Editing MarioWiki:Featured articles/N2/Mario (series)

__NOTOC__
===[[Mario (franchise)]]===
{{FANOMFAIL
|nominated=17:30, 30 March 2011
|lastedit=21:51, 22 April 2012
|nosupport=false
}}
==== Support ====
#{{User|Jose17796}} I would be excited if the Mario series became a feature article!
#{{User|DKPetey99}} This page has a vast amount of info. I don't see any other missing games. Characters, and species seem okay.
#{{User|DK and Diddy Kong vs Bowser and Bowser Jr.}}
#{{User|Weegee010}}
#{{User|Boowhoplaysgames}}
#{{User|Akfamilyhome}} 
#{{User|Lucas777123}}
#{{User|Lightblueyoshi}}
#{{User|DarthPineapple401}}
#{{User|Nbradley13}}
#{{User|Olors}} 
#{{User|Pie4ever0}}
#{{User|BoygeyDude}}
#{{User|SUPERZ}}
#{{User|Jjrapper100}}
#{{User|Conanshinichi}}
#{{User|"Luigi Time!"}}
#{{User|Technickal}}
#{{User|Likesorange}}
#{{User|Helper}}
#{{User|The Knocker}}
#{{User|Luigirules33}}
#<s>{{User|Super Famicom 64}}</s> '''I moved my vote to oppose.'''
#{{User|SoCool21}}

==== Oppose ====
#{{User|Fawfulfury65}} Missing several games, such as Mario Strikers Charged, and many of the recently released games, such as Mario Sports Mix, are lacking information.
#{{User|UltraMario3000}} Per the crazy lab experiment made with the DNA of a Hammer Bro. and Fawful.
#{{User|Yoshiwaker}} Besides the conctruction template? Per the Mario with lame puns.
#{{User|Iggykoopa}} i wanted to vote yes but since it's incomplete it can't be the best the wiki has to offer per all
#{{User|LeftyGreenMario}} You can't just ignore the construction template like that. The template means that the article needs more information and improvement. The article is missing many information. This article is long, but is a far cry from featured status.
#{{User|Baby Mario Bloops}} Even if it is a very popular page, you can't just judge it by the cover, you need to read deep into it. There is way to much missing into this page, and though I hate to say that I feel bad for this page because it is always needing updating, it probably will take a lot to become a FA.
#{{User|New Super Mario}} Per all.
#{{User|Mario4Ever}} Per above.
#{{User|Reversinator}} Missing games (including [[SSX on Tour]] and [[Alleyway]]) and many missing books. And what about the comics?
#{{User|Catboy41}} Per everything above.
#{{User|Magikrazy51}} I'll change my vote when we're finished. But for now, per all.
#{{User|Superfiremario}} per all
#{{User|Steverocks27}} rewrite template
#{{User|Mario Bros.!}} The first thing you see is a rewrite template.
#{{User|Supremo78}} Per the Hammer Bro. with extreme fury.
#{{User|IGGY7735}} How could I not agree with a furious hammer-tossing turtle? :D
#{{User|GEX}}Per all.
#{{User|Toad85}} Work on putting all the games in first.  Per Fawfulfury65.
#{{User|Goomblob}} Per all..
#{{User|KS3}} This looks more like a list of everything instead of an article, and a rewrite template is located at the top of the page.
#{{User|Roads}} Right up at the top of the page is the template that keeps this page below Featured Article standards.
#{{User|Commander Code-8}} Currently not up to FA  standards but can be with lots of editing.
#{{User|YoshiKong}} If it has a rewrite-expand template, it shouldn't become a featured article.
#{{User|M&L}} It has a rrewrite-expand template and is missing lots of information. Maybe with a few people all working hard on it it may be good enough to become a FA, but right now, it needs too much work.
#[[User:'Shroom64]] How can an article become featured if it has some improvement templates? Rule number 5: '''[[MarioWiki:Featured articles|The article must not be tagged with any sort of improvement tags (i.e. rewrite, sectionstub, etc).]]''' But at the top of the article there is a rewrite template and on the "2010-Present" section there is an under construction template. Per all.
#{{User|Super Famicom 64}} This article was never rewritten even if there was a request for rewriting template.

==== Removal of Opposes ====
==== Comments ====
{{User|DK and Diddy Kong vs Bowser and Bowser Jr.}} Thanks for beating me, Reddragon19k.

:@Fawfulfury65, you can still add to it!

::Why don't you? He may not own the missing games, thus he can't add the missing info. {{User|Reversinator}}
:::@Reversinator, just to let you FF65 is female.--{{User|UltraMario3000}}

@DKPetey99: It doesn't matter if it's the second main page. They quality of it is what matters. Also, the construction template is an improvement template, which is not allowed on featured articles. Also, I'd like to add to this article, but I'm a little busy with other articles. {{User|Fawfulfury65}}

Now that I'm starting to fix this, isn't Birdo a villain? Why is she under protagonists? [[User:DKPetey99|DKPetey99]] 13:31, 1 April 2011 (EDT)

Its in pretty good shape as of now. What other games are missing? Tell me and I will add them! {{User|DKPetey99}} 14:18, 1 April 2011 (EDT)

@DKPetey99 not anymore she hasn't been a villain since Super Mario RPG {{User|Iggykoopa}}
:She usually a protagonist nowadays, but her last villain role was in Superstar Saga. {{User|Reversinator}}

And even that one was more based on love than evil and she was a good girls in that game as to {{User|Iggykoopa}}

What else should I add? I mean I appreciate everyone voting, but I've been editing this with '''''NO''''' help! {{User|DKPetey99}} 08:16, 3 April 2011 (EDT)

There are still errors such as in the items section Mini Mushrooms didn't debut until Mario Party 4 yet there listed as Debuting in Super mario Kart {{User|Iggykoopa}}

Also the game section is missing some of the spin offs yet has other from the same series which makes me ask why is this Article no longer under construction when it is missing so much and has errors {{User|Iggykoopa}}

@Iggykoopa, stop saying what small mistake there is, and do it yourself! {{User|DKPetey99}}

{{You do it's your featured article proposal im busy working on the species list {{User|Iggykoopa}}

:You haven't touched that list! I've been working on that for a long time! [[User:DKPetey99|DKPetey99]] 18:45, 4 April 2011 (EDT)
:BTW, if your opposing, and you don't touch the article, you shouldn't even vote!
::I touched it! Penguins seemed good enough to be on the list. Time to add some more. {{User|Magikrazy51}}
Dude i don't care what you say on this one because the fact of the matter is that im right and the article doesnt need deserve to be a featured article {{User|Iggykoopa}}

Everyone is allowed to vote, whether they have touched it or not. Just because you have nominated this article doesn't mean that everyone now has to help it get featured. Since you are concerned about this article, you can fix it up, while everyone else contributes to other articles that they care about. Many other articles need some work too. {{User|Fawfulfury65}}

I'm going to say the same thing I said when Mario Sports Mix was nominated: Finish the article, then feature it.

{{User|Tails777}}

@DKPetey's Removal: He said that it was incomplete. {{User|Yoshiwaker}}

Species list is done, please no one add to it, it may overflow! {{User|DKPetey99}} 12:12, 28 April 2011 (EDT)

'''@DKPetey''' We don't forget about construction templates. So many people do this... They nominate an article to be featured, when they forget about construction templates. {{User|Supremo78}}

'''@Fawfulfury65''' Under construction or not, it's a page that should be featured, as it's a main component to Mario. {{User|Jbsunshine124}}
'''[[User:Fire?! flower]]''': It's great! And missing information(I think).--[[User:Fire?! flower|Fire?! flower]] 17:49, 15 October 2011 (EDT)

‹s›This may just be my 3DS doing this, but some of the images are just coming up as their names rather than the pictures. {{User|Commander Code-8}}

If there's a reason for this, can someone explain why there are no game and watch titles in this article {{User|Commander Code-8}}‹s›

'''@Jbsunshine 124''' Being a main component of the Mario series doesn't make it worth being a featured article. Have you noticed that not even the Mario arrticle is featured? {{User|Commander Code-8}}