Editing MarioWiki:Featured articles/Unfeature/N2/Goomba
From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then publish the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
| Latest revision | Your text | ||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
__NOTOC__ | __NOTOC__ | ||
{{ | ===[[{{SUBPAGENAME}}]]=== | ||
|nominated=10:56, April | |||
| | {{UNFANOMSTAT | ||
|nominated=10:56, 20 April 2012 (EDT) | |||
|passed= | |||
<!--When it is 5-0, put the time (such as 12:10, 11 December 2009) of the fifth support/removal of last opposet by copying it from the history of the page.--> | |||
}} | }} | ||
==== Remove Featured Article Status ==== | ==== Remove Featured Article Status ==== | ||
#{{User|987li}}[[Goomba|This article]] has mostly perfect grammar, spelling and use of punctuation. It has a great use of links and images. As with [[ | #{{User|987li}}[[Goomba|This article]] has mostly perfect grammar, spelling and use of punctuation. It has a great use of links and images. As with [[MW:CITE]], it shows that articles with information that is in an in-universe style provided from a source from the game (all of Goomba's roles in the games) itself does '''not''' need to be sourced. However, information that is provided outside the games, such as "Trivia" and "Names in other languages" (sections) are not sourced. | ||
==== Keep Featured Article Status ==== | ==== Keep Featured Article Status ==== | ||
| Line 15: | Line 17: | ||
#{{User|MarioSmasher}} Do we need even sources '''for names in other languages and for the trivia?!''' You know it, you can prove the trivia by playing the games, and for the other languages' names, they don't even need citations. Per all, and those reasons '''are not enough for an unfeaturing'''. | #{{User|MarioSmasher}} Do we need even sources '''for names in other languages and for the trivia?!''' You know it, you can prove the trivia by playing the games, and for the other languages' names, they don't even need citations. Per all, and those reasons '''are not enough for an unfeaturing'''. | ||
#{{User|Ultraluigi}} Per MarioSmasher. | #{{User|Ultraluigi}} Per MarioSmasher. | ||
#{{User|Lost Mini Star09}} Per all of the above. | |||
#{{User|Superluigirules}} Per all. I do not see any reason for sourcing, those sections, and it needs to have not enough information in order to be unfeatured, and this article has enough information. | #{{User|Superluigirules}} Per all. I do not see any reason for sourcing, those sections, and it needs to have not enough information in order to be unfeatured, and this article has enough information. | ||
#{{User|Mariobros1985}} This article should stay featured, since it is very long and detailed, as well as being interesting to read | #{{User|Mariobros1985}} This article should stay featured, since it is very long and detailed, as well as being interesting to read | ||
| Line 20: | Line 23: | ||
#{{User|robokoopa}} Per everyone, especially the first two. | #{{User|robokoopa}} Per everyone, especially the first two. | ||
#{{User|Vommack}}Per all. Very weak reasoning to unfeature... | #{{User|Vommack}}Per all. Very weak reasoning to unfeature... | ||
==== Removal of Support/Oppose Votes ==== | ==== Removal of Support/Oppose Votes ==== | ||
| Line 46: | Line 31: | ||
:That's not true why would you need to cite the source for a name in a different language after all we don't cite the source for the American name in fact we don't do that for any article {{User|Raven Effect}} | :That's not true why would you need to cite the source for a name in a different language after all we don't cite the source for the American name in fact we don't do that for any article {{User|Raven Effect}} | ||
Responding to the first comment, yes, I think a tiny mistake can lead to unfeaturing. However, most of the time, it's negligible because it can be corrected swiftly. Also, we have a <nowiki>{{refneeded}}</nowiki> tag in this wiki for those statements without citations, but a few of those tags won't unfeature an article. Also, the policy we have is that if you can find the source by playing the game, you don't have to cite it. I know that foreign names are often different than a bare translation ("Chemin à la Sucrerie" is "Maple Treeway", but the literal translation is "Road to the Sugar Place"). For the most part, these foreign names are found by playing the game in another language, which means that we don't need a source. {{User|LeftyGreenMario}} | Responding to the first comment, yes, I think a tiny mistake can lead to unfeaturing. However, most of the time, it's negligible because it can be corrected swiftly. Also, we have a <nowiki>{{refneeded}}</nowiki> tag in this wiki for those statements without citations, but a few of those tags won't unfeature an article. Also, the policy we have is that if you can find the source by playing the game, you don't have to cite it. I know that foreign names are often different than a bare translation ("Chemin à la Sucrerie" is "Maple Treeway", but the literal translation is "Road to the Sugar Place"). For the most part, these foreign names are found by playing the game in another language, which means that we don't need a source. {{User|LeftyGreenMario}} | ||
