Editing Talk:3DS Music Park

==Split Bouncing Note from Music Park==

{{settled TPP}}

[[Fleeper|There's]] [[Gooey Goon|no]] [[Pompon Flower|reason]] [[Batadon|to]] [[Kurokyura|keep]] [[Omodonmeka|them]] [[Diva's Lips|on]] [[Stretch (Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island)|the]] [[Scorchit|same]] [[Spooky (enemy)|page,]] [[Octo (Yoshi's Safari)|considering]] [[Naval Bud|we]] [[Ameboid|have]] [[Jumping Blooper|a]] [[Face Ball|lot]] [[Blade-Face|of]] [[Vase-Based|pages]] [[Nibbles|for]] [[Wind Duppy|minor]] [[Sleepy Boo|enemies]] [[Klamber|that]] [[Fly Stinger|only]] [[Old Red-Mug|appeared]] [[Fire Snake (Super Mario World)|in]] [[Fire jet|one]] [[Slide Box|game]] [[Buster Beetle|or]] [[Kuromame|its]] [[Stretch (Super Mario Bros. 3)|remakes]] [[Oyster|(even]] [[Penny (enemy)|conjecturally]] [[Fire Snake (Wario Land 3)|named]] [[Kop|ones,]] [[Patan|and]] [[Chain Chomplet|ones]] [[Biting Bullet Bill|that]] [[Bookend|only]] [[Mad Piano|appeared]] [[Killer Chair|in]] [[Waiter|one]] [[Karamenbō|area).]] [[Spider (The Super Mario Bros. Super Show!)|Besides,]] [[Robo Troopa|we]] [[Buzz-Bomb|even]] [[Clog Monster|have]] [[Chomp-Muncher|pages]] [[Goomerang Brother|for]] ''[[Net Bomb|non-game]]'' [[Black Pit Bob-omb|one-time]] [[Stink Bob-omb|enemies,]] [[Tweeter Bat|so]] [[Robo Shy Guy|why]] [[Shy Guy Lion|not]] [[Wereturtle|this?]]

'''Deadline''': <s>April 22, 2015, 23:59 GMT</s> '''Extended''': <s>April 29, 2015, 23:59 GMT</s> <s>May 6, 2015, 23:59 GMT</s> May 13, 2015, 23:59 GMT.

#{{User|Andymii}} Honestly, I don't think this even needs a proposal, though apparently not everyone agrees, so I guess I shall explain. In the comments section, I've used [[Kurokyura]] as an example, and I'll use it here as well for convenience's sake (though their are many others I can provide if requested). Kurokyura literally '''appears only once in a single level in a single game'''; we have a healthy article for it. The Bouncing Note is just that kind of character. It has an official name, is just as notable as Thwomp (in a Mario Kart sense), and, judging by its facial expression, is a living character. Put simply, the lack of information isn't an issue.

#{{User|Viper26}} Per proposal.

#{{User|SuperYoshiBros}} Well, unlike all the other Mario Kart obstacles it's a living thing. Therefore, I think it deserves to be split.

#{{User|Mario}} [[Talk:Walking Tree#Merge Moving Tree into Luigi's Mansion (course)|Per my reasons it got split in the first place]]. There is little reason to create an article on a stage hazard that is exclusive to one stage, Music Park, when being included in the course description is sufficient. Saying it appeared in two games is a fantastically weak argument since it is the same course, but with enhanced graphics. The gratuitous amounts of links provided is supposed to suggest that the lack of a Bouncing Notes article is a coverage gap. The proposal then suggests that since minor enemies get articles, minor stage hazards in one-off courses get articles. This comparison does not compel me in any form simply because there is a difference: the enemies are notable enough to have their own article. We'd have a coverage gap if we covered common enemies but left out the more elusive ones. Simple course hazards, unlike enemies, do not deserve their own articles unless they are a common element, since there are other course hazards that do not get their own articles. If we let this proposal pass, we'd open the doors to create articles for Moving Tree, the rolling thing from Thwomp Ruins, the pinballs in [[Waluigi Pinball (course)|Waluigi Pinball]] (which appear in TWO games, ''Mario Kart DS'' excluding the remade 3DS version, and ''Mario Sports Mix''!), the mechanical Piranha Plants in [[Waluigi Stadium]], the snowballs from [[DK Pass]], the falling pillars in [[Dry Dry Desert]], the shooting spaceship from [[Spacedust Alley]], the [[Yellow Devil]] from [[Wily Castle]] (which honestly needs a merge anyway since [[Talk:King Bulblin and Lord Bullbo|King Bulblin and Lord Bullbo are so]]), the drawbridge bell from [[Boulder Canyon]], and so on. Perhaps a lot are just generic objects (although I don't see how Bouncing Note is somehow more notable than those), but this proposal, I feel, might open the doors to these mostly-redundant articles. [[Wiggler Wagon|Wiggler Bus]] might be used as an example, but I think it's borderline too much, and it has the excuse of appearing in two different stages in one game.<br><br>td;lr<br> I think Bouncing Notes fail the significance test, and it would be mostly redundant. If it is missing, there wouldn't be a coverage gap.<br>The comparisons made to one-off enemies are not sound.<br>It leads to questions on other, arguably as notable or more notable, stage hazards which are redundant to their stage hazards.<br><br>td;lr of td;lr<br>It's going to be redundant.