa Troopa are stuck together despite being mechanically distinct, then theres absolutely no reason Cat Koopa Troopa should get its own page as a cosmetic reskin. Theres more justification to split the colors of Yoshi than the Cat variants. | #{{user|PopitTart}} If Green Koopa Troopa and Red Koopa Troopa are stuck together despite being mechanically distinct, then theres absolutely no reason Cat Koopa Troopa should get its own page as a cosmetic reskin. Theres more justification to split the colors of Yoshi than the Cat variants. | ||
<s>#{{User|Arend}} Given that these have never been classified as a group, and that said group never even got the name "Cat Enemies", I would rather give each subject its own article instead. I would suggest retitling the proposed article to something like "List of cat variants of enemies in ''Bowser's Fury''", but that would cover nearly every enemy in the entire campaign, which would be redundant. (side note, the Cat Goomba from ''Bowser's Fury'' should NOT be merged with [[Cat Goomba|the ''3D World'' one]])</s> | <s>#{{User|Arend}} Given that these have never been classified as a group, and that said group never even got the name "Cat Enemies", I would rather give each subject its own article instead. I would suggest retitling the proposed article to something like "List of cat variants of enemies in ''Bowser's Fury''", but that would cover nearly every enemy in the entire campaign, which would be redundant. (side note, the Cat Goomba from ''Bowser's Fury'' should NOT be merged with [[Cat Goomba|the ''3D World'' one]])</s> | ||
| Line 83: | Line 76: | ||
{{@|Blinker}} - [[Frame Boo|About]] [[Frame Chomp|that]]... ...and that's not getting into the "paper" enemies in ''Paper Jam'', which, while differences in behavior are sometimes present, they are generally minute. [[User:Doc von Schmeltwick|Doc von Schmeltwick]] ([[User talk:Doc von Schmeltwick|talk]]) 13:42, March 8, 2025 (EST) | {{@|Blinker}} - [[Frame Boo|About]] [[Frame Chomp|that]]... ...and that's not getting into the "paper" enemies in ''Paper Jam'', which, while differences in behavior are sometimes present, they are generally minute. [[User:Doc von Schmeltwick|Doc von Schmeltwick]] ([[User talk:Doc von Schmeltwick|talk]]) 13:42, March 8, 2025 (EST) | ||
:The Frame enemies do have unique properties compared to their normal counterparts, and the Paper enemies at least appear alongside non-Paper enemies and, as you mention, often have differences in behavior. These don't have anything aside from a "Cat" prefix and a small visual difference. Aside from the names, they feel more like the origami enemies from The Origami King (although at least those appear alongside their normal counterparts). [[User:Blinker|Blinker]] ([[User talk:Blinker|talk]]) 13:54, March 8, 2025 (EST) | :The Frame enemies do have unique properties compared to their normal counterparts, and the Paper enemies at least appear alongside non-Paper enemies and, as you mention, often have differences in behavior. These don't have anything aside from a "Cat" prefix and a small visual difference. Aside from the names, they feel more like the origami enemies from The Origami King (although at least those appear alongside their normal counterparts). [[User:Blinker|Blinker]] ([[User talk:Blinker|talk]]) 13:54, March 8, 2025 (EST) | ||
