Editing Talk:Blargg
From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then publish the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
Latest revision | Your text | ||
Line 44: | Line 44: | ||
==Create a Blargg (species) page== | ==Create a Blargg (species) page== | ||
{{ | {{SettledTPP}} | ||
{{ | {{ProposalOutcome|canceled}} | ||
I do not understand the meaning of the page. Is it a page for the Blargg that first appeared in Super Mario World or a page for the species as a whole? If I read the first line of text, this page is for Blargg who first appeared in Super Mario World. So, I propose a small clean up to this page and create a page for the Blargg species. Since there are several types of Blargg now. After all, we have a page for the Koopa species, a page for the Boom Boom species, a page for the Yoshi species and so on. It also would provide a better built page for the enemy and for the species, because presently this page was yet to Blargg from Super Mario World and now it resembles a page for the species. | I do not understand the meaning of the page. Is it a page for the Blargg that first appeared in Super Mario World or a page for the species as a whole? If I read the first line of text, this page is for Blargg who first appeared in Super Mario World. So, I propose a small clean up to this page and create a page for the Blargg species. Since there are several types of Blargg now. After all, we have a page for the Koopa species, a page for the Boom Boom species, a page for the Yoshi species and so on. It also would provide a better built page for the enemy and for the species, because presently this page was yet to Blargg from Super Mario World and now it resembles a page for the species. | ||
To be more specific about what I want to do : | To be more specific about what I want to do : | ||
Line 83: | Line 83: | ||
== Merge YS-related parts of this article to "Red Blargg" == | == Merge YS-related parts of this article to "Red Blargg" == | ||
{{ | {{SettledTPP}} | ||
{{ | {{ProposalOutcome|failed|0-3-8}} | ||
Yoshi's Story depicts Blarggs as blob-like beings with large mouths, small arms and beady eyes. Perhaps there's a possibility to merge YS-related parts of the "Blargg" article with "Red Blargg", since I made a proposal on deciding what to do with that article. | Yoshi's Story depicts Blarggs as blob-like beings with large mouths, small arms and beady eyes. Perhaps there's a possibility to merge YS-related parts of the "Blargg" article with "Red Blargg", since I made a proposal on deciding what to do with that article. | ||
Line 122: | Line 122: | ||
== Decide what else Blargg can be split into == | == Decide what else Blargg can be split into == | ||
{{ | {{TPP}} | ||
My proposal to either merge certain parts of this article to [[Red Blargg]] or split into the ''Yoshi's Story'' Blargg had just been declined, so I've come up with a new proposal, this time to decide what else Blargg can be split into: either split into Blargg and {{fake link|Blargg (''Yoshi's Story'')}}; split into Blargg and {{fake link|Blargg (blobby)}}; split into Blargg and {{fake link|Blargg (big)}}; split into Blargg and {{fake link|Blargg (big blobby Blargg)}}; or leave it the way it is. Like I said in my last proposal, ''Yoshi's Story'' depicts the Blarggs here as big blobby beings with large mouths, small arms and beady eyes. For example, in German, Blarggs are also called Feuerdrache (i.e. Fire dragon), while big blobby Blarggs in ''Yoshi's Story'' are referred to as Dudel Sprudel (i.e. Fizzy doodle). | My proposal to either merge certain parts of this article to [[Red Blargg]] or split into the ''Yoshi's Story'' Blargg had just been declined, so I've come up with a new proposal, this time to decide what else Blargg can be split into: either split into Blargg and {{fake link|Blargg (''Yoshi's Story'')}}; split into Blargg and {{fake link|Blargg (blobby)}}; split into Blargg and {{fake link|Blargg (big)}}; split into Blargg and {{fake link|Blargg (big blobby Blargg)}}; or leave it the way it is. Like I said in my last proposal, ''Yoshi's Story'' depicts the Blarggs here as big blobby beings with large mouths, small arms and beady eyes. For example, in German, Blarggs are also called Feuerdrache (i.e. Fire dragon), while big blobby Blarggs in ''Yoshi's Story'' are referred to as Dudel Sprudel (i.e. Fizzy doodle). | ||
Line 144: | Line 143: | ||
#{{User|Pizza Master}} Despite the different appearances, Nintendo doesn't refer to the other designs of Blarggs by different names so we shouldn't either. | #{{User|Pizza Master}} Despite the different appearances, Nintendo doesn't refer to the other designs of Blarggs by different names so we shouldn't either. | ||
#{{User|Hewer}} My problem with the last proposal was the idea of splitting the Yoshi's Story Blargg at all, not the identifier used by the split page (and all of the new suggestions are significantly worse anyway). Per all. | #{{User|Hewer}} My problem with the last proposal was the idea of splitting the Yoshi's Story Blargg at all, not the identifier used by the split page (and all of the new suggestions are significantly worse anyway). Per all. | ||
===Comments=== | ===Comments=== | ||
Line 153: | Line 149: | ||
Their other proposal left the option for voting to split the Blargg article into "Blargg" and "Blargg (Yoshi's Story)". Since all of their descriptions of the 'other' Blargg in this proposal are obviously in reference to the Blarggs from [[Yoshi's Story]], then yes. This proposal should be taken down for violating [[MarioWiki:Proposals#Rules|Rule 7]]--{{User:Pizza Master/sig}} 23:25, August 14, 2023 (EDT) | Their other proposal left the option for voting to split the Blargg article into "Blargg" and "Blargg (Yoshi's Story)". Since all of their descriptions of the 'other' Blargg in this proposal are obviously in reference to the Blarggs from [[Yoshi's Story]], then yes. This proposal should be taken down for violating [[MarioWiki:Proposals#Rules|Rule 7]]--{{User:Pizza Master/sig}} 23:25, August 14, 2023 (EDT) | ||
:Although i wanna oppose, i'm gonna abstain for now. --{{User:FanOfYoshi/sig}} 10:41, August 16, 2023 (EDT) | :Although i wanna oppose, i'm gonna abstain for now. --{{User:FanOfYoshi/sig}} 10:41, August 16, 2023 (EDT) | ||