| Latest revision |
Your text |
| Line 1: |
Line 1: |
| __NOTOC__ | | __NOTOC__ |
| ===[[{{#titleparts:{{PAGENAME}}||3}}]]=== | | ===[[{{#titleparts:{{PAGENAME}}||3}}]]=== |
| {{FANOMFAIL | | {{FANOMSTAT |
| |nominated= 11:42, 20 October 2021 | | |nominated= 11:42, 20 October 2021 |
| |lastedit=11:42, 19 December 2021 | | |passed=<!--When it is 5-0, put the time (such as 12:10, 11 December 2012) of the fifth support/removal of last oppose by copying it from the history of the page.--> |
| |nosupport=false
| |
| }} | | }} |
| | | This article is in excellent shape and it is in Wikipedia format, so it should be featured. |
| ==== Support ==== | | ==== Support ==== |
| #{{User|OhoJeeOnFire}} This article is in excellent shape and it is in Wikipedia format, so it should be featured. | | #[[User: OhoJeeOnFire|OhoJeeOnFire]] Per This. |
| #{{User|Bubbasour11}} It has links to most of the sub-species.
| |
| #{{User|CBFan5}} Overall, this article is pretty good. It has few contractions, and its format is great. Therefore, it should be featured.
| |
| #{{User|FanOfYoshi}} Per all
| |
| | |
| ==== Oppose ==== | | ==== Oppose ==== |
| #{{User|Ray Trace}} Article simply isn't ready yet. Compare it to [[Banzai Bill]], and much more information can be used for its sections, such as level specific appearances and perhaps can use a game-by-game evolution of its appearances in a section for general information. I could do a more specific breakdown if you like but as of now, I don't support.
| |
| #{{User|Swallow}} Per Ray Trace.
| |
| #{{User|Hewer}} Per all.
| |
| #{{User|BananaBarrels}} In my opinion, the article is a bit too long to be featured. Featured Articles should be of a decent length, but newcomers should be able to read an article short enough that they can get a basic idea of this wiki.
| |
| #{{User|Waluigi Time}} Per Ray Trace.
| |
|
| |
|
| ==== Removal of opposes ==== | | ==== Removal of opposes ==== |
| '''BananaBarrels'''
| |
| #{{User|OhoJeeOnFire}} Read Ray Trace’s comment.
| |
| #{{User|Archivist Toadette}} When it comes to size, long featured articles trump short ones.
| |
|
| |
|
| ==== Comments ==== | | ==== Comments ==== |
| Line 29: |
Line 16: |
|
| |
|
| How? Where? —-[[File: Doopliss.png|30px]] [[User: OhoJeeOnFire|OhoJeeOnFire]] ([[User talk:OhoJeeOnFire|talk]]) 11:49, October 20, 2021 (EDT) | | How? Where? —-[[File: Doopliss.png|30px]] [[User: OhoJeeOnFire|OhoJeeOnFire]] ([[User talk:OhoJeeOnFire|talk]]) 11:49, October 20, 2021 (EDT) |
|
| |
| Never mind. —-[[File: Doopliss.png|30px]] [[User: OhoJeeOnFire|OhoJeeOnFire]] ([[User talk:OhoJeeOnFire|talk]]) 11:51, October 20, 2021 (EDT)
| |
|
| |
| Here's my issues with the article, using [[Banzai Bill]] as a point of reference:
| |
| *Article lacks a sound cue for when a Bill gets shot out of a cannon. This is an extremely important cue for this enemy, as it often gets fired from off-screen.
| |
| *''Super Mario Bros.'': Where exactly does it appear in World 5-1? And what other levels does it have subsequent appearances in? What levels where it's fired from a cannon, and fired off-screen?
| |
| *No mention of ''[[Super Mario All-Stars]]'' when that warrants a section header.
| |
| *No mention of ''[[Super Mario Bros. Special]]'', except in appearances and nav template.
| |
| *''Super Mario Bros.: The Lost Levels'': What levels does the Bullet Bill appear in? Also needs a reference to [[All Night Nippon Super Mario Bros.]]
| |
| *''Super Mario Bros. 3'': Needs level specific appearances, also detailing where it appears in the level.
| |
| *''Super Mario World'': This is what the sections in this article should look like, where it details their appearances level-by-level, especially for some that appear in some special rooms and whatnot.
| |
| *''Super Mario Land 2: 6 Golden Coins'': Needs level specific appearances, also detailing where it appears in the level.
| |
| *''Super Mario 64'': It's mostly complete but it doesn't mention how they eventually disappear if shot out for too long. Could use a comparison pic for it and the remake.
| |
| *''Super Mario Sunshine'': Needs level specific appearances, also detailing where it appears in the level.
| |
| *''New Super Mario Bros.'': Their level specific appearances could be further detailed.
| |
| *''Super Mario Galaxy'': Needs level specific appearances, also detailing where it appears in the level.
| |
| *''New Super Mario Bros. Wii'': Level appearances can use expansion.
| |
| *''Super Mario Galaxy 2'': Needs level specific appearances, also detailing where it appears in the level.
| |
| *''Super Mario 3D Land'': Needs level specific appearances, also detailing where it appears in the level.
| |
| *''New Super Mario Bros. 2'': Needs level specific appearances, also detailing where it appears in the level.
| |
| *''New Super Mario Bros. U'': Needs level specific appearances, also detailing where it appears in the level.
| |
| *''Super Mario 3D World'': Needs level specific appearances, also detailing where it appears in the level.
| |
| (you get the general idea of the platformer appearances)
| |
| *''Paper Mario'': Needs images.
| |
| *''Game & Watch Gallery'': Linked section headers are not allowed, so those need to be edited out.
| |
| *''Mario Party'': Needs images
| |
| *''Super Princess Peach'': Section badly needs a rewrite, has remnants of old wiki writing.
| |
| *Article has repetitive "this appears again, once again, reappears" when it should be written to be less repetitive. Bullet Bills are a series staple, it's known they'll make a lot of appearances.
| |
| *Bullet Bills appear in Roy Koopa's move in Dr. Mario World.
| |
|
| |
| This isn't all of it, I kinda fell after I was done with the platformer sections so...yeah now you get why I have issues with this nomination. {{User:Ray Trace/sig}} 22:09, October 21, 2021 (EDT)
| |
|
| |
| @Banana Barrels: That's not the point of featured articles. The point is to showcase the best articles on the wiki, not necessarily to introduce people new to it. {{User:Ray Trace/sig}} 04:12, November 5, 2021 (EDT)
| |
