Editing MarioWiki:Featured articles/N1/Mii
From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then publish the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
| Latest revision | Your text | ||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
__NOTOC__ | __NOTOC__ | ||
===[[{{SUBPAGENAME}}]]=== | ===[[{{SUBPAGENAME}}]]=== | ||
{{FANOMSTAT | |||
|nominated=18:59, 23 June 2009 (EDT) | |||
|passed= | |||
}} | |||
==== Support ==== | ==== Support ==== | ||
#{{User|Yoshario}} - This article is in-depth and detailed, covers all Mario-appearances, and has images to support it. I think its ready to become featured. | #{{User|Yoshario}} - This article is in-depth and detailed, covers all Mario-appearances, and has images to support it. I think its ready to become featured. | ||
| Line 9: | Line 11: | ||
#{{User|Lu-igi board}} great article but the images are mostly poor. | #{{User|Lu-igi board}} great article but the images are mostly poor. | ||
#{{User|Pie Shroom}} This article is well written and deserves to be an FA. | #{{User|Pie Shroom}} This article is well written and deserves to be an FA. | ||
#{{User|BabyLuigiOnFire}}Now the picture is better, I'm on for it. | |||
#{{User|Mario64fanatic}} The article is well stated, for a character who is basiclly not a Mario character. | #{{User|Mario64fanatic}} The article is well stated, for a character who is basiclly not a Mario character. | ||
#{{User|McQueenMario}} - It's good now. | #{{User|McQueenMario}} - It's good now. | ||
#{{User|Platitudinous}} It has all of the info I need on Miis in the Mario series. | #{{User|Platitudinous}} It has all of the info I need on Miis in the Mario series. | ||
==== Oppose ==== | ==== Oppose ==== | ||
#{{user|Tucayo}} - As 2257 said in the Ganondorf nomination page, no articles that dont belong to the Mario series should be FA's | |||
#{{user|Edofenrir}} - I really fail to see why this article should be any better than many other non-featured articles. Plus, it is a mere list of Mii's appearances in the Mario series, and it's trivia section is filled with information, that could be merged into the main article. The fact about Miyamoto (2nd trivia) isn't verified with a source. There are yet many holes to fill in that article, so no support from me (n/o to the creators). | |||
==== Removal of Opposes ==== | ==== Removal of Opposes ==== | ||
'''Tucayo''' | |||
*{{User|Marioguy1}} - There is no reason for his vote other than seriesism (like racism but for series). There is no reason this article cannot be good even if it doesn't have to do with mario! | |||
==== Comments ==== | ==== Comments ==== | ||
I hate Miis, they are not even from the Marioverse! Ironnical that Mii will become an FA and Mario is not {{user|Tucayo}} | I hate Miis, they are not even from the Marioverse! Ironnical that Mii will become an FA and Mario is not {{user|Tucayo}} | ||
:Well, if you recall that FAs are about the article's quality rather than its topic, it's not that ironical anymore. {{User|Time Q}} | :Well, if you recall that FAs are about the article's quality rather than its topic, it's not that ironical anymore. {{User|Time Q}} | ||
::The other "first picture" was [[: | ::The other "first picture" was [[:Image:Mii.png]]. Should it be switched to that? –{{User|Yoshario}} | ||
:::There was another one? Whoa, that one doesn't have random black lines all through it. Yes, switch it! {{User|Marioguy1}} | :::There was another one? Whoa, that one doesn't have random black lines all through it. Yes, switch it! {{User|Marioguy1}} | ||
@Marioguy1: I think Tucayo has a point here: FAs shouldn't be just extraordinary well written, they should be representative for the Marioverse, the very topic this wiki is about. I'm not saying that the whole FA nomination should be canceled because of this, but you shouldn't classify Tucayo's vote as invalid, for he at least has a point that needs to be thought about. - {{user|Edofenrir}} | @Marioguy1: I think Tucayo has a point here: FAs shouldn't be just extraordinary well written, they should be representative for the Marioverse, the very topic this wiki is about. I'm not saying that the whole FA nomination should be canceled because of this, but you shouldn't classify Tucayo's vote as invalid, for he at least has a point that needs to be thought about. - {{user|Edofenrir}} | ||
