Editing Talk:Baby Yoshi
From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then publish the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
| Latest revision | Your text | ||
| Line 10: | Line 10: | ||
==Merge to Yoshi (species)?== | ==Merge to Yoshi (species)?== | ||
{{ | {{SettledTPP}} | ||
{{ | {{ProposalOutcome|failed|2-6|keep split}} | ||
The information on this page doesn't necessarily merit an individual article. Baby Yoshi aren't a species, sub-species, or even a form; they're simply infant Yoshi. This article amounts to no more than a list of appearances of infant or child Yoshi in different media, but dresses it up in a flashy way with lots of pictures. A similar issue was brought up and proposed not too long ago, about knowing the difference between characters as infants, and the Baby characters. The two are not one and the same, and this was understood and the two separated per that proposal. | The information on this page doesn't necessarily merit an individual article. Baby Yoshi aren't a species, sub-species, or even a form; they're simply infant Yoshi. This article amounts to no more than a list of appearances of infant or child Yoshi in different media, but dresses it up in a flashy way with lots of pictures. A similar issue was brought up and proposed not too long ago, about knowing the difference between characters as infants, and the Baby characters. The two are not one and the same, and this was understood and the two separated per that proposal. | ||
| Line 19: | Line 19: | ||
'''Deadline:''' March 15 2010, 23:59 | '''Deadline:''' March 15 2010, 23:59 | ||
<div id=fh3 class=mw-headline>Merge to Yoshi (species)</div> | |||
#{{User|Redstar}} - Per proposal | #{{User|Redstar}} - Per proposal | ||
#{{User|KS3}} Per Redstar. I split Blue toad for you FYI. | #{{User|KS3}} Per Redstar. I split Blue toad for you FYI. | ||
<div id=fh3 class=mw-headline>Leave un-merged</div> | |||
#{{User|Zero777}} I am Zero! I changed my mind, Baby Yoshis seem to have a slightly different role in mario games then regular yoshis. Zero signing out. | #{{User|Zero777}} I am Zero! I changed my mind, Baby Yoshis seem to have a slightly different role in mario games then regular yoshis. Zero signing out. | ||
#{{User|Reversinator}} The same could be said about [[Baby Mario]], [[Baby Luigi]] and the like. | #{{User|Reversinator}} The same could be said about [[Baby Mario]], [[Baby Luigi]] and the like. | ||
| Line 31: | Line 31: | ||
#{{user|Bloc Partier}} - The article needs improvement, sure. But It should not be merged, as the Baby Yoshi is a rather different form of Yoshi, especially in SMW. | #{{user|Bloc Partier}} - The article needs improvement, sure. But It should not be merged, as the Baby Yoshi is a rather different form of Yoshi, especially in SMW. | ||
<div id=fh3 class=mw-headline>Comments</div> | |||
@Reversinator, LeftyGreenMario, and Supermariofan14: You all seem to think this proposal is about merging Baby Yoshi (character) into Yoshi (character). This is not what this proposal is attempting to do. It instead attempting to merge the infant stage of Yoshi into the Yoshi as a race page, which covers biology. Infant Yoshi are a stage in Yoshi biology, so keeping the information unmerged is needless. This proposal is nothing like merging Baby Mario, Baby Luigi, etc. into their adult forms. [[User:Redstar|Redstar]] 19:49, 2 March 2010 (EST) | @Reversinator, LeftyGreenMario, and Supermariofan14: You all seem to think this proposal is about merging Baby Yoshi (character) into Yoshi (character). This is not what this proposal is attempting to do. It instead attempting to merge the infant stage of Yoshi into the Yoshi as a race page, which covers biology. Infant Yoshi are a stage in Yoshi biology, so keeping the information unmerged is needless. This proposal is nothing like merging Baby Mario, Baby Luigi, etc. into their adult forms. [[User:Redstar|Redstar]] 19:49, 2 March 2010 (EST) | ||
| Line 51: | Line 51: | ||
==Merge relative info into [[Yoshi (species)]], <s>[[Little Yoshi]]</s> and [[Fearsome 5]]== | ==Merge relative info into [[Yoshi (species)]], <s>[[Little Yoshi]]</s> and [[Fearsome 5]]== | ||
{{ | {{SettledTPP}} | ||
{{ | {{ProposalOutcome|failed|1-4|no merge}} | ||
As Redstar states above, we need to merge info where Baby Yoshi was considered a species. But, in Paper Mario, there was 5 baby yoshis called the Fearsome 5, and In Tetris Attack, there is a yellow Little Yoshi. The info can be merged into the respective articles. <br> | As Redstar states above, we need to merge info where Baby Yoshi was considered a species. But, in Paper Mario, there was 5 baby yoshis called the Fearsome 5, and In Tetris Attack, there is a yellow Little Yoshi. The info can be merged into the respective articles. <br> | ||
Sections are split into: | Sections are split into: | ||
| Line 66: | Line 66: | ||
'''Deadline:''' March 17 2010, 23:59 | '''Deadline:''' March 17 2010, 23:59 | ||
<div id=fh3 class=mw-headline>Support</div> | |||
#{{User|KS3}} | #{{User|KS3}} | ||
<div id=fh3 class=mw-headline>Oppose</div> | |||
#{{User|Gamefreak75}} Little Yoshi redirects to Baby Yoshi and the Fearsome 5 are very important characters and have a lot of info. If we do this, then we'd have to merge all the Glitz Pit Battle Teams into their respective articles, such as [[Craw Daddy]]. | #{{User|Gamefreak75}} Little Yoshi redirects to Baby Yoshi and the Fearsome 5 are very important characters and have a lot of info. If we do this, then we'd have to merge all the Glitz Pit Battle Teams into their respective articles, such as [[Craw Daddy]]. | ||
#{{User|Reversinator}} Per Gamefreak75. | #{{User|Reversinator}} Per Gamefreak75. | ||
| Line 75: | Line 75: | ||
#{{user|Bloc Partier}} - The article needs improvement, sure. But It should not be merged, as the Baby Yoshi is a rather different form of Yoshi, especially in SMW. | #{{user|Bloc Partier}} - The article needs improvement, sure. But It should not be merged, as the Baby Yoshi is a rather different form of Yoshi, especially in SMW. | ||
<div id=fh3 class=mw-headline>Comments</div> | |||
Why did you make this proposal when mine, just above, is proposing essentially the same exact thing? [[User:Redstar|Redstar]] 01:08, 3 March 2010 (EST) | Why did you make this proposal when mine, just above, is proposing essentially the same exact thing? [[User:Redstar|Redstar]] 01:08, 3 March 2010 (EST) | ||
:No it isn't. It is going to merge the Paper Mario info into the [[Fearsome 5]]. {{User|KS3}} | :No it isn't. It is going to merge the Paper Mario info into the [[Fearsome 5]]. {{User|KS3}} | ||
| Line 86: | Line 86: | ||
::::::No, it's not. The main focus of this article is on infant (baby) Yoshi, not Baby Yoshi the character, whom is a Star Child. Information on both are on here because Baby Yoshi (character) doesn't have enough information to hold its own. [[User:Redstar|Redstar]] 01:40, 3 March 2010 (EST) | ::::::No, it's not. The main focus of this article is on infant (baby) Yoshi, not Baby Yoshi the character, whom is a Star Child. Information on both are on here because Baby Yoshi (character) doesn't have enough information to hold its own. [[User:Redstar|Redstar]] 01:40, 3 March 2010 (EST) | ||
:There isn't a Baby Yoshi character [[User:MarioLover54|MarioLover54]] | |||
==Subject of the article== | ==Subject of the article== | ||
| Line 102: | Line 103: | ||
==Split {{fake link|Baby Yoshi (species)}} from Baby Yoshi== | ==Split {{fake link|Baby Yoshi (species)}} from Baby Yoshi== | ||
{{ | {{SettledTPP}} | ||
{{ | {{ProposalOutcome|no quorum|1-1}} | ||
Some sections explain the Baby Yoshi as a species (like the Super Mario World one), and this article should only explain the characters Baby Yoshi. There was a proposal splitting the Yellow Toad page, and this is the exact thing I am doing here. | Some sections explain the Baby Yoshi as a species (like the Super Mario World one), and this article should only explain the characters Baby Yoshi. There was a proposal splitting the Yellow Toad page, and this is the exact thing I am doing here. | ||
| Line 109: | Line 110: | ||
'''Deadline:''' 21 April 2010, 24:00 | '''Deadline:''' 21 April 2010, 24:00 | ||
<div id=fh3 class=mw-headline>Split info that is about the species</div> | |||
#{{User|KS3}} The Yellow Toad species sections were split, why not this (Super Mario World section, Yoshi's Story section, etc) | #{{User|KS3}} The Yellow Toad species sections were split, why not this (Super Mario World section, Yoshi's Story section, etc) | ||
<div id=fh3 class=mw-headline>Keep merged...</div> | |||
#{{User|Homestar Runner}} I'm pretty sure that there is no "character" Baby Yoshi. | #{{User|Homestar Runner}} I'm pretty sure that there is no "character" Baby Yoshi. | ||
<div id=fh3 class=mw-headline>Comments</div> | |||
@Homestar Runner: I'm pretty sure that there is a character named Baby Yoshi (Yoshi's Island DS hello). {{User:KS3/sig}} | @Homestar Runner: I'm pretty sure that there is a character named Baby Yoshi (Yoshi's Island DS hello). {{User:KS3/sig}} | ||
| Line 137: | Line 138: | ||
In the Italian version of [[Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door]] it is confirmed that the [[Yoshi (Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door) | Yoshi]] there is a Baby Yoshi, as he is defined as a ''MiniYoshi'', with the explanation that MiniYoshis are ''Yoshis that just hatched from the eggs'' (you can read the translated text of Wonky's tale and its source in the talk section of that page). Since he also shares the same Japanese name of Baby Yoshi in that game, should a section about him be added here? | In the Italian version of [[Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door]] it is confirmed that the [[Yoshi (Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door) | Yoshi]] there is a Baby Yoshi, as he is defined as a ''MiniYoshi'', with the explanation that MiniYoshis are ''Yoshis that just hatched from the eggs'' (you can read the translated text of Wonky's tale and its source in the talk section of that page). Since he also shares the same Japanese name of Baby Yoshi in that game, should a section about him be added here? | ||
{{unsigned|Mister Wu}} | {{unsigned|Mister Wu}} | ||
